3 ms·
Is a baby boom being considered a positive here? I would think that an increase in consumption from a population increase is not a good thing when living an non
by giantg2 5y ago
Is a baby boom being considered a positive here? I would think that an increase in consumption from a population increase is not a good thing when living an non-sustainable lifestyle.
- lowkey_ 5y agoDan Price being sketchy aside, yes, people feeling financially comfortable enough to produce babies is a positive thing. It's the most fundamental purpose we have as humans.
- giantg2 5y agoBut is it responsible, assuming the concerns around consumption and climate change?
- rflec028 5y agoIf you think it's a problem, don't do it yourself.
- giantg2 5y agoIs that what you tell people for all problems/actions?
- lowkey_ 5y agoYes! Human ingenuity will either solve climate change, or it won't, in which case we're either going to die or live a hard existence on another planet. If anything, the more children there are, the higher the odds that those in the next generation will be able to come up with solutions to climate change. This is all putting aside the basic argument that it's our most fundamental purpose. If we stop reproducing, humanity is extinct within a ~hundred years.
- Jensson 5y agoNo amount of technical development can keep up with exponential increase in resource usage. Just giving western living standards long term to everyone we have on earth today is a daunting task, adding even more is just insanity. And no, adding more people until everyone has to live a poor destitute life wont make people more creative.
- lowkey_ 5y ago> No amount of technical development can keep up with exponential increase in resource usage. People having children doesn't mean exponential increase in population. The US has an average children per family of 1.93 as of 2019, which actually means the population will shrink. > adding more people until everyone has to live a poor destitute life wont make people more creative This is a common fallacy that wealth is a fixed pie, and adding more people into the equation will make existing people poorer. This isn't true — wealth is created!
- rmk 5y agoThe solution to a non-sustainable lifestyle is not to stop having children. There seems to be a misguided Malthusian thought process that appears to be taking hold amongst younger people of childbearing years in this department. If you do not have the right amount of population growth, you will have demographic time bombs explode in your face, such as the one China will be facing in the coming decades. There needs to be a decent ratio of working, productive people to nonproductive people in any society that hopes to take care of its older citizens.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't see how it is misguided. We don't know how many people the world can sustainably maintain from a resource consumption standpoint and the carbon emissions tied to it. It's misguided to believe that there are no constraints. Your population growth point seems to imply a misguided idea. With automation, it's possible the population can stagnate or even shrink.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoIt's misguided in the sense that people in developing countries that don't have the leisure time to ponder the future of the Earth will be having kids, regardless of whether you do or not. If you want to go ahead and not perform your one biological imperative because you think you're saving the planet, that's your prerogative. But don't think it's going to make a tangible difference.
- giantg2 5y agoWho said anything about developing countries? The developed countries have the largest impact on a per capita basis, and thus the larger difference for an individual choice. "If you want to go ahead and not perform your one biological imperative" It seems you are implying that we should follow our biological imperatives without question, and that there is only one. There are several biological imperatives. If we follow them without question then we risk things like war (territorialism), rape (reproduction), etc. Its only because we question these imperatives that we are able to place restraints on them. Also, I don't think I'll save the planet by not having a bunch of kids. But at least by not having them I wont be bringing them into a life of pain and suffering.