3 ms·
> solving the housing issue What is this mythical 'housing issue' we hear so much about. A housing shortage? I dont see that, if you want a house, you walk int
by blitzar 5y ago
> solving the housing issue
What is this mythical 'housing issue' we hear so much about. A housing shortage? I dont see that, if you want a house, you walk into one of the estate agents, they are every second shop on the high street, and you give them money and they give you a house.
'But I want a 12 bedroom house on Park Lane with a 50 foot garden for 100k.' Yes there are issues there.
- jlokier 5y agoOne does not give money one doesn't have. For many people, 100% of the available properties in that estate agent's window are too expensive, not just the 12 bedroom places. These people will probably never be able to buy anywhere useful, and they are not renting the places in the window either. They rely on a less formally advertised market of lower price rentals. Then there are the people for whom a maxed out mortgage would only just cover the bottom rung prices if they could get such a mortgage, but they can't so they have to rent, perversely at a monthly price higher than the mortgage would be. They don't gain equity for their payments, which harms their financial and housing security later in life, and limits their access to other credit. They don't know what they will do at retirement when they can no longer afford the rent, which is currently 50% of their income. Then there are a few people who can afford the not-bottom prices. These people mostly already have a home, and are a minority. For the first two groups, renting is their only option, and renting in some countries sucks for many reasons. Insecurity, no location stability (random evictions are common and new options limited), no equity, regular home inspections, often not even allowed to decorate, no home improvements (solar, windows, kitchen etc).
- blitzar 5y ago> One does not give money one doesn't have. Off base opener, becuase that is exactly how buying property works in the majority of cases. Ohterwise we agree the problem is people are too poor, it is affordability that is the issue. There are plenty of houses, but not enough money. Building more studio flats in battersea that cost 750k solves the 'supply' issue, but it is supply that is really useless.
- jlokier 5y agoTreat it as "have (access to)", because that's obviously what was meant. I think it's not really about not enough money, because if everyone at the bottom had more money, prices at the bottom would increase to compensate, ensuring it stays just out of reach for many, and just at the edge of achievable for others. I'm not against injections of money, I think it's a good idea. But I don't expect it would solve the housing affordability problem, unfortunately.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSo my solutions to the problem you dont thik exists would probably make that house more expensive, because the value of the land underneath it is the main driver of price increases, and the person who owns the home does little to drive that, but reaps all the benefit. This distorts the market and forces people into buying property. If someone could just rent for a few years then they probably would, and then we could write laws that support rrenters and owning and renting buildings would just be a boring business. Instead, people do the sums and realise they are rewarded for buying that property and getting the free money as the area is developed. So we are all nudged into buying property and then we get laws that benefit people with property. If there was a land value tax, then people living in low density homes in amazing locations in cities would be taxed out and high density homes would be built in their place. These would likely still be expensive, but by splitting the tax among several people, would be able to afford the land tax.
- blitzar 5y agoThe result of the tax you are suggesting almost already exists. As the 5 floor town house gets to a price tag of 10mil the owner realises that it is easier to find 5 people who will pay 2mil for a 1 floor appartment than one person who wants a 10mil house. This works for a while, but we are now at a point where 100's of prime location studio appartments are built and the price tag is the best part of $1mil. Here we hit the mismatch of affordability and function - if you have a mil for a property, you probably dont want a studio appartment. If you do want a studio appartment in central city, you probably only have 1/2 the money you need (if you are lucky). The only real function of a land tax would be to depreciate the present value of the land by the future libaility of those taxes. In theory this just changes the cash flows, but also might have a dampening effect on growth which would be desireable / undesirable.