6 ms·
> Also consider that there are no good audio drivers for Linux (like Asio for example) so you're almost forced to stay in windows or Mac... This is false. > I
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> Also consider that there are no good audio drivers for Linux (like Asio for example) so you're almost forced to stay in windows or Mac...
This is false.
> Imagine if they applied something similar to a git versioning system to music projects.
People have done this. Using git itself is a little problematic because it is very line-oriented and most project file formats for DAWs are not.
Regarding plugins, I know that I'm not the only lead developer of a DAW who, if they possibly could, would refuse to support plugins entirely. The problem is that most users want more functionality than a DAW itself could feasibly provide (they also sometimes like to use the same functionality (plugin) in different DAWs or different workflows).
There are things close to DAW functionality that have a CLI (such as ecasound). You can also run plugins from the command line by using standalone plugin hosts. You can use oscsend(1) to control plugins inside several different plugin hosts.
It sounds to me as if you've worked with a relatively small number of DAWs on only Windows and macOS and are not really aware of the breadth or depth of the "field".
- dewert 5y ago> > Also consider that there are no good audio drivers for Linux (like Asio for example) so you're almost forced to stay in windows or Mac... > This is false. This was my immediate thought as well. Not sure what level we're talking here, so sorry if I'm addressing the wrong part of the stack, but JACK on Linux has been a great experience for me in terms of latency and ease of use. I run into way more day-to-day problems on Windows. What feature specifically are you missing on Linux? Re: plugins, DAWs with VST sandboxing are great. I use Bitwig, and I've never lost work due to a plugin crash.
- noahadavis 5y agoAnd now that we have PipeWire, getting low latency audio is extremely easy too.
- lolcat_cowsay 5y agoJACK is also really easy to setup with PipeWire.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoPipeWire is love. PipeWire is life. Doing post on a documentary whilst using PipeWire. Linux for audio is finally there.
- officeplant 5y ago>Re: plugins, DAWs with VST sandboxing are great. I use Bitwig, and I've never lost work due to a plugin crash. Exactly, the original thread reads as someone who hasn't touched a modern DAW from the last 8 years or so. Even Renoise has multicore support with sandboxed plugins so one of my ancient free shitty vsts doesn't bring down the whole system.
- wwweston 5y ago> This is false. Suffice it to say that it's non-obvious to me where to start to go about getting a stable and mobile (ie laptop) experience. I'd like nothing better than to receive a response that makes me feel sheepish for thinking that Linux is the problem, and if anyone can give out good pointers I'd imagine you can.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWell, first of all let's start with noting that hardware can prevent you from ever getting a stable response. Some explanatory background on that here: https://manual.ardour.org/setting-up-your-system/the-right-computer-system-for-digital-audio/ https://manual.ardour.org/setting-up-your-system/the-right-c... On Linux you do not (as a rule) install device drivers for your devices. They come with the system or they (generally) don't exist. I know of only one audio interface manufacturer who ever maintained their own drivers outside of the kernel tree (i.e. not part of mainstream Linux) and even they have had their drivers integrated now. Next, since you're on a laptop, you're relieved of the unenviable task of figuring out whether to use a PCI(.) bus device or a USB interface. USB is your only option. The good news here is that any USB audio interface that works with an iPad also works on Linux. Why? Because iPad doesn't allow driver installs, and so manufacturers have been forced to make sure their devices work with a generic USB audio class device driver, just like they need to do on Linux. With very few exceptions, you can more or less buy any contemporary USB audio interface these days, just plug it into your Linux laptop (or desktop or whatever), and it will work. What can be an issue is a lack of ability to configure the internals of the device. Some manufacturers e.g. MOTU have taken the delightful step of doing this by putting an http server on the device, and thus allowing you to configure it from any browser on anything at all. Others have used just generic USB audio class features, allowing it to be controlled from the basic Linux utilities for this sort of thing. And still more continue to only provide Windows/macOS-native configuration utilities. For some devices, dedicated Linux equivalents exist. Best place to check on that would be to start at linuxmusicians.com and use their forums. Beyond the hardware, it's hard to give more advice because it depends on the experience/workflow you want to use. If you're looking for something Ableton Live-like, Bitwig is likely your best option. If you want a more traditional linear timeline-y DAW ala ProTools, Logic etc., then Reaper, Ardour or Mixbus would probably be good choices. If you want to do software modular, VCV Rack is head and shoulders above anything else (and runs on other platforms too). There's a very large suite of LV2 plugins on Linux. Stay away from CALF even though they look pretty. The others range from functional to excellent. Your rating will depend on your workflow and aesthetics. You will not find libre plugins that do what deeply-DSP-oriented proprietary plugins do (e.g. Izotope, Melodyne), though you may be satisfied with things in the same ballpark (e.g. Noise Repellent and AutoTalent). There's a growing body of VST3 plugins for Linux. If you're looking for amazing (non-libre) synths, U-he has all (?) their products available in a perpetual beta for Linux. Great stuff. There are plenty of libre synths too. There's an LV2 version of Vital called Vitalium which is more stable than the VST3 version; this synth has had rave reviews from many different reviewers. Sample libraries are a problem because most of them are created for Kontakt. You have a choice of running Kontakt inside a Windows VST adapter (e.g. yabridge) or using other formats such as SFZ or DecentSampler, both of which have both free and libre players. pianobook.co.uk has hundreds of somewhat interesting sample libraries, many (but definitely not even most) of them available in DS format. Hope this helps.
- stevefolta 5y ago> Using git itself is a little problematic because it is very line-oriented and most project file formats for DAWs are not. Ardour and Reaper use plaintext project formats that work well with Git, at least for basic versioning. > Regarding plugins, I know that I'm not the only lead developer of a DAW who, if they possibly could, would refuse to support plugins entirely. The problem is that most users want more functionality than a DAW itself could feasibly provide (they also sometimes like to use the same functionality (plugin) in different DAWs or different workflows). I think the answer to this would be something like Reaper's "JS" plugins, which are written in a small compiled language and distributed as source code. Compared to "JS", it would need to: 1) be open source; 2) be a better language; and 3) support pretty skeuomorphic graphics ('cause people seem to really want that in their plugins). Ardour seems to be working on something like this using Lua (don't know about the graphics, or if the plugins could be supported in other DAWs).
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoArdour uses XML for its session format, which is not a line-oriented format. Git can handle it, most of the time, but is not ideal. Something that groks the concept of XML nodes would do a better job (i.e. less conflicts duing merge resolution). Ardour comes with a small set of basic "curated" plugins written in C or C++, that are "blessed" by us. Writing DSP plugins in Lua is also possible, but generally discouraged and, as you guessed, you can't provide a dedicated GUI for them, nor can they be used elsewhere (same limitation as Reaper's Jesusonic plugins). However, even if those details were improved, the idea that a DAW manufacturer is going to be able to supply the precise EQ that demanding users want, let alone noise reduction, polyphonic pitch correction, and so, so much more, strikes me as unrealistc.
- tialaramex 5y agoNote that git's diffs and merges are customisable. If somebody wants to put in the effort for a particular format, they can write tools that perform these two specific tasks and git can be told "Here are the tools for this repo" and deliver the benefits of improved tooling. It's definitely possible that could be worth doing for a DAW if used with git. Git even understands that it's possible that you can neatly summarise a change in text (for display e.g. as part of the change log) but that summary is not actionable (so the data stored to implement that change is different), e.g. I believe git's man pages provide an example showing how you can get EXIF from a JPEG so that your git tools say the change was from "Photo of Pam and mummy" to "Cropped image of Pam" when actually it's a huge binary data change that is unintelligible to reader.
- tomc1985 5y ago> Regarding plugins, I know that I'm not the only lead developer of a DAW who, if they possibly could, would refuse to support plugins entirely. The problem is that most users want more functionality than a DAW itself could feasibly provide (they also sometimes like to use the same functionality (plugin) in different DAWs or different workflows). Honestly the sound quality of most DAWs' built-in effects and synths are garbage. Even the effects section of most VST synths is bad! Best to allow plugins rather than trying to reinvent the wheel; you'll have to pry my beloved serum/iZotope/u-he/softube plugins out of my cold dead hands Also, the "sometimes" is an understatement. Anyone who's been doing this a while likely to be pretty invested in the plugins they have. I would say the majority of working musicians that use DAWs work this way
- lavabiopsy 5y agoI think you are misinterpreting that comment, I believe the idea there would be to have built-in functionality that would be equal or surpassing to those plugins, possibly by merging the actual plugins with the DAW. Of course doing that in a way that will please everyone is a lot harder to do than it sounds and is likely not even feasible, but the supposed benefit would be that the DAW could better integrate that functionality and would not have to deal with a lot of the reliability issues that exist with plugins. (Disclaimer: I agree with the GP comment in the sense that dropping plugins from DAWs would be a great thing to do if it were at all possible, but it currently really isn't)
- tomc1985 5y agoThe thing is, doing something that would 'be equal or surpassing' is pretty much impossible at an acceptable cost. You can probably write something that's 'good enough' that some people might be happy with -- that is what most all-in-one DAWs do -- but the beauty of the plugin system is that you can delegate development duties for those components to someone who a company who specializes in effects, for example. Or even a specific effect! There are developers who just write synths, or just write reverbs, or whatever. And we want to use their products!
- 5y ago