3 ms·
> researchers discovered what is known as an inverse square relation between the number of people in a given urban location and the distance they traveled to ge
by kazinator 5y ago
> researchers discovered what is known as an inverse square relation between the number of people in a given urban location and the distance they traveled to get there
The found that the frequency of visiting a place, multiplied by the distance traveled (rf) forms a stable parameter which can be used as a single dependent variable. There is then an (approximate, statistically fitted) inverse square law involving this combined variable. Or two square laws.
If we hold frequency constant (say "once a month" or whatever), then the number of people visiting some place drops off inverse square with distance. If 400 people are willing to visit some place once a month that is 10 km away, about 100 once-a-month visitors will come from 20 km away.
Or if we hold distance constant: if 400 people are visiting some place that is 10 km away once a month, about 100 will be visiting twice a month.
> It accurately predicts, for instance, that the number of people coming from two kilometers away five times per week will be the same as the number coming from five kilometers twice a week.
It doesn't predict this; rather this frequency-distance product being a stable parameter is a discovery from the data, on which the formula is then based. I.e this frequency-distance product becomes a model assumption baked into the formula, not a prediction.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- toss1 5y agoGood description — I also thought that the example was off. I'd be very interested to see how this law holds for travel destinations, both from the POV of the destination (national park, ski area, attraction), and from the POV of occasional travelers.
- m0hit 5y agoSome of the specific examples in the article seemed off to me too. However, I did love the book Scale by Geoffrey West who is one of the authors of the paper discussed in the article. At the very least, the book is a great introduction to the many different aspects that scale up with city size.
- yummypaint 5y agoI interpret the inverse square law as being the direct result of the area of a circle scaling as the square of the radius. Imagine dividing a given circle overlaid on a city into fixed sized area units. If you randomly visit a unit, the probability of visiting a particular unit scales as 1/area. Note that this derivation is essentially identical to showing that electric field falls off as 1/(r^2). In that case the area refers to the area of a sphere through which field lines must pass.