3 ms·
I'm not sure that the majority of students will "get used to" a grading system where given their aptitude they will be unlikely to score more than 30% - particu
by notahacker 15y ago
I'm not sure that the majority of students will "get used to" a grading system where given their aptitude they will be unlikely to score more than 30% - particularly when their reward for thorough preparation is likely to be a mere couple of percentage points on top of a dismal looking score. If anything is likely to condition the median person into scraping the minimum necessary requirement it's drawing attention to how far ahead their smarter peers are. Smarter peers who have more outlets for demonstrating their aptitude other than dwarfing the average test scores, and who are probably smart enough to realise their test scores are a poor proxy for real life success anyway.
Skewing the scoring still doesn't make exams resemble real life; one doesn't analyse their successes in percentage-points-from-perfection. If we did, most people would have a serious inferiority complex. Interviewers who screen out unexceptional candidates are normal; those who waste insufficiently exceptional candidates time repeatedly proving they're not creative or excellent enough for the job might even be considered sadistic. There's a difference between failing 90% of interviews and staring blankly at the interviewer as I fail to answer 90% of the questions, knowing I'll have to repeat the experience until someone appreciates the 10% I get right.
Likewise compensation packages expressed as a percentage of most productive employees compensation won't garner much interest, even though incentive structures within conventional companies is usually skewed heavily in the favour of less productive employees.
If I were running a college, I'd probably accept the reality that job sorting is one of the main reasons my students value the course...