4 ms·
This article also has long form responses. I'd love to see a reasoned contrary response.
by peteradio 5y ago
This article also has long form responses. I'd love to see a reasoned contrary response.
- toolz 5y agoThere already is one response from 2 MDs and one MPH with citations. Glad you pointed out the long-form response section as it was a good read.
- blacksqr 5y agoThe contrary argument is reasonably well-stated within the article, it seems to be mostly a matter of what you assess to be the greatest risks going forward as to which argument you think is more valid. After glancing at the endnotes, it seems that the bulk of the scientific references examining natural immunity date from before the delta variant established itself.
- mcguire 5y agoAnd many of them were concerned about prioritization during the rollout, when vaccine doses were scarce.
- rpmisms 5y agoThe reasoned answer is politics. One side of the aisle committed to a message before they had all the data. The other side did this too. Now it's too politically costly to change any of those positions, no matter how much anyone claims to "follow the science".