6 ms·
Wage rises without solving the housing issue is only going to raise house prices further. There's a bunch of potential solutions, but no-one directly benefits
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Wage rises without solving the housing issue is only going to raise house prices further.
There's a bunch of potential solutions, but no-one directly benefits from them in the short term.
Any attempt to fix it will be met with sob stories about old ladies in multi-million dollar homes being "forced out of their homes".
So we'll all just sit and watch as things slowly spin out of control.
- Reason077 5y ago> "Wage rises without solving the housing issue is only going to raise house prices further." House prices aren't that tightly linked to incomes. House prices are more strongly influenced by interest rates and availability of credit. And, of course, supply/demand fundamentals (ie: population change vs. number of housing units in an area).
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI wasn't making a claim about what impacted house prices the most. If I was, then I'd say a system where the government basically gives you free money/tax breaks if you buy a home, is the root cause behind the things you mentioned which then drives house prices. The point is, without fixing that issue, you can't solve it by wage rises. People who don't even want homes are buying them, either as outright investments that they can sit on for years, or as something they also live in, but need to treat as an investment, rather than a home.
- pjc50 5y ago> the government basically gives you free money/tax breaks if you buy a home Such as? MIRAS was abolished 20 years ago. Homes are arguably under-taxed (no US style property tax), but that's not really a "break".
- rjsw 5y agoThere is Help to Buy [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help_to_Buy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help_to_Buy
- xyzzyz 5y agoWhich is not free money from the government. It’s a loan.
- regularfry 5y agoIt's a loan for the buyer. It looks a lot like free money to the seller, which is where the problem is.
- Loughla 5y agoIs availability of credit not linked to income?
- antattack 5y agoHome prices could be linked to wages through renting. I have often seen mortgage loan monthly payment compared to monthly rent as a reason a buy instead of renting.
- FartyMcFarter 5y ago> House prices aren't that tightly linked to incomes. House prices are more strongly influenced by interest rates and availability of credit. I believe banks in the UK don't lend you more than 4.5x - 5.5x of your income, regardless of interest rates.
- postingawayonhn 5y agoIncreased income means increased servicing ability and therefore banks granting higher loans.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoOld ladies in multi-million dollar homes is largely a myth. Sure, there are some of them. But it's absurd to think this is anywhere near the majority. Short Term rentals make up <2% of the market (almost everywhere beside vacation towns) - and they are not a major cause of problems (outside of vacation towns). Multi-million dollar homes are <1% of the market (basically everywhere). Old ladies living in these homes is a fraction of the total homes. These are just excuses. These aren't real problems. The real problem is artificially low interest rates, artificial scarcity caused by NIMBYism, low downpayments (backed by Fannie & Freddie), tax breaks for home owners but not for renters, high income taxes, low property taxes, etc... The vast majority of homeowners are just everyday regular homeowners, almost twice as many as everyday regular landlords. Little old ladies and short term rental operators make up <3% of the market. You can only blame them for much.
- mateo411 5y agoDo Fannie and Freddie underwrite mortgages in the UK?
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoNo - but the problem is the same. You have 5% downpayments (instead of 3.5% in the US), and mortgage-backed securities. From my understanding, it appears there is NOT a government agency backing them, though. I don't think the 3.5% downpayment market be very big in the US if not for Fannie and Freddie (it basically doesn't exist outside of conventional loans Fannie & Freddie will buy). I don't know how big the market is in the UK - maybe it's not much of an issue? I'd love to hear from someone who knows more about this part of the UK market.
- carom 5y agoI don't think the 3.5% down payment market is very big. >Between July 2019 and June 2020, the average down payment for a home amounted to 12% of the home value. In the first three months of 2021, 48% of home buyers made a down payment of at least 20% of the home value. 21% of home buyers in that same period made an all-cash purchase. [1] It sounds like 69% are >= 20% down or all cash. I don't think enabling lower income access to housing is hurting our housing market at all. 1. https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-down-payment-house/ https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-down-paymen...
- blitzar 5y ago> solving the housing issue What is this mythical 'housing issue' we hear so much about. A housing shortage? I dont see that, if you want a house, you walk into one of the estate agents, they are every second shop on the high street, and you give them money and they give you a house. 'But I want a 12 bedroom house on Park Lane with a 50 foot garden for 100k.' Yes there are issues there.
- jlokier 5y agoOne does not give money one doesn't have. For many people, 100% of the available properties in that estate agent's window are too expensive, not just the 12 bedroom places. These people will probably never be able to buy anywhere useful, and they are not renting the places in the window either. They rely on a less formally advertised market of lower price rentals. Then there are the people for whom a maxed out mortgage would only just cover the bottom rung prices if they could get such a mortgage, but they can't so they have to rent, perversely at a monthly price higher than the mortgage would be. They don't gain equity for their payments, which harms their financial and housing security later in life, and limits their access to other credit. They don't know what they will do at retirement when they can no longer afford the rent, which is currently 50% of their income. Then there are a few people who can afford the not-bottom prices. These people mostly already have a home, and are a minority. For the first two groups, renting is their only option, and renting in some countries sucks for many reasons. Insecurity, no location stability (random evictions are common and new options limited), no equity, regular home inspections, often not even allowed to decorate, no home improvements (solar, windows, kitchen etc).
- blitzar 5y ago> One does not give money one doesn't have. Off base opener, becuase that is exactly how buying property works in the majority of cases. Ohterwise we agree the problem is people are too poor, it is affordability that is the issue. There are plenty of houses, but not enough money. Building more studio flats in battersea that cost 750k solves the 'supply' issue, but it is supply that is really useless.