6 ms·
As much as the article wishes to expunge the concept it's a balance disorder all it is actually claiming is an alternative primary explanation for said imbalanc
by zamadatix 5y ago
As much as the article wishes to expunge the concept it's a balance disorder all it is actually claiming is an alternative primary explanation for said imbalance. The idea you should not only eat less but healthier (particularly fewer carbohydrates) is not a groundbreaking concept that just came out in the fight of obesity but is the key discovery in this "new paradigm".
The article draws up comparison to defining "wealthy" as "People get rich because they take in more money than they spend." but that's actually a perfectly fine definition of wealthy which explains what it is. Similarly "is an energy imbalance between calories consumed and calories expended" is a fantastic definition of obesity. What the article actually argues against is again the idea the primary causes of imbalance are portion sizes, advertising, culture, abundance, and so on rather processed foods and quality of diet changing the way the body processes and measures energy intake from food.
I agree heavily with the latter part but the it is still describing a consumption/expenditure balance issue. This research isn't replacing that rather trying to find more ways to combat the issue that may not be explored as much previously.
The other thing is intake reduction still works it's just much harder than it may need to be without a proper diet. The article quotes "To attribute obesity to “overeating” is as meaningful as to account for alcoholism by ascribing it to “overdrinking.”" as if that means alcoholism isn't an intake problem. It is, but the best way to fight the intake problem may not be just saying "drink less" and that's the type of thinking actually being proposed in the research.
- seph-reed 5y ago> but the best way to fight the intake problem may not be saying "drink less" and that's the type of idea actually being proposed in the research Somewhat comically, drinking more water is a great (as in easy / painless) way to combat both alcoholism and obesity. As well as a bunch of other health issues. I have no idea why we -- as humans -- don't just naturally drink the right amount of water.
- macintux 5y agoI grew up in a town with chronically terrible water; we used to joke about the many colors of the water in the school water fountains. So, I grew up drinking anything but water, and that's a habit that's stuck with me for my entire life.
- smohare 5y agoBecause we do? Most people are not chronically dehydrated, despite what a vocal minority would have you believe.
- seph-reed 5y ago> not chronically dehydrated Good job. Taking something to an extreme, just to straw-man it. I like the negative connotation on vocal minorities too. A+
- MichaelBosworth 5y ago> The article draws up comparison to defining "wealthy" as "People get rich because they take in more money than they spend." But that's actually a perfectly fine definition of wealthy which explains what it is. In that analogy, I believe, the article's point is that a definition has been masquerading as an explanation.
- zamadatix 5y agoIt is an explanation. The article does not propose an alternative to the imbalance explanation rather alternative focus of action to achieve said intake balance. It doesn't even say the existing method of action of enough flat intake reduction as an answer to the imbalance explanation (this action is what the article actually finds flawed not the explanation) won't work just that it is ineffective for the same amount of effort.
- sa1 5y agoThere are issues with the imbalance explanation. w.r.t obesity, the least wrong (and most explanatory) equation will relate calories going into adipose tissue, and calories being taken out of adipose tissue. Then another less wrong equation can relate calories absorbed by the digestive system and the calories burnt by the whole body. These are not the same equations as calories eaten vs calories burnt. And the quantities are not easily measured. Depending on exercise, and other potentially unknown environmental or genetic or other conditions, the body will put energy into tissue other than adipose tissue. Not all energy eaten will be absorbed. There was a recent study which showed how eating fructose expands the gut lining to be able to absorb much more nutrition. We do not know all the regulatory mechanisms that control absorption. Nor all mechanisms that control hunger. We're far from understanding all aspects of nutrition. The imbalance equations needs to be refined, if people are looking up to laws of physics to explain this matter.
- SeanAppleby 5y agoI believe the point is that the answer begs another question of "why". In their drinking example, alcoholism literally is overdrinking, but we accept that there is an underlying mechanism of physical and psychological dependency that exists outside of "they just consciously choose to drink all of the time and other people don't". At this point we generally recognize it as a disease with more nuance than "overdrinking". We recognize that there is a significant neurological component that is, at the point that they are an alcoholic, not under their total conscious control. Their subsconscious is pushing them to do things that the subconsciouses of people without the disease do not push for. Similarly, you could ask the question, why do some people eat significantly more than they burn? And it then seems not implausible that the problem could be similar to that of alcoholism, that some neurological system is calling for the body to ingest more food, whereas other people's appetites are fundamentally more accurately calibrated at a subconscious level. Much more speculative, but this would even seem to make sense from a wider lens. Almost our entire evolutionary lineage existed in a world of food scarcity, not overabundance. The selection pressure necessary to evolve a reliable safeguard against overeating would seem plausibly to not be old enough for that mechanism to have evolved to be as reliable and widespread as the one to prevent us from allowing ourselves to starve to death. The health problems of the 20th and 21st century are still incredibly new from the perspective of the mechanisms that created our instinctual impulses.
- rodarmor 5y agoDon't let the article put you off, the paper, no paywall, is much better and much more concrete: https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nqab270/6369073 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/aj...
- zamadatix 5y agoThanks, agreed the paper is miles better than the article! And to be honest an easier read... I almost wish it were the post instead.
- perl4ever 5y agoAs an adult, over about 15 years, I've gone from around 140 lbs (nearly clinically underweight) to almost 200 (slightly overweight), but in my case it's a well known side effect of medication I take. So is diabetes. I hate reading about this topic. I ask (rhetorically) how can it be that people pretend that normal weight is normally achieved through conscious choice? I like to think even if I had stayed the same weight my own life, I would have insight enough, but in my position, it's really clear to me. I have a thermostat, and ingesting chemicals changed the set point. People who keep on gaining weight until they die must have a broken thermostat set on "high". It can't be psychological. I feel like there's an awful conspiracy to gaslight people who are obese, because they can't be sure when someone says it's a matter of willpower, if they've always been that way. What to compare to? But everyone who has spent much or all of their life at a normal weight, should know it doesn't take supreme effort or fanatical accounting. It doesn't require not eating when you feel like you're starving. Empathy should come from properly understanding yourself, even if you can't be philosophically certain what it's like in others' shoes. People have free will, but you wouldn't tell a person who had a congenital inability to feel pain that they are responsible for injuring themselves, would you? You wouldn't construct a model of them as a person, as someone that enjoyed hurting themselves, right? Because conscious thought is not a replacement for automatic regulation.
- kayodelycaon 5y ago> you wouldn't tell a person who had a congenital inability to feel pain that they are responsible for injuring themselves, would you? I know people who absolutely do that. The logic is those people don’t have enough faith or care enough to be healed. People will go a very long way to blame a person who is suffering because it absolves them of responsibility.
- int3 5y agoI don't think it really matters how it's normally achieved. The point is that it can be achieved through conscious choice. I used to be slightly underweight when I was younger, and could eat endlessly with no consequence. These days I have to consciously watch my calories. It was a bit difficult at first, but I've gotten used to it. Conscious thought is not a replacement for automatic regulation in itself, but you can consciously work to form new habits.
- lkey 5y agoI feel like you might have just skimmed the article, as the points you make here were addressed directly, yet you don't take the points made head on. Quoting: 'Similarly "[Obesity] is an energy imbalance between calories consumed and calories expended" is a fantastic definition of obesity.' It isn't though: 'Obesity is a complex disease involving an excessive amount of /body fat/.' is how the Mayo cilic puts it. Not all energy imbalances in either direction result in a loss or gain of /fat/, which is the point the article is trying to make. I'll quote from the article: "Although researchers have rarely thought to control for energy intake in their experiments, when they did, testing whether their animals get fatter than lean controls even when eating as little or less food, they almost invariably report that they do. “These mice will make fat out of their food under the most unlikely circumstances, even when /half-starved/ [my italics],” as Jean Mayer wrote about obese mice he studied in the 1950s. This fundamental observation directly challenges the notion that obesity is caused by poorly regulated eating behavior." Quoting again: "as if that means alcoholism isn't an intake problem" Explaining why curing alcoholism isn't as simple 'stopping overdrinking' is just as tiresome as explaining why losing weight on a nationwide scale isn't as simple as 'eating less', as the article spills much ink to make clear.
- ghshephard 5y agoThe problem with this theory is that in clinically controlled lab studies, where both food and exertion are measured carefully, the weight gain (or loss) is almost 100% predictable based on the inputs of food, exercise, and Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR). Unless your hypothesis is that the weight gain/loss is going into something else other than /fat/? I'm guessing the reason nobody runs these studies is that it's solved science?
- lkey 5y ago"I'm guessing the reason nobody runs these studies is that it's solved science?" One of the article's main points is that the obsession with the calorie-only model (with the assumption that it's solved) has stymied even asking these fat-metabolism questions in the first place (outside of veterinary science, where they actively trying to make animals that get fat very quickly). But yes, your body is free to store/burn mass and energy in muscles, tissue, glycogen and whatnot if it chooses to store the excess at all. Of course if you force an environment of extreme depletion (like bootcamp as mentioned elsewhere), you body will get to its adipose tissue, but that's not going to solve the obesity epidemic. Most veterans get just as fat as the rest of the population after they leave the service. I personally can feel when my glycogen has been depleted when working out. Once it's gone I look a bit anemic and /pushing/ beyond certain limits becomes impossible. Normally it's a precursor to me entering ketosis, which pretty much guarantees I'll be burning fat or muscle only from then out.
- BizarroLand 5y agoWhat I took away from the article is that the standard diet is unhealthy, and that in some people it will cause their insulin production to spike, causing them to create more fat than a person who is not similarly affected. This then causes a snowball effect as their body craves food, energy, and nutrients that their body fat is effectively hijacking and preventing from getting where it needs to go, so the body sends more hunger signals so that enough food to satisfy you is consumed. As the fat increases, so too does the hunger, as fat cells also require maintenance calories. If this is true, (and it seems somewhat more plausible to me than just, "fat people are gut-stuffing pigs with no self control") then the solution to both the obesity crisis and the issue of over-eating is to find systems that shut down that cycle by either chemically manipulating the brain to not respond to the starvation signals caused by the fat cells, (probably effective but not healthy) or to modulate the diet so that the fat cells become the cells that have to beg for calories as the healthy cells get fed first somehow. Low-carb diets might be a first step to that second path as without carbohydrates to trigger insulin the fat cells will have a harder time taking in sugar. Mayhaps in the future we will learn more about the process and find a pill to make the insulin-carb-fat pathway from working as well as it does.