4 ms·
You don't seem to have made an actual argument there. You say: "the main argument against using real names always seems to boil down to someone waiting to shar
by jerf 15y ago
You don't seem to have made an actual argument there. You say:
"the main argument against using real names always seems to boil down to someone waiting to share something radical and controversial but not having it tied to their physical persona."
But you seem to just take it as a given that the idea that someone may want that, or that it may be a social good to protect that, is so bizarre and far out that an argument need not even be made, it's sufficient just to state it.
Well, I disagree. People should be able to say controversial things without any fear, and I can give you two enormous use cases: Democracy, and childhood. Democracies need to be able to freely debate things that are, by definition, controversial, to function at all. Children need to be able to say stupid things without them being tagged by them for the next fifty years.
I'm pretty confident you haven't got an argument more powerful than those... and "reidmain gets annoyed when he sees things (s)he thinks are stupid on the Internet" certainly isn't it.
- reidmain 15y agoIf it sounded like I was saying that anything someone wants to share anonymously is not worth being shared then I apologize. I see the need to be able to say something controversial and not fear reprisal. My main argument was that services like Facebook and Google+ are not geared towards that. It is a personal opinion but it is just how I see these sites being used. Things like EA Spouse definitely need to have the ability to exist on the internet. I just don't think that this woman would need to be able to share it on her Google+ account.