4 ms·
> It's not very diverse, is it? Why do you think India and China aren't diverse by themselves, and within themselves? India probably has more languages than al
by triceratops 5y ago
> It's not very diverse, is it?
Why do you think India and China aren't diverse by themselves, and within themselves? India probably has more languages than all of Europe. Would it be sensible to treat Europe (or even just the Schengen area) as one country, to "increase diversity"? I think that would be dumb. European countries are obviously very diverse and we see that more clearly because they're sovereign nations on a map. India and China are mega-countries and we fail to appreciate the diversity within.
> Basically no one from small nations would get a green card
Why would that happen? It would be a first-come-first-served system. If a person from a small nation applies, they'll get it at the same time as someone from a bigger nation who applied at the same time as them (modulo processing time variances).
- Veen 5y ago> Would it be sensible to treat Europe as one country Why would it? Europe isn't a country. India and China are countries. I fail to see your point. It's obviously more diverse if Chinese, Indians, Europeans, South Americans, Africans etc have a more or less equal chance, and that's what the current rules are supposed to provide. > It would be a first-come-first-served system So you think immigration status should be determined by whether someone gets their forms in on the 1st of January or not? I'm not sure that's entirely practical or fair. Perhaps a lottery would be more suitable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- triceratops 5y ago> Europe isn't a country. India and China are countries. I fail to see your point The point was in the rest of my comment. "Country" doesn't imply a homogenous, non-diverse group of people. And "diversity" is the purported reason for country-of-birth caps. > It's obviously more diverse if Chinese, Indians, Europeans, South Americans, Africans You said China and India are countries, then went on to compare them to continents. Surely you see the fallacy here. > someone gets their forms in on the 1st of January or not? I didn't say anything about the 1st of January (or any other date). "First-come-first-served" means applications are treated on their merits and processed in the order they arrived. If two people with the same application, but different country of birth, apply at the same time, they should have roughly same result in the same amount of time. That's not the case today. And I'm struggling to understand how a single queue is "unfair".
- monocasa 5y agoFor immigration purposes, since the EU is one open territory, it absolutely could make sense to treat it as a single entity if you buy into the base ideas here behind the caps.
- cyberlurker 5y agoThis is a really good point I had not considered before. I assume there is no policy to look for diversity within countries? That’s a shame, because probably many majority nationals from one country may apply and many minorities from those countries are unlikely to make it through.
- triceratops 5y agoThere isn't any "look for diversity" policy at all. The law simply establishes caps for the number of green cards issued to applicants based on country of birth. Country of birth is considered a proxy for diversity. If countries were generally of a similar size IRL, and had similar rates of migration to the US, it might work better.
- known 5y ago"Diverse society will fail" --Putnam https://archive.is/YXDP8 https://archive.is/YXDP8