5 ms·
I hope not, America takes enough Canadian health care workers. This is better for countries with socialized medicine. They don’t need any more incentives to go.
by dmix 5y ago
I hope not, America takes enough Canadian health care workers. This is better for countries with socialized medicine. They don’t need any more incentives to go.
- mlinhares 5y agoThis is, unfortunately, a win-lose game. If the US relaxed its requirements for nurses and doctors they could actually destroy the healthcare or many other countries. I've multiple friends that are experienced healthcare providers in Brazil that would love to move here but the rules are so draconic and complicated they have just given up. In a way I think it's good they have these requirements in place as that means people in Brazil won't be without doctors but its also pretty awful for me to say something like this given I DID move here to work, so I guess anyone else should have the same shot.
- arcticbull 5y ago> If the US relaxed its requirements for nurses and doctors they could actually destroy the healthcare or many other countries. Some medical professionals find the US healthcare system to be unconscionable. Some would move, some wouldn't. My doctor parents were offered jobs in the US but they refused on moral grounds - forgoing a somewhat higher salary - preferring to stay in Canada. The best outcome would be for them to move to the US, push down salaries (salaries in the US are something like 56% of all of healthcare spending) and that normalization would then stem the flow of foreign professionals while seriously benefitting Americans.
- cycrutchfield 5y agoDoctor salaries only comprise 8-9% of total healthcare spending in the US
- arcticbull 5y agohm you're right, I may have found a bad source.
- Veen 5y agoYeah, as a Brit I find it a little irksome when we pay for medical training for people who sod off to the U.S. as soon as they are qualified.
- clort 5y agoas another Brit, I wondered if it is the case that "we pay for medical training for people", so I looked it up https://www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/career-planning/study-and-training/considering-or-university/financial-support-university/financial-support-medical-and-dental-students https://www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/career-planning/study-and-t... and it seems that basically you can get a student loan for this for the first four years of your degree, then you might be eligible for a means tested bursary afterwards and a non means-tested £1000 grant. This scarcely counts as paying for medical training, in my opinion.
- Veen 5y agoThat's true, but the costs to the student are heavily subsidized. It costs about £220,000 to train a doctor for the first five years. The tuition fees paid by students with loans are less than a quarter of that, and don't include on-the-job training after the fifth year, which significantly inflates the cost. That's why doctors trained in the US typically graduate with around $240,000 in debt, while doctors trained in the UK owe a fraction of that.
- 908B64B197 5y agoWhy doesn't Canada just... compete?