7 ms·
Some of it is laudable, some of it is just political show, IMHO. Indeed, was there really any pressing need to reduce the residence requirement from 5 to 2 yea
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
Some of it is laudable, some of it is just political show, IMHO.
Indeed, was there really any pressing need to reduce the residence requirement from 5 to 2 years for garbage collectors?
To be meaningful this sort of programme should focus on people who have gone significantly above and beyond otherwise it just dilutes the act of getting citizenship. For instance legionnaires wounded in battle can apply for citizenship... Clearly not the same at all.
Let's not forget that next year is a major electoral year with both Presidential and general elections.
- CydeWeys 5y agoWhy all this gatekeeping around citizenship? Why is 5 years the right number and not 2? If someone is going to live in your country long term you may as well give them citizenship sooner so they feel fully bought in as early as possible. And France has made the calculation here that, yes, garbage collectors that worked straight through the entire pandemic are both (a) vital and (b) likely to stick around long-term at this rate, so may as well officially recognize that now.
- djbebs 5y agoBecause citizenship is supposed to be an important life changing decision with massive consequences at every level. The dilution of the meaning of citizenship is a massive tragedy.
- carlob 5y agoNo the life changing decision is to move to a new country to become a garbage collector. If you consider that the person collecting your garbage during a pandemic getting the same rights as you have by being born in the right side of the globe is a dilution of the meaning of citizenship I really don't know how to explain this to you any better.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sophacles 5y agoWhat purpose does citizenship actually have? Why does it need to be such a huge deal, and why is it's difficulty to attain (unless you accidentally got born there) such an important aspect of it?
- blululu 5y agoAccidentally got born somewhere is a very US centric perspective. Most countries do not follow Jus Soli births so this is not enough for citizenship. Citizenship is a matter belonging to a nation, past, present and future. Traditionally families have been the principle unit of human organization and citizenship acts as a generalization of the family unit to the nation as a whole. The answer to your question is pretty simple if you replace citizenship with family relations. This is perhaps changing as neoliberal ideology emphasizes individuals over families or collectives, but this is a separate matter.
- sophacles 5y agoYou have sort of explained "what is citizenship", complained about some random ideology, and completely failed to answer either of my questions. My country is NOT my family. My "nation" (whatever that is... a replacement for a tribe or something?) is NOT my family, nor even my extended clan. Why do I need to have "family" at a scale of millions of people, almost all of whom I will never encounter? A reminder of the still unanswered questions: Why does citizenship matter? What does any of that have to do with the difficulty of changing citizenship?
- bserge 5y agoLets you live in a place without worrying of being forced to go back home. Basically, you become a lazy local lol
- Zababa 5y agoCitizenship is here to slow down the rate of change of the country/culture/population, which is something many country want (and by country I mean either the people voting, or the people in power).
- anigbrowl 5y agoCool, make everyone apply for it them so that people don't get inflated ideas of their own worth just from having the good luck to be born within a jurisdiction.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThe idea is that citizenship may be granted after a person has fully settled and demonstrated that they have integrated in society, including through fluency in language and culture. I think 5 years is a fair period for this to happen and for a person to also decide that this is going their 'forever' country. If the requirements are too low then national identity no longer means anything. There can of course be exceptions but an exception should require something exceptional. > garbage collectors that worked straight through the entire pandemic Same as everyone else. The pandemic has not changed their job. Compare this with front line health workers in overcrowded ICUs who had to face "war-like" conditions for months.
- throwaway744678 5y agoI'm with you here, and don't understand the downvotes; I get that someone can disagree with you, but the argument seems reasonable to me, and made in good faith. Also, I'd like to point out that of lot of commenters are from the US: as a French citizen, I very much believe that, for obvious historical and cultural reasons, our conception of the citizenship (nationality) very much differ.
- BjoernKW 5y agoIn secular countries, citizenship often is considered to be something of almost sacred value. Citizenship also comes with very tangible benefits such as the right to vote or - in many cases - entitlement to social security benefits. That's not something that should be handed out lightly. That said, the current at least partially time-based requirements for naturalization in most countries probably aren't exactly perfect. The question is: How would one approach such an individually impactful decision differently and more effectively? Immigration authorities often already are unable to adequately cope with applications for naturalization as is. Further complicating matters by individually assessing if someone is likely to stay in a country probably isn't particularly helpful in that regard without a wholesale overhaul of the bureaucracy involved.
- carlob 5y ago> In secular countries, citizenship often is considered to be something of almost sacred value. Citizenship also comes with very tangible benefits such as the right to vote or - in many cases - entitlement to social security benefits. Having the right citizenship also means you can command higher salaries for the exact same job. Some authors have called this citizenship premium or citizenship rent. To me all these seem like valid arguments against gatekeeping rather than for. In a way passports serve a similar role to what hereditary titles were until the 18th-19th century in much of the Western world, and what you're saying sounds a lot like the debates people had on newly minted barons not deserving the privileges of old blood...
- hef19898 5y agoSocial Security is, more or less, tied to residency for EU-citizen across the board anyway. France has a long standing tradition of granting citizenship for service to state, nation or society (he right of spilled blood, bad translation). And I think we highly over estimate the value of citizenships, after all they can be literally bought in some places.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> France has a long standing tradition of granting citizenship for service to state, nation or society (he right of spilled blood, bad translation). Indeed, and that should not be diluted by lowering the bar to "has been showing up for work for two years", which is pretty much as low as can be and, frankly, an insult to those who got it by spilled blood or outstanding service. I'm not against this program but, since it is done in relation to the pandemic, it should have been restricted to those who did exceptional things to help during that time , garbage collectors clearly haven't even if their role is essential.
- sersi 5y agoHadn't read about garbage collectors but given that it's a job that's hard to recruit for and has a higher accident than most jobs, it makes sense. It's the kind of job that non-immigrants tend to not want to do.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoGarbage collectors are explicitly mentioned in the article and the original article in French. I'd like to see data to back your claim that it is hard to recruit for that job in France. I'm far from convinced and in fact in some French cities it is a very coveted job because it is well paid taking into account the low number of hours (famously source of a long conflict in Marseille where they are paid 35h per week but usually work 15h and go on strike when attempts are made to increase number of hours actually worked...)
- sersi 5y agoWell, purely anecdotal but a family member was part of the local communauté de commune and they had difficulties recruiting Eboueurs. This is more in the country side where I imagine that the risks in term of accident might be higher? (at least when it comes to road safety), I do not know the situation in cities.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoI had to look up that word (éboueur). I like it, maybe they'd have better luck recruiting with a classy french title. ;-)
- mywittyname 5y ago> for garbage collectors? If these people stop showing up for a month, you'll find out just how essential these people are. If it is hard to find people to do this domestically, then offering citizenship to attract foreign workers is a good idea.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoBoth your points are red herrings. In addition, France does not offer citizenship to attract foreign workers. It has sped up the process for a few people so that the government can have its PR less than a year before elections. Again, I'm not opposed to granting citizenship outside of the normal procedure, but I think this should require having done some exceptional to deserve it. I have no problem with granting it to a law-abiding health worker who has pulled 60 hour weeks in ICU since the beginning of the pandemic, but I don't see what a garbage collector who's been doing their job normally (like everyone else) has done to deserve "a medal". Lastly, France has a high unemployment rate so I don't think there is a need to attract unskilled foreign workers. If unskilled jobs are left unfilled (and I don't have data to say they are) the issue is not workforce shortages.
- phtrivier 5y ago"Giving citizenship to foreigner" is definitely _not_ something that the government wants to have in the news during the election period (the election will be played, as usual, between the candidate that manages to balance fearmongering about foreigners and following the eternal french mandate of welcoming the oppressed.) So if there is a calculation, it's to do it well in advance of the campaign, so as not to have to justify themselves.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoNo-one forced the government to set up this program, which is not a usual thing to do, and obviously everything is political when you're the government. They have not really done anything on immigration, it's not where they want to go, quite the opposite: "immigration is an opportunity for France" [1] and this is part of that stance. Marcon is appealing to the centre and left because I think he'd be quite happy to have another second round between him and Le Pen. It'd be closer than last time but he'd win. So ideally the best things he can do are things that make more people on the left vote for him and keep Le Pen on top on the right. This might be one of them. I also think Macron launched his campaign with his visit to Marseille, which also looked very much like an appeal to the centre and left. [1] https://www.connexionfrance.com/French-news/Immigration-is-an-opportunity-for-France-says-President-Macron https://www.connexionfrance.com/French-news/Immigration-is-a...
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoGarbage collectors are more essential to a society than any developer. Don't mistake being well compensated with being important. A lot more people are going to find themselves inconvenienced if the neighborhood garbage collector stops his route than if the neighborhood software nerd stops writing code.
- throwaway744678 5y agoMaking the world a better place, one garbage can at a time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 5y ago> Indeed, was there really any pressing need to reduce the residence requirement from 5 to 2 years for garbage collectors? Judging by piles of garbage decorating biggest cities of Western Europe every few months, yes.
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoOnly immigrants work for their citizenships, I got mine and you got yours as birth and it’s clearly a dilution of citizenship.
- vinay427 5y agoThis is a fantastic reframing, even from someone that already generally felt in line with this view. If you consider the citizenship test in the US, which is already far easier than in much of Europe (and certainly the places with more assimilationist tendencies), it's fairly clear that a decent number of native-born citizens wouldn't pass in the US, and people in the country in which I live would probably do even worse on the test here. A question once asked here was which two species of animals are kept together in the local zoo. Another person was denied by their town (until appealing to a higher court) because they were involved in some animal rights activism, which the people in her town/community disagreed with.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoWitty but actually nonsensical. The point of gate-keeping citizenship for immigrants has been explained ad nauseam in this discussion alone and is, frankly common sense expect for the most extreme on the political spectrum.