4 ms·
I was also kinda liked The New Microsoft and prepared to put my anger towards them to the side (I remember the ACPI memo days). Also, as a grown-up computer use
by bayindirh 5y ago
I was also kinda liked The New Microsoft and prepared to put my anger towards them to the side (I remember the ACPI memo days). Also, as a grown-up computer user, I got appropriate number of licenses (for every Microsoft application we use) for my family and personal computers.
However, the latest GitHub Copilot stuff, their agreement with OpenAI, return of their embrace, extend, extinguish tactics with GitHub, VSCode and other stuff undone everything.
It's their DNA now. All Microsoft Empire is built with crushing monopoly as their core value and driving force. Changing this requires more than changing a mere CEO and posting a "We Love Linux" banner.
The only really good thing they do is hardware.
Posted from my Debian 11 box using Microsoft Keyboard.
- flatiron 5y agoI recently left Apple and my new company gave me a choice of windows or macOS as my device and I chose windows. I’m not really sure why. But I do have to say after not using windows for 10+ years it’s come a long way. Wsl simply is amazing. Vscode works perfectly with it. The office apps are leaps and bounds better than there macOS counterparts. I certainly have never been a MS lover but I think they are much better now than their 90s reputation.
- binkHN 5y agoThey are also, very much, embracing Linux. More and more of Azure has Linux underpinnings and we'll see more integration of Linux in Windows, starting with WSLg.
- gsnedders 5y agoI mean a lot of the Azure stuff is realising that they could either: continue offering Windows Server only and likely miss out on a lot of potential customers but gain some sales of Windows Server, or start offering Linux in their cloud offering. Ultimately they decided to do the latter, and I'd bet that it's the more profitable option.
- horsawlarway 5y agoI think the writing has been on the wall for a while now - Windows (server or otherwise) is no longer considered the money maker - now it's Office and Azure. Nadella was literally the top Cloud Computing executive at the company before he was picked for CEO. Replacing Balmer - who was very pro-windows.
- syshum 5y agoYes, but likely they will then "extend" Linux so if an dev is using WSL to develop a linux project you will need to install MS things on your production enviroment, likely in the NET Core world... I am sure this will happen with the full support the Linux Foundation whom they paid off. It will also come by default in Azure I am sure After they "extend" with MS open source then start to require just a few closed binaries, that is not a big deal right, for the functionality... see VSCode as an example of this in modern times. This likely will be a paid feature unless you use Azure where it will be free... and before long we enter the Extinguish phase
- smoldesu 5y agoI don't really see that as much of a concern. If Microsoft announced plans for world domination tomorrow, all I'd need to change in my workflow is which fork of VS Code I'm using.
- syshum 5y agoNo one announces plans for world domination, it is far more benign and slow than that. it is like quicksand, by they time you know you are in deep it is too late for you to do anything
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoThe existence of company DNA is a marketing fib. Every company aspires to be big enough to integrate the entire stack and kick out all their competition. Only a few manage to do it. There was never a new Microsoft. There was only Microsoft when they admitted they didn't have a stranglehold monopoly on PCs anymore. It's as basic a strategy as anything you'd find in Art of War: When you're #2, cooperate with #3 to take down #1. When you're #1, pull up the ladder so #2 and #3 can't use it.
- sangnoir 5y ago> The existence of company DNA is a marketing fib. It isn't - company DNA doesn't always represent positive attributes. Company culture, incentive structure, priorities and skill-sets are all part of what's given the shorthand "company DNA" (and all are self-reinforcing/self-replicating. Google's DNA makes it exceptional at developing and scaling complex web services, but terrible at product longevity (except for the break-out hits), and terrible at consumer electronics. Apple is mostly the opposite. In spite of all their efforts, both companies struggle to be half as good as the other one in the areas outside of their core competency, because of their respective company DNA.
- Semaphor 5y agoWhat kind of EEE do they currently do? Outside of GH, I don’t even see them having any kind of position dominant enough to extinguish anything and GH doesn’t seem to have shifted in any way since MS bought them, they were "value add on top of git" before and are still now.
- ginko 5y agoWSL is clearly EEE.
- zaphar 5y agoWhy? I mean it's clearly Embrace. But Embrace and Extend are the goals of OSS. MS is a for profit company true. But OSS has never been anti-profit. The last E is problematic of course and MS has a history of going for Extinguish in the past. However I haven't seen any sign of that behavior in the current leadership and they've been doing their thing for a while now. You may not believe MS can change and you may not trust them. But that's a faith statement right now not a fact statement.
- smichel17 5y agoI've understood the second E to mean "...with our proprietary stuff". Building OSS on top of other OSS is still just Embrace. An example of Extend would be building features for WSL that only work in WSL, not Linux proper. So now people become dependent on the MS ecosystem, and lock-in begins; the lock-in is what enables the Extinguish phase.
- opencl 5y agoThey've done a little bit of that with DirectX for WSL2. https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/directx-heart-linux/ https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/directx-heart-linux/
- garaetjjte 5y ago>An example of Extend would be building features for WSL that only work in WSL, not Linux proper. That thing already exists, DirectX is available only under WSL: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/wp-content/uploads/sites/42/2020/05/word-image-9.png https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/wp-content/uploads/si... Extinguish phase is not clear though. (at least for now)
- tester34 5y ago>GitHub Copilot Github is Github Microsoft is Microsoft Aren't they? Github works heavily independently from MS
- eagle2com 5y agoMicrosoft acquired github in 2018
- nvrspyx 5y agoI think they recognize that, but are stating that Microsoft has taken a hands-off approach after acquiring GitHub and that GitHub mostly runs independent of Microsoft, similar to NPM.
- bayindirh 5y agoEh, mostly. For CoPilot, you need a language model, where the current best one is made by OpenAI, which doesn't like to share its stuff. This is the same OpenAI, which got $1B from Microsoft, and gave commercial licenses to Microsoft to use GPT-3. Which is the company which also owns GitHub, and also has a platform like Azure, so it can just "lend" GPT-3 and some servers to train the said model on some code, which GitHub clearly has possession of. So, while they're different, and it's casually owned by the other, this ownership allows them to put one's code and other's GPT-3 access into "good" use. At the end of the day, public code is public, so license doesn't matter, eh?* *: CoPilot is trained on all public code containing GPL, AGPL and similar licenses which doesn't allow proprietary use, so it's another ball of hair.
- jcelerier 5y ago> It's their DNA now. All Microsoft Empire is built with crushing monopoly as their core value and driving force. it's literally the point of being a public company, how is that a surprise for anyone.