8 ms·
> Did they learn nothing from the antitrust cases of the 2000's They learned for awhile- until the rest of the industry caught up. This might sound weird but
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
> Did they learn nothing from the antitrust cases of the 2000's
They learned for awhile- until the rest of the industry caught up.
This might sound weird but I've actually been rooting for Microsoft a lot lately. A majority of their revenue is not from ads and lock-in BS and they weren't called in front of Congress recently over antitrust concerns. I was hoping they would set themselves apart from the pack in an odd way by making good software and hardware products that people enjoy using. (xbox, windows, office, WSL, VSCode, Visual Studio, hololens, phones, laptops, Halo on Steam, etc.)
Seeing the new browser war and direction Windows 11 is headed, now has me worried. The widgets pane is obviously for serving ads.
I understand that these public companies are required to act in the best interests of shareholders but I fear that the obsessive push for revenue gains only benefits short term shareholders. Long term shareholders get the shaft when every decision is aimed at squeezing revenue just for the next quarter.
Edit: I'm not a Microsoft/Windows-Stan either, I've been using Linux intermittently since 2006-ish and now daily drive Fedora as my main.
- bayindirh 5y agoI was also kinda liked The New Microsoft and prepared to put my anger towards them to the side (I remember the ACPI memo days). Also, as a grown-up computer user, I got appropriate number of licenses (for every Microsoft application we use) for my family and personal computers. However, the latest GitHub Copilot stuff, their agreement with OpenAI, return of their embrace, extend, extinguish tactics with GitHub, VSCode and other stuff undone everything. It's their DNA now. All Microsoft Empire is built with crushing monopoly as their core value and driving force. Changing this requires more than changing a mere CEO and posting a "We Love Linux" banner. The only really good thing they do is hardware. Posted from my Debian 11 box using Microsoft Keyboard.
- flatiron 5y agoI recently left Apple and my new company gave me a choice of windows or macOS as my device and I chose windows. I’m not really sure why. But I do have to say after not using windows for 10+ years it’s come a long way. Wsl simply is amazing. Vscode works perfectly with it. The office apps are leaps and bounds better than there macOS counterparts. I certainly have never been a MS lover but I think they are much better now than their 90s reputation.
- binkHN 5y agoThey are also, very much, embracing Linux. More and more of Azure has Linux underpinnings and we'll see more integration of Linux in Windows, starting with WSLg.
- gsnedders 5y agoI mean a lot of the Azure stuff is realising that they could either: continue offering Windows Server only and likely miss out on a lot of potential customers but gain some sales of Windows Server, or start offering Linux in their cloud offering. Ultimately they decided to do the latter, and I'd bet that it's the more profitable option.
- horsawlarway 5y agoI think the writing has been on the wall for a while now - Windows (server or otherwise) is no longer considered the money maker - now it's Office and Azure. Nadella was literally the top Cloud Computing executive at the company before he was picked for CEO. Replacing Balmer - who was very pro-windows.
- syshum 5y agoYes, but likely they will then "extend" Linux so if an dev is using WSL to develop a linux project you will need to install MS things on your production enviroment, likely in the NET Core world... I am sure this will happen with the full support the Linux Foundation whom they paid off. It will also come by default in Azure I am sure After they "extend" with MS open source then start to require just a few closed binaries, that is not a big deal right, for the functionality... see VSCode as an example of this in modern times. This likely will be a paid feature unless you use Azure where it will be free... and before long we enter the Extinguish phase
- smoldesu 5y agoI don't really see that as much of a concern. If Microsoft announced plans for world domination tomorrow, all I'd need to change in my workflow is which fork of VS Code I'm using.
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoThe existence of company DNA is a marketing fib. Every company aspires to be big enough to integrate the entire stack and kick out all their competition. Only a few manage to do it. There was never a new Microsoft. There was only Microsoft when they admitted they didn't have a stranglehold monopoly on PCs anymore. It's as basic a strategy as anything you'd find in Art of War: When you're #2, cooperate with #3 to take down #1. When you're #1, pull up the ladder so #2 and #3 can't use it.
- sangnoir 5y ago> The existence of company DNA is a marketing fib. It isn't - company DNA doesn't always represent positive attributes. Company culture, incentive structure, priorities and skill-sets are all part of what's given the shorthand "company DNA" (and all are self-reinforcing/self-replicating. Google's DNA makes it exceptional at developing and scaling complex web services, but terrible at product longevity (except for the break-out hits), and terrible at consumer electronics. Apple is mostly the opposite. In spite of all their efforts, both companies struggle to be half as good as the other one in the areas outside of their core competency, because of their respective company DNA.
- Semaphor 5y agoWhat kind of EEE do they currently do? Outside of GH, I don’t even see them having any kind of position dominant enough to extinguish anything and GH doesn’t seem to have shifted in any way since MS bought them, they were "value add on top of git" before and are still now.
- ginko 5y agoWSL is clearly EEE.
- zaphar 5y agoWhy? I mean it's clearly Embrace. But Embrace and Extend are the goals of OSS. MS is a for profit company true. But OSS has never been anti-profit. The last E is problematic of course and MS has a history of going for Extinguish in the past. However I haven't seen any sign of that behavior in the current leadership and they've been doing their thing for a while now. You may not believe MS can change and you may not trust them. But that's a faith statement right now not a fact statement.
- smichel17 5y agoI've understood the second E to mean "...with our proprietary stuff". Building OSS on top of other OSS is still just Embrace. An example of Extend would be building features for WSL that only work in WSL, not Linux proper. So now people become dependent on the MS ecosystem, and lock-in begins; the lock-in is what enables the Extinguish phase.
- opencl 5y agoThey've done a little bit of that with DirectX for WSL2. https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/directx-heart-linux/ https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/directx-heart-linux/
- garaetjjte 5y ago>An example of Extend would be building features for WSL that only work in WSL, not Linux proper. That thing already exists, DirectX is available only under WSL: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/wp-content/uploads/sites/42/2020/05/word-image-9.png https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/wp-content/uploads/si... Extinguish phase is not clear though. (at least for now)
- tester34 5y ago>GitHub Copilot Github is Github Microsoft is Microsoft Aren't they? Github works heavily independently from MS
- eagle2com 5y agoMicrosoft acquired github in 2018
- nvrspyx 5y agoI think they recognize that, but are stating that Microsoft has taken a hands-off approach after acquiring GitHub and that GitHub mostly runs independent of Microsoft, similar to NPM.
- bayindirh 5y agoEh, mostly. For CoPilot, you need a language model, where the current best one is made by OpenAI, which doesn't like to share its stuff. This is the same OpenAI, which got $1B from Microsoft, and gave commercial licenses to Microsoft to use GPT-3. Which is the company which also owns GitHub, and also has a platform like Azure, so it can just "lend" GPT-3 and some servers to train the said model on some code, which GitHub clearly has possession of. So, while they're different, and it's casually owned by the other, this ownership allows them to put one's code and other's GPT-3 access into "good" use. At the end of the day, public code is public, so license doesn't matter, eh?* *: CoPilot is trained on all public code containing GPL, AGPL and similar licenses which doesn't allow proprietary use, so it's another ball of hair.
- jcelerier 5y ago> It's their DNA now. All Microsoft Empire is built with crushing monopoly as their core value and driving force. it's literally the point of being a public company, how is that a surprise for anyone.
- yessirwhatever 5y agoI suspect it that this is like the usual situation at MS, most employees think this strategy is dumb, but there's that one guy who's still living like it's 1991 and he's got good connections with management, so they let them run unchecked. That's the person who's coming up with such idiotic strategies.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI'm not so sure. It's possible all the employees who thought this was dumb left before or shortly after Windows 8, so all that's left are people who don't care and the incompetent.
- cabalamat 5y ago> The widgets pane is obviously for serving ads. If Windows is going to have ads at the OS level, that I can't get rid of, I simply won't use it. > Long term shareholders get the shaft when every decision is aimed at squeezing revenue just for the next quarter. True
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is the definition of long term? Investments in Microsoft and Apple would surely have paid off over the past few decades.
- ravenstine 5y ago> I understand that these public companies are required to act in the best interests of shareholders but I fear that the obsessive push for revenue gains only benefits short term shareholders. Long term shareholders get the shaft when every decision is aimed at squeezing revenue just for the next quarter. Never so succinctly have I seen described the economic problem of the modern age; endless growth for its own sake. Sure, it's motivated by profit, but society and global elites don't act as if there are significant downsides to an investment-driven economy. Rather, it's treated as a virtue, else we wouldn't all be buying into it, literally and figuratively, for the bare minimum of not losing our wealth. > Halo on Steam Hah, you don't hear much about Halo anymore. But it's entirely possible you may be able to play Halo on Steam on your Linux machine in the near future. Combat Evolved plays really well on my M1 Macbook through Parallels (even with Anniversary mode, given some settings tweaks) and Reach is playable but drops a lot of frames; if you ever get a Linux machine that runs on ARM then you can virtualize Windows for ARM in a way that blows away any x86_64 emulation I've seen in the past. Of course most of the work to make that a reality isn't even because of Microsoft besides their compiling of Windows for ARM. Besides that... > xbox, windows, office, WSL, VSCode, Visual Studio, hololens, phones, laptops, Halo on Steam, etc. Honestly, the only decent things you mentioned are Office, VSCode, and Halo, which are all things that just about any other company could have created. Office itself is begging for a viable alternative, but has been effectively grandfathered in to being a necessity for businesses. I mentioned Halo but not Xbox because, IMO, Xbox is an obsolete concept and Microsoft knows this. There's GitHub, but it's only a matter of time before Microsoft decides to add "plans" for features that are already free as well as forms of prioritization for all things Windows. I guess I'm not exactly sure what point I'm trying to make besides that I kind of agree with you in the sense that M$ has been less problematic than other Big Tech in recent years. With Windows 11, now I'm not so sure.
- paganel 5y agoImo their Lumia phones (and the accompanying OS and new UI philosophy) were also something special, and I say that as a hater of those products earlier on (i.e. before I got to know them better). It's a shame that those phones didn't catch on.
- 5y ago
- Craighead 5y agoAhahahahahahahahaha >a majority of their revenue is not from ads and lock-in BS You're not a stan, you're only a fool.
- PaulHoule 5y agoMicrosoft's ad problem is that they damage their existing products to advertise new products that are a lost cause. There was that "crash your desktop" bug caused by an ad for Teams but longer ago there was OneDrive... DropBox, Box, Google and many others could make file sharing programs that could sync successfully, but somehow Microsoft couldn't. To add injury to insult they made OneDrive the default way to save files in Microsoft Office, but sometimes a problem with OneDrive would mean YOU COULDN'T SAVE YOUR WORK AT ALL. If you've had that experience ONCE you are NEVER going to use OneDrive ever. Then there was that time that OneNote was a pretty good product but Microsoft killed it by inserting at least five icons on and around your desktop (practically up your nose) signalling that it is absolute garbage that they're trying to force up your A*. Google kills products after the launch, but Microsoft kills them in the process of launch with it's internal advertising.
- tl 5y ago> To add injury to insult they made OneDrive the default way to save files in Microsoft Office, but sometimes a problem with OneDrive would mean YOU COULDN'T SAVE YOUR WORK AT ALL. It's worse than that. The change to default OneDrive breaks auto-save everywhere that isn't OneDrive. On the Mac, this includes breaking auto-save on pre-Azure Sharepoint instances and network shares, but some of that works sometimes on Windows. So Office is a worse product even if you never use OneDrive.
- Notanothertoo 5y agoYep and as a Mac user with office your just left wondering why. Why on earth would I use one drive on Mac. One of the many reasons stopped using office on Mac. Rip excel.
- easton 5y agoOneDrive on Windows is fine now, but oh my gosh OneDrive for Mac is a mess. I didn't use it until my new M1 Mac (so maybe they are re-implementing everything without kernel extensions and it's causing issues), but it absolutely sucks. Every time it starts it can't find the folder, and I have to tell it where it is, then it will say "up-to-date" but nothing will actually have synced, then when it eventually catches up it spews duplicate files everywhere because every other box I have OneDrive on has updated since this computer actually synced. And Office doesn't understand that when I save in the ~/OneDrive folder, it goes into OneDrive, so it won't enable AutoSave or sharing unless you do a Save As and save it to the OneDrive SharePoint site it automatically adds. It's like OneDrive on Windows 5-6 years ago. I know other people that used it, it worked fine at one point, but now it's terrible.
- syshum 5y ago>>and lock-in BS Microsoft has all kinds of ways they do vertical lockin, it is not has overt as say Apple, but do not think for a second that the company that promoted Embrace, Extend, Extinguish does not have methods to lock in users
- prox 5y agoI wish I could give you an award or magically transport you to the MS office where these ridiculous choices are made. You hit nail on head I think. It’s the same manager mistakes over and over again.
- smt88 5y agoI understand the temptation to root for New Microsoft, but we should all remember that large corporations are extremely powerful psychopaths. Anything they do that seems ethical is self-serving, not part of a moral code that they will follow even when it hurts them.
- tracker1 5y agoI understand, but disagree with the sentiment... Companies are a collection of different people, with differing actual personalities, including agreements, disagreements and meaningful conflict and negotiations. To some extent it comes from leadership down, to another it starts at the ground floor. In the end, I think most MS movement has been self-serving, that doesn't make it inherently bad or good. I'm not liking the OS-shift, which seems to be following Apple/Google in a lot of ways. That doesn't mean everything MS does is poison.
- smt88 5y ago> That doesn't mean everything MS does is poison. Of course not. I love New Microsoft's products and customer/dev support. I vastly prefer Microsoft over any other FAAMG. I trust them more and think they're far less harmful than any of the others. All that said, I don't believe any of this is because of ethical principles. It's because they make more money by being "good" than by antagonizing their own society and customers. > Companies are a collection of different people, with differing actual personalities, including agreements, disagreements and meaningful conflict and negotiations. Yes, but as we've seen throughout human history, morals disappear as soon as people are part of a large group. You can participate (and even lead!) while telling yourself that the things you're doing as a group are totally out of your control. For example, I have a Jewish friend at Facebook who is appalled by their enablement of conspiracy theories, but he still works at Facebook. If everyone at Facebook who objected to their company's behavior would find another job, I guarantee the behavior would change or the company would collapse. > I think most MS movement has been self-serving, that doesn't make it inherently bad or good I guess it depends on your definition of "bad". I have never observed a large corporation take a huge hit to its bottom line in order to stand up for something moral. I don't think I ever will. To me, that's "bad" -- a group of people who exercise an enormous amount of power without feeling that they're personally responsible for the consequences. That's why I described it as psychopathy.
- ChrisSD 5y ago> I understand that these public companies are required to act in the best interests of shareholders This is not true. Public companies are only required to be honest with shareholders, no more or less. The shareholders are free to invest elsewhere if the don't like how a company is run, or to exercise whatever voting rights they bought with the shares.
- dylan604 5y agoThat might have been true in the past, but now there are activist shareholders who will try to take control rather than dump the stock and move on to something else. After all, it is their investment, and if they choose to raise their voice then that is their right as well.
- ChrisSD 5y agoSure they can raise their voice but they're limited in what they can achieve, legally speaking. Especially in large companies with a lot of shareholders. Unless the companies by-laws give shareholders undue influence, which would be unusual. It's true that activists can make a nuisance of themselves if there are enough of them but they basically have to hope to get sections of the press on their side and for the company to care about that. The risk, of course, is the bad press ends up hurting their own investment. In short, they have no legal recourse unless the company mislead them in some way.
- dylan604 5y agoAre you really this unfamiliar with this or being obtuse about it? Of course it is unlikely that a single shareholder will have enough stock to hold clout, but that's not how these people operate. Just like no one person makes a difference when protesting anything. You find like minded people, gather together, and make your large number of people heard. Sure, it's not easy to get a large enough percentage of the stock, but there are ways of doing it and it has been done and will continue to be done. A recent tech example is how Disney was pushed by its investors to pursue the streaming options [0]. [0]https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-07/disney-activist-loeb-wants-dividend-halt-to-fund-streaming-hits https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-07/disney-ac...
- akira2501 5y ago> and they weren't called in front of Congress recently over antitrust concerns Congress hasn't exactly been a hotbed of anti-trust activity over the past 40 years. I wouldn't take the absence of action here as anything particularly meaningful.