3 ms·
> Having a lot of money does not in any way equal power or influence. No, but I'd argue only in the sense that having a lot of dollar bills in your wallet does
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
> Having a lot of money does not in any way equal power or influence.
No, but I'd argue only in the sense that having a lot of dollar bills in your wallet does not equal having an equivalently-valued watch or a car. But one can be converted into the other.
I'm not sure why this whole thread doesn't bring this point. Even today, we don't really grade people's wealth by the actual money they have in hand, we count up their assets. And influence is just another asset, even if it's hard to quantify[0].
So Mr. Jimmy John Liautaud may not be famous and influential, but were he to take his $1 billion of assets and try to convert it to influence, I'm plenty sure he'd succeed at becoming no less influential than Glenn Greenwald. Conversely, Krugman, Greenwald and Yglasis may not be swimming in money or "traditional" assets, but were they to try to convert their influence into money, I'm also convinced they'd succeed.
I think the missing mental model for people claiming influence/power != money is that you need to actually spend influence/power to make money. You only go from influential to influential+wealthy if you have enough influence at the beginning that there's something left after the conversion. Similarly, if you don't have enough money, converting your wealth to influence will leave you with little wealth.
In this way, I think money and power are equivalent in a similar way that cash and the house you own are.
--
[0] - It's not something the economists haven't seen before. Even stocks can hard to value in terms of "how much dollars would you have after selling them all", because if you have enough of them, their price starts changing while you sell them.
- xyzzyz 5y ago> but were he to take his $1 billion of assets and try to convert it to influence, I'm plenty sure he'd succeed at becoming no less influential than Glenn Greenwald. And how would he do that, exactly? Oh yes, that’s right, by paying people like Glenn Greenwald to spread his message (or rather, paying journalists more corrupt than Greenwald is), paying NGO operatives and lobbyists to massage the public and politicians into what he wants. So yes, his billion can buy influence (maybe), but only through the actual elites who have a lot of personal influence of their own, unlike Jimmy John Liautaud.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYup. That's the part where he'd burn the money on creating influence. After which, he would have influence - and possibly no money. Then, at some point, some other wealthy person could use him as a platform to convert their wealth to influence. Meanwhile, Glenn Greenwald could launch a book and/or start a company and/or run for an office, and leverage his audience and name recognition to get into a position of wealth... most likely significantly damaging his platform in the process. An influence to wealth conversion. I don't see anything strange in here, or anything countering my point. Yes, to exchange money for $thing, you often need to give it to people already having $thing.