3 ms·
Indeed, there is no evidence there was ever any New Testament text in Aramaic. Nothing in the Greek text hints at any sort of translation difficulty going from
by ncmncm 5y ago
Indeed, there is no evidence there was ever any New Testament text in Aramaic. Nothing in the Greek text hints at any sort of translation difficulty going from a Semitic to an Indo-European language.
Questions of whether Jesus, Matthew, Luke, et al ever even existed as live people arise. Again, there is no evidence of any kind to settle the matter. Serious historians, in its absence, lean toward "no". Many conclude that Christianity started out as a cult wholly based in Rome, that later identified a need for "people stories" set in someplace exotic to appeal to the laity.
- bhaak 5y ago[citation needed] who those serious historians are supposed to be.
- ncmncm 5y agoPlease allow me to direct you to an active, ongoing history of refereed journals, academic chairs, and professional study which you may even see discussed at great length on Youtube, such as is cited in a sibling reply.
- objectivetruth 5y agoMost of us don't find "just watch this YouTube URL, it explains everything" to be a helpful reply from an interlocutor. I can't ignore the fact that it is a very common tactic of conspiracy theorists of various stripes, poor deluded QAnon believers, and drinkers of ivermectin. I gave you the benefit of the doubt and it's a 10-year-old recording of a nearly-hourlong lecture by a single scholar. I'm not watching that. You implied there is a significant number of professional ("serious") historians that don't believe in the historicity of Jesus in 2021 and I just don't see how this video supports that.
- bhaak 5y agoI'm not sure how "New Evidences the Gospels were Based on Eyewitness Accounts" would support your claim "whether Jesus, Matthew, Luke, et al ever even existed" and that Christianity started out as Roman cult.
- gwd 5y ago> Again, there is no evidence of any kind to settle the matter. ...Many conclude that Christianity started out as a cult wholly based in Rome, that later identified a need for "people stories" set in someplace exotic to appeal to the laity. There are sorts of clues. For instance, say that you and I both wrote a story set in your hometown. Assuming that your hometown isn't the same as mine, your story would have a much richer "backdrop", in terms of, say, the variety of place names. Some evidence along these lines are presented in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5Ylt1pBMm8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5Ylt1pBMm8
- ncmncm 5y agoThat its authors were familiar with geographical Palestine is evident, but that does not bear on events or existence of named individuals. And, of course, any of them could have existed without the events reported occcurring, just as we acknowledge GW without conceding his cherry tree. It all comes down to faith, the which historians are obliged to work without.
- gwd 5y ago> ...but that does not bear on events or existence of named individuals. Right, the logic of my post wasn't clear. I wasn't addressing whether there was evidence for the existence of Luke, but addressing the theory that "people stories" were made up in some exotic locale. > That its authors were familiar with geographical Palestine is evident, So what you're saying is that members of this cult from Rome: 1. Determined that their nice theory needed "people stories" (why?) 2. Determined that they needed to be placed in an exotic locale 3. Actually travelled and to Palestine and bummed around there long enough to be familiar with the geography -- and not just Jerusalem and some of the surrounding villages, but Galilee way up in the north, the Samaritan region in between, and so on. It had been awhile since I watched that video; after posting it I watched it again, and it turns out these authors also bummed around long enough that the made-up names in these made-up stories just accidentally match up well statistically with the names that were common in Palestine at the alleged time of the events. > It all comes down to faith, the which historians are obliged to work without. This is just propaganda. I've listened to a number of audio books of history in the last few years, including a biography of Catherine Howard (5th wife of Henry VIII), the Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, and a history of Pompeii. All of them seem perfectly comfortable discussing a number of possible reconstructions given the facts at hand and giving a judgement of the plausibility of any of them. "We don't have any evidence that a person named Luke existed" doesn't sound like the kind of thing those authors would say. It's not that huge of a deal theologically whether Luke existed or not; but my understanding is that there's no particular reason to doubt that he did. So consider two hypotheses: A. "There were guys named Matthew, Luke, Mark, and John who collected and wrote down reports collected from people who actually met some a Palestinian preacher named Joshua" B. "People from some theology-heavy cult based in Rome lived in Palestine for a decade drinking in the culture so that their made-up stores would be more realistic." Any neutral judge -- i.e., one who isn't starting out with the assumption that the events in the gospels are complete fabrications -- would say A is a lot more likely scenario than B. And if B really is the best alternate explanation people have been able to come up with, that lends an awful lot of credence to A, in my mind.