37 ms·
It's a great debating trick. Its very funny. It doesn't invalidate RCT as a statistical model. The underlying ethics behind RCT are complex. There are instance
by ggm 5y ago
It's a great debating trick. Its very funny. It doesn't invalidate RCT as a statistical model.
The underlying ethics behind RCT are complex. There are instances of RCT being abandoned early because of abundant evidence the tested drug worked, and there are instances of RCT post-treatment for participants who were denied the drug under test by virtue of being the control, and there are examples of widespread concern at the ethics of RCTs.
"The Emperor of All Maladies" by Siddhartha Mukherjee discusses the history of RCT in the context of Cancer treatment, where the drugs were so cycotoxic the hospitals were extremely concerned at the ethics of even trying to use them.
- agent327 5y agoWhat it invalidates is the notion that research that does not include RCT is automatically wrong. We currently see this in action in the way corona is being treated. When we were told that masks don't help stop the spread of corona, what was really meant was "there has been no RCT that demonstrates that the spread of corona is less in a mask-wearing group" - in other words, the issue was simply untested, but this was formulated in such a way that a lay person would believe it was already known that masks have no effect, which is something completely different. The use of Ivermectin is arguably in the same situation right now.