4 ms·
Some takeaways I've had in reading Smith ... decades after he was assigned reading in my intro economics uni courses: "Adam Smith's Lost Legacy: Or why you sho
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Some takeaways I've had in reading Smith ... decades after he was assigned reading in my intro economics uni courses:
"Adam Smith's Lost Legacy: Or why you should read Wealth of Nations, that it's not what you think, and how the "invisible hand" is entirely a 20th century propaganda disinformation campaign"
- I didn't seek out Smith anticipating agreement
- Smith isn't an advocate of laissez faire
- Smith speaks of the "free market" only once: criticising business practices
- Almost all discussion of "Adam Smith's Invisible Hand" is absolutely, completely, utterly false, and a modern 20th century fabrication
- The exceptionally curious nature of the common presentation of "Smith's Hand":
- Smith does make errors: barter, US colonial advice, university compensation
- Read him yourself. Free, online
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4cyroa/adam_smiths_lost_legacy_or_why_you_should_read/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4cyroa/adam_sm...
Adding to those ponts:
- Smith's exploration of pricing behaviours of various goods and services is both accessible and brilliant. Wages, commodities, stock (capital), rents, skilled labour (a five-point compensation formula), interest, assets (gold and silver), public goods, and taxes. Most of those are in the first part ("book") of Wealth of Nations, public expenditure is in the 5th part.
- His five-factor analysis of wages, again: agreeableness, ease of learning, regularity of trade, risk of success or failure, trust required by those employing the trade.
- Much on the relationship of workers and employers ("masters").
- Much sympathy for the plight of the poor, and the importance of seeing to the improvement of their circumstances.
- Much criticism of shareholder ("joint stock") corporations.
- Far more than you ever wanted to know about English monetary history.
- "Wealth, as Mr Hobbes says, is power." Yes, there are a few short sentences.
- alfiedotwtf 5y ago> Almost all discussion of "Adam Smith's Invisible Hand" is absolutely, completely, utterly false, and a modern 20th century fabrication From memory, the words "Invisible Hand" was only ever mentioned once throughout Wealth of Nations. It was used in his other writings.
- dredmorbius 5y agoCorrect. It's also mentioned once in A Theory of Moral Sentiments, and in the posthumously published Essays on Philosophical Subjects, a book on astronomy. In both it's clear from context that the "invisible hand" is some unknown mechanism, and not an explanation, but a statement of ignorance. "The invisible hand of God" would be a more common contemporaneous phrase, in the sense of a Creator and Organiser of the Universe, though Smith as with Hume seems to have been largely non-Deistic. From Moral Sentiments: The produce of the soil maintains at all times nearly that number of inhabitants which it is capable of maintaining. The rich only select from the heap what is most precious and agreeable. They consume little more than the poor, and in spite of their natural selfishness and rapacity, though they mean only their own conveniency, though the sole end which they propose from the labours of all the thousands whom they employ, be the gratification of their own vain and insatiable desires, they divide with the poor the produce of all their improvements. They are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life, which would have been made, had the earth been divided into equal portions among all its inhabitants, and thus without intending it, without knowing it, advance the interest of the society, and afford means to the multiplication of the species. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Theory_of_Moral_Sentiments/Part_IV https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Theory_of_Moral_Sentiment... Gavin Kennedy's scholarship on the Invisible Hand question is the best I've found. See his paper here: (freely available PDF download): https://econjwatch.org/articles/adam-smith-and-the-invisible-hand-from-metaphor-to-myth https://econjwatch.org/articles/adam-smith-and-the-invisible... https://econjwatch.org/File+download/252/2009-05-kennedy-watchpad.pdf?mimetype=pdf https://econjwatch.org/File+download/252/2009-05-kennedy-wat... Gavin Kennedy's blog also has futher discussion: http://adamsmithslostlegacy.blogspot.com/ http://adamsmithslostlegacy.blogspot.com/ (Kennedy himself died in 2019.) There are two other occurrences of "invisible" in Wealth of Nations, both occurring in discussion of warfare: [T]he noise of firearms, the smoke, and the invisible death to which every man feels himself every moment exposed as soon as he comes within cannon-shot, and frequently a long time before the battle can be well said to be engaged, must render it very difficult to maintain any considerable degree of this regularity, order, and prompt obedience, even in the beginning of a modern battle. In an ancient battle there was no noise but what arose from the human voice; there was no smoke, there was no invisible cause of wounds or death. Every man, till some mortal weapon actually did approach him, saw clearly that no such weapon was near him. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_V/Chapter_1 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_V/...
- spamizbad 5y agoI think a lot of modern capitalist thinking has been shaped more by Hayek, but ends up getting misattributed to Smith.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt was the Chicago School specifically which prompted much of the misunderstanding, though my read is that Smith was used by advocates for specific policies, many of which he would not have endorsed, since the 19th century. The malconstruction of the "invisible hand" quote, which is drawn from a very carefully re-edited set of passages spanning hundreds of pages and multiple parts of the original book, comes from Jacob Viner, of the University of Chicago. Popular use of "the invisible hand" expanded greatly after the publication of a set of essays by Hayek, Friedman, Stigler, and other Austrian School / Libertarian economists, by Regnery Press (now largely know as an alt-right / white-nationalist imprint) in the early 1960s. (Use indiated through Google's Ngram Viewer.) Both points noted in my Reddit essay. Smith's name itself was co-opted by the Libertarian "Adam Smith Institute", part of the Atlas Network of over 500 "think tank" institutions (the Cato Institute, Heratige Institute, Heartland Foundation, and Manhattan Institute are among the better-known American entities). Milton Friedman's Free To Choose (book and television series, now its own propaganda institute) is responsible for much of the misportrayal in the public mind. (The book and series were part of my own intro economic course, taught by, I later discovered, a rabidly libertarian professor.)
- int_19h 5y agoWhile we're at it, speaking of malconstructions and misappropriations, a reminder that the very term "libertarian" used to mean "left anarchist" until the Austrian School hijacked it. (They used to call themselves "liberal", but when the meaning of that word shifted to describe stuff like New Deal, some decided that a rebranding is in order.)