3 ms·
> but if you zoom out to the helicopter perspective, the biggest “influencers” have always been the oligarchs and the sole requirement for joining their ranks i
by inglor_cz 5y ago
> but if you zoom out to the helicopter perspective, the biggest “influencers” have always been the oligarchs and the sole requirement for joining their ranks is having lots and lots of money.
That, on the other side, sounds very American-centric and contemporary-centric to me. I would say that even though money generally correlates with influence, there were many other factors at play.
Feudal nobles of Europe resented and despised the merchant class even if they could not utterly suppress it. Wealthy commoners would have an influence, but holders of hereditary titles would still in many cases be considered above them legally. In countries such as Tsarist Russia, being of noble birth would be way more important than being rich; pre-revolutionary France wasn't too dissimilar.
There were strict theocracies where the priestly caste would hold sway. Notably, scholars were considered more prestigious in Jewish societies than businesspeople, which might have contributed to the intellectual strength of the nation that is obvious even now.
In Soviet-like systems, real power was held by the nomenklatura consisting of high level apparatchiks, senior members of the Party. You could bribe them, but money wasn't really the most important thing; the most important thing was their intra-Party position, earned over decades of patient scheming against other possible competitors in badly sewn grey suits.
Spartans (or, to be more precise, Spartiates, the hereditary top class) would never under any circumstances admit any outsider among them as an equal - even if it meant that their ranks were thinning with each generation to the point of near extinction.
Saddam Hussein only trusted his own Tikrit gang and anyone else, rich or smart, was second rank only.
- shakow 5y ago> pre-revolutionary France wasn't too dissimilar. In appearance maybe; if you dig a bit under the varnish, the power exerted by creditors over nobles and even kings quickly appears.
- cassepipe 5y agoThere is that and let's not forget that powerful nobles were nobles with estates and/or positions in the state apparatus that directly corresponded to receiving a rent. I'd argue that OP's theory that the wealthy were always in control still holds but what has changed throughout history is what wealth has been (cattle, land, slaves, merchandise-money like gold, credit backed money you name it)
- Sebguer 5y agoIt's always the means of production, the means just change with the era.
- wincy 5y agoDoesn’t Jeff Bezos mostly own the means of logistics? Or is that bundled up in “means of production”. A warehouse full of iPhones isn’t worth much if it’s impossible to get them to your customers.
- Sebguer 5y agoThe means of distribution (or as you call it, the means of logistics) is part of the means of production, yeah. The mechanism by which products of labor are moved throughout the world is just as much a part of the means of production as anything else. It's one of the reasons that folks are so keen on privatizing things like the Royal Mail (one of the places that the UK right is ahead of the curve on the US) and the ongoing attempts to do the same to the USPS.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI feel it's just legacy in terminology - "means of production" imply "things you use to make stuff", because stuff was front-and-centre when it got coined as a political term. For most of the known history, humans didn't have much stuff. Making stuff was what seemed to bring all the money; logistical chains, being shorter, didn't seem that important. Additionally, all the stuff made was concrete, material things. But if you extend the meaning of "means of production" to cover not production of stuff, but production of more abstract economic value, you can see that the same struggle between different groups of people happens today, over not just material goods, but also virtual ones, as well as services. So Jeff Bezos definitely owns the "means of production" of logistics service.
- bobthechef 5y ago> Feudal nobles of Europe resented and despised the merchant class even if they could not utterly suppress it. Sure, and as with all rank, there is an element of pride driving this. You even have racial origin theories like the Sarmatian origin myth that held for a couple centuries among the Polish nobility to distinguish themselves from commoners. But the distaste for merchants I gather is more complex than absence of noble title, or rather, the noble title is presumed to have some association with certain virtues opposed to mercantile activity. For example, pre-industrial Polish nobility were actually forbidden from engaging in all commerce save for commerce of an agrarian nature. Probably whatever else they earned came from some kind of taxation, at least among those rich enough to own villages, towns, or even cities. But why forbid commerce? Either the Crown had managed to check the power of the nobility in some way (who had become obscenely wealthy by the 17th century), or the nobility themselves saw that they should not themselves partake in such commerce for some, ostensibly virtuous, reasons. But the fact is that the wealthier nobility nonetheless had the upper hand and the advantage. Poorer family members were known to work for their richer relatives. So you have segmentation within a given social class by wealth. > There were strict theocracies where the priestly caste would hold sway. Notably, scholars were considered more prestigious in Jewish societies than businesspeople, which might have contributed to the intellectual strength of the nation that is obvious even now. I would say that even in Catholic Europe, which was Catholic-confessional but never theocratic and could not legitimately be by virtue of the Christian distinction between secular and religious estates (something unique in history; e.g. neither Jews nor Muslims understand this concept natively, only as something borrowed ill-fittingly and ad hoc from the Christian worldview), the priesthood was (and among Catholics still is) regarded as the higher calling owing to man's supernatural end. Thus Catholics understand the supreme pontiff as the highest ranking authority on earth and the bishops as very literally the princes of the Church. This places them above the nobility in a certain sense, even if this is more of a partial rather than total order. And of course the clergy were the best educated members of society and among whom no hereditary advantages existed in the strict sense (even if the nobility within its ranks did promote "nephews" to various positions, but this is an aberration). Perhaps we can understand this as the result of the Catholic priesthood being heir to the Jewish priesthood. Which is to say that here, a bishop has higher rank than a wealthy noble.
- numpad0 5y agoI am thinking the disagreement with GP can be resolved by assuming money is representation of influences and connections. I’d argue that you can’t be poor with tons of connections with rich, and sole currency accumulation is not sufficient to be influential because it is only an aspect of your portfolio, but are usually well correlated with the level of influences as money exists as a representation of connections.
- moksly 5y ago> Feudal nobles of Europe resented and despised the merchant class even if they could not utterly suppress it. Wealthy commoners would have an influence, but holders of hereditary titles would still in many cases be considered above them legally. This supports what I’m saying though. The reason the nobility who achieved their wealth through force wanted to suppress the rising merchant class was exactly because their power became threatened by the new wealthy class. Ultimately the nobility failed. > There were strict theocracies where the priestly caste would hold sway. Notably, scholars were considered more prestigious in Jewish societies than businesspeople, which might have contributed to the intellectual strength of the nation that is obvious even now. How did the church grow mighty? It wasn’t faith, it was money. > In Soviet-like systems, real power was held by the nomenklatura consisting of high level apparatchiks, senior members of the Party. Both Castro and Mao were sons of wealthy farmers. The Bolsheviks were funded by none other than the German Kaiser. > Spartans Sparta was a clear cut oligarchy. I’m not really sure why you being them up, as the very reason their financial class discouraged trade was because they reasoned it would weaken their power if other members of society saw any sort of wealth.