4 ms·
> I can’t think of a period of human history, or a political system, where the richest families within it, didn’t have much more power than the ordinary citizen
by gumby 5y ago
> I can’t think of a period of human history, or a political system, where the richest families within it, didn’t have much more power than the ordinary citizen
You presumably haven’t lived in a society where the powerful become wealthy rather than the wealthy becoming powerful.
In republican Rome, the elite families controlled (to a major degree) the expenditures of the state, but their own fortunes waxed and waned. Gaius Julius Caesar came from an old but not especially wealthy family (his was a cadet branch), worked his way up the system (elected a tribune etc — didn’t start at the bottom!) but made his fortune in the usual way, by running Spain and then winning some wars. His chief asset was the Julian name.
His friend amd heir, Augustus inverted this system (e.g. was able to pay the national budget out of his own assets).
Aristocracies worked this way too — you gained or lost wealth due to your power and proximity to the king, not the other way around. In fact if you became too wealthy it could cost you your fortune or even your life.
Modern kleptocracies still operate this way, on scales from Congo to Russia to China.
- rkk3 5y ago> Gaius Julius Caesar came from an old but not especially wealthy family (his was a cadet branch), worked his way up the system (elected a tribune etc — didn’t start at the bottom!) but made his fortune in the usual way, by running Spain and then winning some wars. His chief asset was the Julian name. Gaius Julius Caesar family didn't have the Auctoritas or wealth, but His uncle was Marius, the most important man in Rome and he married at a young age Marius's successor's daughter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Marius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaius_Marius Sharp contrast to Pompey Magnus who was so rich his first foray into public life was using his own funds to raise a private army, without being elected or having imperium, to support Sulla.
- gumby 5y agoYou point out another great factor in the example of Julius Caesar: though he married into wealth he was stripped of it before he had any real power, but was able to use other family connections to get back on his feet.
- moksly 5y agoHow does this dispute what I say? Fortunes change hands, and sometimes people who just so happen to be friends with the Ceasars can suddenly rise to fortune through the positions they achieve through their network, but which of them were able to do so without a rich oligarch? Modern America is probably the best example of people obtaining “elite” status from nothing, but it’s very rare, and it’s the money they obtain on the way that solidify their positions.
- gumby 5y ago> How does this dispute what I say? Fortunes change hands, and sometimes people who just so happen to be friends with the Ceasars can suddenly rise to fortune through the positions they achieve through their network, but which of them were able to do so without a rich oligarch? That is exactly it. The example of Gaius Julius Caesar in particular such an example; he was able to marry into money through family connection, was stripped of it all, but was able to get some crucial positions and claw his way back into power...from which he then became wealthy. Some of the most powerful houses in England (Spencer, Cromwell, Beaufort have been intertwined with the monarchy over the centuries. They queen not even the head of the richest family but by definition she has the most status.