8 ms·
Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production
- dukeofdoom 5y agoScooby-Doo
- harrychin2 5y agoayyyy cmong mang
- dukeofdoom 5y agoNot sure why I got flagged for mentioning Scooby-Doo. The censors have no sense of humour. Shaggy spoke like a stoner and got munchies all the time. "Older teenagers and adults have admitted to enjoying Scooby-Doo because of presumed subversive themes which involve theories of drug use and sexuality, in particular that Shaggy is assumed to be a user of cannabis" -- from wikipedia
- sp332 5y agoThere are gait and hand function differences?
- esarbe 5y agoThis was mentioned in the paper, sounds like an interesting point.
- petee 5y agoThe title seems like a stretch since they then go on to say, "Audio samples were analysed objectively using acoustic analysis for measures of timing, vocal control, and quality. Subtle differences in speech timing, vocal effort, and voice quality may exist between cannabis and control groups, however data remain equivocal." "After controlling for lifetime alcohol and tobacco use and applying a false discovery rate, only spectral tilt (vocal effort and intensity) differed between groups and appeared to change in line with duration of abstinence from cannabis use" Basically no acoustical difference, except in perceived effort. You'd get the same intensity out of a group of tired people too, but that oddly doesn't seem to have been compared in the study
- Alex3917 5y ago> Basically no acoustical difference, except in perceived effort. On the data points measured. It's easy to observe things like "heavy cannabis users tend to have flat affect," but very difficult to translate "flat affect" into something measurable. Look at the way that Alex Grey or Terence McKenna talk. There is clearly something going on there, regardless of our ability to measure it.
- danenania 5y agoIt’s hard to separate the effect of culture. A lot of cannabis users have an affinity for the cannabis sub-culture, or with related ones like the hippie/hipster cultures that have many shared speech patterns. You might see similar results analyzing the speech of surfers, pilots, sorority members, etc.
- esarbe 5y agoTry to remember that if you hear a pilot meowing.
- derekja 5y agodo tell?
- FDSGSG 5y agomeow
- esarbe 5y agoDid you just say 'meow'..?
- esarbe 5y agohttps://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/127118-meow.html https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/127118-meow.html https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/i-had-heard-of-it-but-never-actually-heard-it-meow.123304/ https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/i-had-hear...
- davesque 5y agoCould it have anything to do with subcultural differences among cannabis users and not deleterious physical effects of consumption?
- bperson 5y agoDo these folks study speech and know what to control for at all? Seems there are more critical confounding factors a study is likely to observe before psycho-active drug use is a significant factor https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2790192/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2790192/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sega_sai 5y agoGiven they only had 31 subjects, and the group with cannabis use without cannabis use differed drastically in alcohol and tobacco consumption, I think one should take these results with some degree of caution.
- tiahura 5y agoThe way America’s legalization effort has progressed has been really unfortunate. It seems as though no attempt at finding a middle ground was made, and consequently we wound up with complete legalization. Marijuana is an addictive highly potent mood altering substance that’s become available on demand with no real discussion about the consequences. Will anyone argue that having 15% of the otherwise young and productive demographic zonked out 24hrs a day on “Mint Diesel x AK-47 DDH Live Resin (TM)” gives us an advantage over China? Hyperbolic discounting par excellence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- realce 5y agoBy that logic America should also ban video games because Chinese kids arn't "zonked out" on Fortnite. You're not having a real discussion either, you're employing overblown rhetoric in your request to bring the conversation to a more sane environment. In most states there are limits on purchases for different products. While I totally agree that more regulation should be in place to inform consumers, I cannot at all agree with your rational or verbiage.
- valar_m 5y agoI would argue that the injustice of mass incarceration resulting from inequitable and inconsistently applied drug laws was far more unfortunate and harmful. I say: more legalization, and now.
- esarbe 5y agoFederal legislation is far from finished. Who knows what we end up with. I for one would prefer to pay rehabilitation therapy rather than supporting the ludicrous enforcement apparatus we have now. If someone wants to burn away their brain cells, let them do it. Why involve police and the justice system? Why throw them in jail, where they have even less chance of rehabilitating themselves? I don't need to retread the old discussion "How on earth is alcohol legal?", since the effects of alcohol abuse are so much worse than the effects of marijuana abuse and it's rather hard to OD on the later. But in the end; what do I care? There's the case to be made for protecting young adults, since there's solid evidence that smoking weed is harmful to the developing brain.
- sdeep27 5y agoTo point out the absurdity of this study using only 31 users with varying degrees of other types of drug use, as well as measuring some highly subjective metric, let me offer some purely anecdotal evidence that has a bigger sample size. I can name more than 31 rappers (try me) that have heavy, long-term cannabis use that have fast "speech timing", high "vocal quality", and low "vocal effort" compared to the general population.
- ZoomZoomZoom 5y agoSo? It just shows that rapping might be an effective prevention therapy for this supposed effect.
- omgwtfbyobbq 5y agoWell, supposed effective prevention for the supposed effect.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIt doesn't show that at all. It could mean that that profession selects people who are the best in the world at those things, and cannabis is entirely coincidental.
- howaboutnope 5y ago> You see, I think drugs have done some good things for us. I really do. And if you don't believe drugs have done good things for us, do me a favor. Go home tonight. Take all your albums, all your tapes and all your CDs and burn them. 'Cause you know what, the musicians that made all that great music that's enhanced your lives throughout the years were rrreal fucking high on drugs. The Beatles were so fucking high they let Ringo sing a few tunes. -- Bill Hicks
- SquishyPanda23 5y ago> let me offer some purely anecdotal evidence that has a bigger sample size That is not how science works. And a study isn't absurd just because you don't like its conclusions.
- deegles 5y agoNot convinced a sample size of 31 is enough, but imagine the implications of a ML model that can detect if you’ve used cannabis recently. Seems like a privacy nightmare.
- foxfluff 5y agoWell, the first thing I thought upon reading the headline is someone somewhere is going to build an AI based on this and there will be false positives and it'll suck.
- mlang23 5y agoWow, is it really normal to publish results from such small sample sizes? This feels like tossing dice and publishing the result.
- mountainb 5y agoYeah. There are other tricks to make a tiny n seem more relevant, like making the relevant (tiny) n a subset of a bigger sample, taking many separate samples from different populations and looking for correlations in them separately, and so on. Trust the science.* *Whereas science is defined as getting a certain score in an abstract statistics game.
- mlang23 5y agoWhat I find most problematic is that there is clearly a mix of difference incentives at play. At the one hand, scientists are not getting tired of waving the scientific method about to the uninitiated. Claiming science has no agenda and is only interested in hard data. But on the other hand, it is rather clear that the career of individual scientists depends on how much they publish. Yes, there is peer review, but no, that doesnt help, because people form networks and have friends and allies. So, how do we ensure that the common people trust science more? I think we should start by ridiculing publications like this, if the scientific community by itself is not capable of filtering such noise out.
- sideshowb 5y agoYes. Though it's also normal that whatever your sample size, someone will always complain it wasn't bigger.
- jMyles 5y agoOthers have pointed out the flaws in this study. I want to add: at first blush, the basic premise seems plausible on its face. I bet I'd be able to pick out many long-time regular cannabis consumers (of whom I'm one) based on audio recordings of their conversational voice.
- robocat 5y ago> based on audio recordings of their conversational voice While they are high??
- Animats 5y agoThe sample size is too small to be definitive. But that could be fixed by doing the same tests in smartphone voice recognition programs and providing the results to advertisers. Facebook probably has enough information already to recognize cannabis users.
- newbie789 5y ago> Subtle differences in speech timing, vocal effort, and voice quality may exist between cannabis and control groups, however data remain equivocal. Sorry but this is straight up goofy. Stoners maybe sound a little different subjectively sometimes in a subtle way but scientists can’t prove it? Who is this information for? What is the purpose of this?
- newbamboo 5y agoReminds me of Bem’s ESP research. https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-proved-esp-is-real-showed-science-is-broken.html https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-prove...
- cronix 5y agoIs recreational cannabis somehow different than medical cannabis? Why specifically mention "recreational" at all instead of just cannabis itself? If you're taking it medically and in a comparable quantity/frequency, somehow it doesn't affect speech?
- scythe 5y ago>Differences between groups may reflect longer term changes to the underlying neural control of speech. A simpler hypothesis: Cannabis smoke is hot and messes with your throat. No need to invoke mysterious neural changes. See also: links between hot beverage consumption and throat cancer.
- mcbuilder 5y agoI've been a recreational Cannabis smoker for almost 20 years, since I was 14, and smoking it 100% has a noticeable effect on my speech. People, also stoners mind you, will make fun of me for it because of the level of effects it has on me. For instance, they would say I'm actually a model for why people shouldn't smoke pot (again these are users). Anyway, these effects go away with abstinence, but generally take up to a month to really go away (not that I've had many breaks that long in the last 20 years). Yes, weed effects my speech, but also other activities that involve hand-eye coordination or heavy thinking, such as sports, video games, programming, learning mathematics, etc. It's not a huge stretch of the imagination (and a theory supported by research) that short term neurochemical changes will result in longer term structural, i.e. syntactical, changes in the brain. There is a lot understood about this type of mechanism (I did a PhD in computational neuroscience, so I've seen and understood the research in this area).
- ffggvv 5y agohow’d i know every comment would reflexively try to find holes in the study. it’s funny i don’t see the same gusto for finding flaws in pro cannabis “studies” where it supposedly cures cancer and every other disease
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoThe real question is are the audio samples publicly available? > only spectral tilt (vocal effort and intensity) I can sort of picture what 'vocal effort' & 'intensity' mean but they are assumptions. Really would be nice to have some examples.
- GoodJokes 5y agoHackernews desperately needs a science moderator. These studies are an utter waste of time.