2 ms·
> Because his phone number was in my address book (so I could block him) Signal thought it had the right to let him know he can now contact me. Nope. Because y
by tialaramex 5y ago
> Because his phone number was in my address book (so I could block him) Signal thought it had the right to let him know he can now contact me.
Nope. Because your number was in his address book, his device periodically asks Signal "Hey, can I use Signal to message this contact?" and once you use Signal it says "Yes". The fact he's in your contacts means, by default, your phone thinks you know each other and it should provide information like your preferred name and photo if asked. Of course if you've got the number in there "so I could block him" you should... block him. In Signal too. Having blocked him, your phone won't provide your information and he can't contact you on Signal.
Under the hood if you do this, your phone ignores Signal messages from this number but it also mints fresh "postage stamps" for Signal's anonymous sender capability, it won't give the new ones to the newly blocked person and the old ones no longer work, so your actual friends can get new stamps and send you messages without even Signal being able to tell who sent them, but blocked people can't waste the service's time sending messages you won't even see.
This capability is necessary for Signal to function as something more than a fun "secret decoder ring" for a small circle of nerds. Without it for example, the ex-colleague I suddenly needed to contact a month ago wouldn't have been reached over Signal, he had no reason to tell me, a person he rarely talks to, that he's got Signal since we last met, but since his phone does have Signal, and my phone checked my contact list, it knew that Signal would work and it transparently used Signal for the conversation.
- mmerlin 5y agoYeah good point on the program logic there. I uninstalled Signal instead of blocking him