5 ms·
Very hard to see how they can discount confounding correlates to diesel particulate and other PM10 and finer materials, brake dust &c. Not that I don't think t
by ggm 5y ago
Very hard to see how they can discount confounding correlates to diesel particulate and other PM10 and finer materials, brake dust &c.
Not that I don't think the science is good, I'm sure they do and the article says they do, but I struggle to see how you can isolate noise from particulate exposure: they'd have semi identical square law dropoff by distance and volume.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe article says: “The results are strengthened by the authors controlling for levels of traffic pollution, which was recently shown to be associated with dementia as well as other diseases.”
- jstanley 5y agoHow can you possibly control for traffic pollution in a way that is independent from traffic noise?
- lathiat 5y agoWith ear plugs apparently. But then you have an entirely different control problem.
- nerdponx 5y agoSkimming the article [0], it looks like they compared outcomes of people who lived closer to the road against people who lived farther away from the road, in the same building. I think the idea is that people living in the same building should all have roughly the same particulate and pollution exposure, but people living on a road-facing side of the building will have more exposure to road noise. It's an extremely clever study design. 0: https://www.bmj.com/content/374/bmj.n1954 https://www.bmj.com/content/374/bmj.n1954
- hardlianotion 5y agoIf the assumption is that people in the same building have the same exposure to pollution but differential exposure to noise based on distance, I would prefer that it were tested. I am sceptical that this is the case, as I would expect folk on the road facing side to be exposed to more particulates and pollution and noise.
- nerdponx 5y agoThat's a good point, and I didn't read far enough in the paper to see if they tested that assumption or not. It seems like they developed some kind of model of noise exposure as a function of elevation and proximity to the road, so it's possible they developed a similar model for pollution.
- Goety 5y agoWe dont have an accurate assessment of traffic pollution or air pollution in general. Thanks 'regulatory agencies'
- dannyw 5y agoTwo ways I can think of: 1. Electric trains wont generate diesel particulate, but will generate road noise. 2. It's relatively straightforward to measure pollution and noise, so you can do analysis to try and separate them. In many situations these would not be correlated exactly. For example, terrain, wind patterns, noise dampening structures, etc.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> 1. Electric trains wont generate diesel particulate, but will generate road noise. They don't generate diesel particulate, by they do generate "other PM10 and finer particulate", from the brakes for example. In Paris there's a lawsuit against the RATP (local transit authority) for particulate pollution inside the stations. [0] There's also the fact that, at least in Paris, some metros are running on tires. For those that run on metal wheels and rails, some turns are quite sharp, and you can hear the screeching of the metal. This is likely to contribute to particulate pollution. I suppose for overground trains, this is less of an issue. --- [0] https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20210323-french-ngo-sues-paris-metro-operator-over-critical-pollution-levels-air-environment-health https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20210323-french-ngo-sues-paris-...
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoThey could adapt the system of [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Metro#Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Metro#Design Popcorn!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fighterpilot 5y agoExcept road noise was associated with dementia and train noise wasn't, which suggests it's pollution related according to your (1) The other problem is that people that live near noise are poorer. Did they control for wealth? These epidemiological observational studies are so hard to take seriously. I get why so many of them are done though. It's a relatively lower effort way to get publications out the door, all you need is a dataset and a few days in python.