3 ms·
My grandma struggles to use a computer. She has no real ability to scan a UI or intuit where she needs to click. She rarely remembers even basic operations, so
by jdietrich 15y ago
My grandma struggles to use a computer. She has no real ability to scan a UI or intuit where she needs to click. She rarely remembers even basic operations, so she writes them down in a notepad, step by step:
1) Click on "File" in top left of screen
2) Click on "Print" in drop-down menu
3) On new screen, click little up arrow next to right hand number for more copies
4) Click "Print" button in bottom right of new screen
If she is unsure how to proceed or accidentally clicks the wrong thing, she has essentially no ability to recover; Her usual solution is to restart the computer and begin from scratch. Even after years of using a computer, she has no sense of what GUI metaphors mean and relies upon memorising a series of incantations by rote.
Unsurprisingly, she finds her computer to be frustrating, opaque and a little bit frightening. I have absolutely no doubt that she would be happier and more productive in a suitable CLI environment. I don't think she is alone in this and in many respects I feel that WordPerfect 5.1 was a high-water mark in computer usability. A modern GUI simply presents too much information for someone with a slow OODA loop to process. In a GUI, all actions are mutable and a user must constantly be aware of what mode they are in, what window is active, what menu is selected and so on. A CLI requires no situational awareness beyond the current working directory.
I think it's easy for mid-level users to forget the amount of accumulated knowledge they have, how honed their intuition is, how well they understand the implicit grammar of interfaces. When we view the world through the eyes of someone with no cognitive model of how a computer works, we can see that uttering incantations into a CLI is far more straightforward than trying to navigate the labyrinths of modern GUIs.