4 ms·
> The books of the Deuterocanon are not viewed as canonical by most Christian churches for a number of valid reasons The phrase by most Christian churches is s
by skissane 5y ago
> The books of the Deuterocanon are not viewed as canonical by most Christian churches for a number of valid reasons
The phrase by most Christian churches is somewhat misleading. Weighting them by number of adherents, most Christian churches do accept the Deuterocanon as canonical. Two out of the three major historical branches of Christianity (Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant) count them as canonical (*). The fissiparous nature of Protestantism means that Protestants form the vast majority of Christian denominations, counting each denomination as one regardless of its size–in spite of the fact that Protestants are a minority of all Christians.
And I don't agree that the reasons you give are valid – in some places I think you have the facts wrong, or are presenting them in a biased way. I don't think this site is the best place to debate it in detail, but you can find numerous works by Catholic and Orthodox writers rebutting the arguments you make.
(*) Some count more than three major branches – such as by splitting the Orthodox into Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox – but doing that still leaves Protestants the odd ones out
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ImpressiveWebs 5y ago> The phrase by most Christian churches is somewhat misleading. As someone else pointed out, I'm not talking about every individual church as a separate 'Christian church', I'm referring to the primary denominations, so Catholocism and Eastern Orthodox would be two churches. Most of the rest do not accept those books as part of the Bible canon. > And I don't agree that the reasons you give are valid – in some places I think you have the facts wrong, or are presenting them in a biased way. When it comes to religion, every view is biased. But that's ok if a view is correct. I'm looking at the facts based on what happened prior to all the offshoots of Christianity (including Catholicism, which didn't even exist until at least 300 years after Christ). The purely historical argument, outside of any denomination makes it clear that the Deuterocanonical books were not considered part of the Bible canon. > I don't think this site is the best place to debate it in detail, I think it's fine if we remain civil. > but you can find numerous works by Catholic and Orthodox writers rebutting the arguments you make. They are just as biased as I am. But like I said, I'm not looking at any denominational argument, I'm only looking at the facts of history prior to ~300 CE.
- hitekker 5y agoLouis, this sounds like a conspiracy theory. A huge, controversial claim with misleading points, a belief that everyone is biased yet only you are "looking at the facts", a fervent desire to keep arguing on a technology-focused forum, and an ignorance of the links shared in the thread so far. If you really want to set the record straight, the place to do so is in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterocanonical_books https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterocanonical_books. You can edit the page and see what the theologians and experts on Wikipedia have to say about a frontend enthusiast's view on Biblical Historicity.
- ImpressiveWebs 5y agoWhat part of that Wikipedia document do you think contradicts what I've said? The lede says: > Although there is no scholarly consensus as to when the Hebrew Bible canon was fixed, some scholars hold that the Hebrew canon was established well before the first century AD – even as early as the fourth century BC, or by the Hasmonean dynasty (140–40 BC). The modern Hebrew canon does not include the seven deuterocanonical books, and this was the basis for excluding them from the Protestant Old Testament. And: > Since the 16th century, most Protestant churches have accepted only works in the Masoretic Text of the Hebrew Bible as the canonical Old Testament, and hence classify all the non-protocanonical books from the Septuagint as apocrypha. Those two points more or less support the points I'm making. Of course much of this is debatable, I'm not denying that, but I think the preponderance of evidence strongly suggests that these books don't belong.
- skissane 5y agoYou say the preponderance of evidence strongly suggests that these books don't belong. Meanwhile Wikipedia says there is no scholarly consensus as to when the Hebrew Bible canon was fixed. Don't you think your statement and Wikipedia's are somewhat in conflict? It also says some scholars hold that the Hebrew canon was established well before the first century AD – even as early as the fourth century BC, or by the Hasmonean dynasty – but that is just the opinion of some scholars, and other scholars disagree. Contrary to the opinion of those scholars, I think there is good evidence that the canon was not fixed that early. The fact that Mishnah Yadayim records 2nd century CE Rabbis debating whether Qohelet(Ecclesiastes) and Song of Songs belonged in the canon or not is evidence that the Pharisees did not finish fixing their canon until the 2nd century CE, by which point Christianity had already begun to separate into a separate religion, and most Christians did not feel bound by the Pharisees' decisions.