3 ms·
Case against indentation! Alice was not a bit hurt, and she jumped up on to her feet in a moment: she
by kazinator 5y ago
Case against indentation!
Alice
was
not a bit hurt,
and
she
jumped up
on to her feet
in a moment:
she
looked up,
but
it was all dark overhead;
before her was another long passage,
and
the White Rabbit
was
still in sight,
hurrying down it.
I mean, just look at it. Would you read a whole book like this? You can't see the semantics for all the obsession with syntax.
Case against multi-file projects! Would you read a book if you had to go back to a Makefile or other project artifact to figure out where the next chapter is? Come on, put the whole damn program in one file that reads from top to bottom!
Case against local variables:
but
let P = "another long passage"
it was all dark overhead;
before her was P,
and
the White Rabbit
was
still in sight,
hurrying down P
This is now totally unnatural "STEM speak". Use the good old ambigous anaphoric pronouns, or GTFO!
- tetha 5y agoYour first example might actually be really nice in something like a math paper. Something that follows a somewhat rigid premises-argument-conclusion format. For prose, it's obviously silly, because one point and one goal of prose is to keep the reader in the dark about many wonderful things - or even mislead them to suprise them. So techniques that allow for an easier skimming and back-and-forth (like I did to compare example #2 with example #1) are detrimental there.
- mcv 5y agoWhile I agree with your argument that the comparison with fiction is nonsensical, I'd actually like to try reading a book like that. I'm a slow reader, and I wonder if indenting based on the structure of the sentence might help me.