4 ms·
It's been this way since they launched, hasn't it? I tell you what would be really nice: a browser that lets me click & launch into reader mode directly. None
by tomrod 5y ago
It's been this way since they launched, hasn't it?
I tell you what would be really nice: a browser that lets me click & launch into reader mode directly.
None of these shenanigans with Turing complete JS. Just give me text to read.
- julianlam 5y agoCan you not do this with browsers? Turning off JS should get rid of most of the egregious stuff, and I think at least Firefox lets you strip out CSS and inject your own (or if not, then via plugin like Greasemonkey)...
- tomrod 5y agoMaybe? The experience would be: - Normal model with JS on (modulo ad blocker/flash blocker) - Oh, hey, a site that plays shenanigans with text! - Rightclick, open in reader view
- gumby 5y ago> I tell you what would be really nice: a browser that lets me click & launch into reader mode directly. Safari can be set to use reader mode by default (then you can tell it to ignore individual sites). I use it in this mode.
- tomrod 5y agoSafari is stuck in the dark ages of Apple lockin, isn't it?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Safari is stuck in the dark ages of Apple lockin, isn't it? Why would Apple be obligated or even incentivised to make their browser for other operating systems?
- tomrod 5y agoSame reason smart musicians embraced Napster. Led to more sales as the world shifted to streaming. In what world would they not want their browser to be used?
- gumby 5y agoThey used to support Safari for Windows but it was a lot of work. It was worth it so that developers using Windows had a change of testing for Safari as well. Once the iphone came out and Macs became popular development machines in their own right, the burden of supporting Safari on Windows stopped mattering. In Google's case the opposite applies: they don't have a development platform but need ubiquity because collecting user data is their reason for being. So they need to support a lot of platforms for the sake of their customers' (i.e. companies buying ads).
- gumby 5y agoI'm not sure I would call it "lockin" but yes, it only runs on Apple devices. You asked if any browser does this, and I said that one did. Other browsers supported by your browsing history are unlikely to make this change.
- tomrod 5y agoTotally fair take. Seems like it should be an easy plugin. I'll see if firefox has anything.
- skyfaller 5y agoEveryone talks about how complicated browsers and the modern web are, and how impossible it is to make a new browser engine, even Microsoft gave up... What about a reader mode browser engine? Couldn't you make a great browser from scratch by limiting it to this use case?
- btdmaster 5y agoPerhaps imperfect, but how about [1]? [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/automatic-reader-view/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/automatic-rea...