8 ms·
Luck in Wesnoth: Rationale (2008)
- reidjs 5y agoI love analyzing game mechanics. I haven’t played Wesnoth, but other games that handle luck well are Darkest Dungeon and Faster Than Light. The article makes a good point about how a lot of the challenge is in distinguishing bad luck + good strategy vs normal luck + bad strategy
- haolez 5y agoYeah, I feel that. Some weeks ago, I was playing Battle Brothers and I lost a game because I failed three 80% checks in a row. It was incredible bad luck, but the decision to "all in" in these three checks was mine. Maybe I could've found a strategy that wouldn't ruin me in case a check fails, regardless of how high its probability is.
- bee_rider 5y agoI've played this game a bunch, mostly in the player-vs-computer mode. Maybe removing luck would work for player-vs-player mode, but against the computer it would just reduce the game to feeling like a puzzle. Planning contingencies and managing risk is the main skill the game tests, and what gives it the 'battle game' feeling. There's an observation to be made in these game -- people wouldn't complain about the dice, if their plans didn't fall apart when they missed a roll. The problem is in the fragility of the plans.
- dragontamer 5y agoWesnoth has a scaling problem for its difficulty curve in general. Because level 2 (and lvl3, lvl4) units are so much better than base units (especially since they only cost 20 gold to pull out...), you often times end up in a situation where the developers had either more units than you, or fewer units than you, at particular points of a campaign. For long campaigns with like 20 levels, it leads to innate imbalances. If you managed to keep your units alive and coming back in all levels, you'll have a much easier job at the end than another player who lost a unit once or twice. ----------- The fact of the matter is: an Orc Warrior with 50% night attack bonus with 10 damage per swing x 3 can one-shot your tier1, and even tier2 units. Your typical land routes have 40% evade, meaning there's a 21% chance that the Orc Warrior hits with all attacks and deals 45 damage, more than enough to kill any tier 1, and most tier2 units. And you have nothing you can do about it. Even if you mitigated this issue to the max: say with an Elvish Sorceress in a Treeline (70% evade), there's still a 2.7% chance she dies. There's no higher evade than 70% in the game, and Sorceresses / Archers (with 70% evade) have rather low HP to boot. So you're ultimately relying upon luck to survive the night-attacks by Orcs. Losing that Elvish Captain or Sorceress early in the campaign very well could lead into cascading failures, an inability to complete say the 9th chapter (when things get difficult). -------- Sure, there's a day/night cycle. But campaigns inevitably lead to night-only scenarios (ex: caves) where you have to just deal with Orc Warriors and their 20% chance to literally one-shot any unit of yours, with no way to reasonably beat back the night-bonus. (No forests exist inside of caves, so you have no opportunity to reach 70% evasion). ------ Orc Warriors are among the more "fair" units as well. I recall maps with "lancers", who are daytime units and level 2, but with 12x3 attack. Except... lancers deal double-damage to all units (and all units deal double damage to lancers). So really, lancers are 24x3 on the charge, before the daytime "sun" bonus kicks that up to crazy numbers. With a crazy 10 movement, you can't even outrun these guys or hope to fight them at the night time. They have the highest movement in the game. As such, your only plan is to send units in, and hope that they miss. If lancers get lucky, your units die and I guess you just restart the level. There's no strategy to it: your units have 6 movement, and lancers have 10. You just gotta run in there and hope for the best. ---------- Strangely enough: I think luck in the PvP world is a bit more fair. I'm well accustomed to games of chance (Pokemon, Backgammon, Poker) in the competitive world. Furthermore: the PvP world in Wesnoth is mainly played with tier1 units (so no "luck factor" in determining if your tier2 units survive: because you simply don't have any tier2 units in battle). The games end up more fair. Maybe the enemy gets lucky and kills my tier1 elf fighter due to luck. Oh well, it was only 14 gold, and I can build another. The campaign is where stupid lancers feel like you're just playing vs a slot machine however. A line of enemy lancers just isn't fun to go up against. There's no strategy involved in fighting vs it (and it also would never come up in a PvP setting, since Knights are often times a superior unit over lancers and are the preferred promotion path)
- bee_rider 5y agoThe Orc infantry line has big attacks and pays for it with high damage variance (and also a total lack of ranged attacks until T3, which can leave them quite vulnerable). The solution is to avoid fighting them full powered at night with your valuable units -- sacrifice some T1 units if you have to, hit the orc with a bunch of archers, slow them with a Shaman to reduce their damage. Caves are particular challenges, and of course there's a map editor so somebody can just design a really poorly balanced campaign. But the Wose fairs not too bad in a cave because, well, they weren't really planning on evading anyway. E: Regarding this lancer issue -- sounds like a bad map, but even the biggest attack can only kill one unit per turn. Set your T1's up to block your good units. Then, get revenge on your turn. Plus, as a bonus, Charge works both ways -- some of your T1's might get some big hits in or even some kills.
- dragontamer 5y agoOrc Warriors aren't even the highest variance in the game though! That's just... typical Wesnoth. Really, Orc Warriors don't have much more variance than Elvish Heroes. When we start talking Horsemen, Lancers, Thunderguards, Ulfserkers, Griffons, Wraiths... these are the real "high variance" units of Wesnoth. (Wraiths have self-healing on their hits. So its very "sharp" when they hit. If they "get lucky", a Wraith may be at full health after killing 3 units, because they self-healed). EDIT: Oh yeah, and Trolls too have way more variance. That's the thing: the default level of variance in Wesnoth is really damn high. Far more variance in this game than pretty much everything else I've ever played. And when we get into the lol "variance as a strategy units" (aka: lancers/wraiths), its pretty much like playing against a slot machine. > The solution is to avoid fighting them full powered at night with your valuable units -- sacrifice some T1 units if you have to, hit the orc with a bunch of archers, slow them with a Shaman to reduce their damage. 2x attacks from the Shaman is pretty low accuracy. Assuming your typical 40% evade chance, there's a 16% chance that your shaman misses both slow-attacks. If the Orc is standing on its advantaged hill or mountain terrain, you're basically screwed (slow probably will miss more often than hit). No T1 unit has a chance of killing an Orc Warrior. None at all. Slow is probably your best bet (-50% damage), but its really not that reliable of a strategy.
- setr 5y agoPersonally I prefer fudged dice (I forget the proper term) where expected damage is maintained, but low rolls and high rolls are dampened on repeats, to avoid low-chance sequences of misses/crits. In fact, I’d go further to say it’s fundamentally correct — repeat bad/great swings of the sword is too rare to really account for, has no real basis in “reality” and is purely an artifact of the simplified simulation. Their occurrence adds no value to the strategy, by either arbitrarily trivializing or exploding risk as to be untenable. It’s removal also eliminates the majority of the “unfairness” of the dice — 80% feels like 80%.
- bee_rider 5y agoI think this is fine if you don't show an '80%' there. If you show it, it skews the player's perception of what 80% means. 80% is a 1-in-5 chance of failure. 80% chance of success should mean "I should have a solid backup plan here."
- setr 5y agoThe problem is accounting for the 1-25, 1-125, 1-625 possibilities that are still legal, but you can’t meaningfully do anything about (and a 1-625 crit sequence trivializes any boss fight, and a 1-625 miss sequence makes a trivial enemy impossibly powerful). It really amounts to a 1-625 chance that combat just breaks down altogether. Another alternative is you have so many rolls individual rolls don’t matter (e.g. mass combat), or you have such cheap restarts / difficulty that a 1-625 game breakage doesn’t matter (ADnD, roguelikes). Tail risk is probably a the least interesting type of risk, unless the game is specifically designed for it (it runs long enough that encountering a tail risk is an expected proposition)
- lmm 5y agoHmm, IMO tail risks are the most interesting type of risk - just handling a certain amount of normal variance is uninteresting, it's the tails that are memorable and create stories.
- 5y ago
- retsibsi 5y agoThis is why I like games with an execution element as well as a decision-making element. If the execution is challenging, you get dynamism and unpredictability for free, without taking anything out of the player's hands.
- rpmisms 5y agoI adore this game, big nostalgia trip for me, and the luck system is what makes it great. Really feels like a D&D campaign.
- pugworthy 5y agoPeople do seem to detest the concept of random number generators in games. They feel like the "luck" is completely out of their control. Yet if you give a player a set of dice to give them perceived control over the random number generator, they are much more happy. Dungeons and Dragons and other dice-based RPGs are a great example. If they roll a 20, they are overjoyed with the results and feel incredibly lucky. If they roll a 1 they are sad or mad, but chalk it up to bad luck. But if it's a random number generator that they have no control over, they feel it's "random" and there is no luck. And they blame the random number generator for bad results. Even if it's just the same as using dice, without the physical interaction. I've always thought that even if you just let the player click a button to activate the random number generator, you give them a sense of control. Perhaps you let them hold the button down for a while just like how players rattle the dice for longer hoping for "luck" in the results.
- BizarroLand 5y agoYou could make a spinning color-wheel circle that the player places their mouse into whose x & y coordinates on click are multiplied by the hex value of the color that happens to be under the mouse pointer on click to generate the seed for the random number generator or you could just make a button that says, "Click here when you feel lucky". No one would be able to tell the difference.
- pugworthy 5y agoOh totally. It's all theater really. Random number generators wrapped up in theater and superstition. That said, you can't ignore it since it's about perception not fact usually. And at the same time, sometimes the "it's so random!" complaints are real. I remember finding a bug in Valve's shot pattern code based on players complaining about how our FPS shots were "off". It should have done a concentrated shot pattern, with more shots in the center of the aiming circle than the edges. But it wasn't, and ended up being a total random distribution. Changing it to have a greater weighted chance in the middle greatly improved the "feel" of the guns. Even then when firing a real gun, nobody ever complains about "random number generators" when they don't hit their target. That's because they really feel like their ability to aim and hold a target in the sites is a critical part of the process of obtaining accurate results. Again like dice, a situation where the participant feels like they can actually influence the outcome - and in the case of a real gun, they actually can.
- sfink 5y agoSomeone I play with got really frustrated at getting perpetually bad rolls in Settlers of Catan, to the point of no longer wanting to play. So I wrote down two copies of all possible rolls (such that they end up weighted appropriately) on small pieces of paper, and we cycle through them all. For that game, at least, it feels much better and feels more "fair". (It does add an element of "card" counting, but none of us are serious enough to pay that much attention. At most, we remember whether the 2 or 12 has come up yet.)
- fiddlerwoaroof 5y agoThere's an interesting "mod" for games involving die rolls where you replace each dice with a set of numbers that the player can just pick, with the limitation that each "die" must use each number once before reusing any.