3 ms·
Well, suppose I want to find my friend Jameson Soulblighter on Google+, but I can't because his real name is Henry Jones, and since I know him from online rathe
by dagw 15y ago
Well, suppose I want to find my friend Jameson Soulblighter on Google+, but I can't because his real name is Henry Jones, and since I know him from online rather than real life, I had no idea. Now I'll never get back in touch with him.
I know enough people online that I'd consider friends and yet I don't know their full legal name.
- philwelch 15y agoIt's probably fair to say that if you are close friends with certain people and yet don't know their real names, you're already keeping in touch with them somewhere on the internet anyway, and how completely different people use completely different websites is frankly not your business.
- darklajid 15y ago> how completely different people use completely different websites is frankly not your business. Likewise? This is not helpful. Some people want their pseudonym as 'main' handle, optionally adding their real name _if they please_. That would solve the usecase further above. Other people want to use their real name and _keep other people out unless they comply_. I really don't get it how you can try to put it different while keeping a straight face.
- philwelch 15y agooptionally adding their real name _if they please_. That would solve the usecase further above. Um, one of the primary use cases of a social network is to search for people you know in real life by their real names. Making that entire thing "optional" hinders that. If your primary use case is to use a pseudonym, the entire rest of the web is more or less set up for you that way already.
- darklajid 15y agoHow can you state that as an absolute truth? For you (and maybe a lot of people, granted) the primary use case seems to be "Hey, let's search for that guy I know". For me it's not. I _still_ like to use these networks. Along the whole thread you failed to provide a single decent argument why other people need to use their real name except for "_I_ want to find them like that". Great. But this attitude is not what I'd consider social in the first place. If I'm darklajid on G+ or not, you don't see it. If your own friends in real life _want_ to connect with you in a social network, they better make sure that you can find them or write 'Puffy1982' on a napkin in that bar you meet and tell you to look them up using that pseudonym. Do you only meet people that give you their full name? You go out, and everyone in a pub introduces himself as 'Hi, my name is John Smith' so that you're able to find them on Facebook? Or is it rather like 'Hey, I'm Ben. Nice to meet you'. And - y'know what? I'm Benjamin according to my passport and you still don't have my last name. No way to find me with only that bits of information. So your use case falls apart for casual encounters, unless you already exchange explicit details. "Hey, can you add me on Facebook? You find me as ..." works with pseudonyms just that well. Don't say real names are easier to remember, write or pronounce or I have a huge pile of counter examples. Countering the last open point: If you want to (for example) find your old class mates from primary school by their real name, there are sites for that. They specialize on this particular need of yours. That is not a primary function of a social network in my personal opinion. Bottom line: Your use case is not universal, you can do whatever you like. Consider returning the favor to others.
- philwelch 15y agoFor you (and maybe a lot of people, granted) the primary use case seems to be "Hey, let's search for that guy I know". For me it's not. I _still_ like to use these networks. Well, those sites are obviously designed around that use case. So your use case falls apart for casual encounters, unless you already exchange explicit details. "Hey, can you add me on Facebook? You find me as ..." works with pseudonyms just that well. Personally, if I meet someone only once or twice and don't know their full name yet, I'm not going to add them as a friend on Facebook. That said, you can use contact information, partial names, your friends' friends lists, and recognizing someone's face in their profile picture as ways of narrowing someone down. If I meet you in real life, you're not going to introduce yourself as darkajid, you're going to introduce yourself as Ben. If you're listed on a social network as Benjamin Foo and you're already a couple degrees away from me, I can search for "Ben" and the search algorithm will most likely pop up "Benjamin Foo" with a recognizable photo of you. Outside of social networking sites, it's the predominant social norm to use a handle. Without pressuring or requiring people to use their real names, people by and large wouldn't use their real names and the sites wouldn't be usable. Countering the last open point: If you want to (for example) find your old class mates from primary school by their real name, there are sites for that. And they're slowly dying because no one wants to sign up for a single purpose site just to do that. They've been replaced by Facebook.