4 ms·

Ask HN: Which Covid vax did you select and why?

5 points by SQL2219 5y ago

Appreciate some feedback, I have to make a decision soon. J&J, Moderna, Pfizer, or waiting on Novavax?

SQL2219 5y ago
not a lot of data out there on comparison of brands, I did run across this one: https://imgur.com/yMA3Wsg https://imgur.com/yMA3Wsg would you recommend throwing darts?
- cpach 5y ago
  “would you recommend throwing darts?” Sure, why not.
Bostonian 5y ago
In some cases you don't get to choose. Our Massachusetts town had a 1-day vaccination clinic, and when you showed up you got what was available.
cpach 5y ago
I got Pfizer. That was the one I was able to get the earliest. It worked fine, IIRC I didn’t experience any side effects.
justforcovaxin 5y ago
Covaxin
sircastor 5y ago
I didn’t get a choice (this was back in April) and got Pfizer. I do recall hearing at the time that the J&J vaccine had a 60% efficacy rate, whereas the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were in the 90s. I don’t know if that understand is still true.
softwaredoug 5y ago
J&J because I was caring for my dying mother at the time. Appointments for J&J were plentiful at the time and it got to immunity fastest
ksherlock 5y ago
There are some suggestions that Moderna might be longer lasting than Pfizer due to a larger payload and the 4 week delay (vs 3 weeks) for the second dose. They're all better than invermectin.
71a54xd 5y ago
Moderna, it was the fastest available in NYC and I was turned down for the Pfizer vaccine (even though I had an underlying condition) because some pharmacist in Manhattan said I "looked to young and healthy". I didn't feel anything on the first dose, second dose gave me insane dreams and night sweats.
approxim8ion 5y ago
AstraZeneca. Neither Moderna nor Pfizer were available and AZ seemed a better choice than Sputnik or any other available vaccine at the time.
AnimalMuppet 5y ago
J&J, but not by deliberate choice. I just went into the pharmacy to get a prescription filled, and they said, "Hey, we've got this extra dose, do you want it?" J&J has the virtue of only taking one shot instead of two. So that probably is the one I would have preferred anyway, because getting shot is, um, not my favorite activity.
bradknowles 5y ago
Didn’t have a choice. When we signed up, we didn’t know what would be available where. Our biggest fight was trying to find a place that would give us an appointment at all. Through a tip from a friend, we found a place nearby that had been in the phase 1a period for a while, and had not done any vaccinations recently — no one in that group wanted them, at least not from that provider. So, they moved on to phase 1b, and we were able to quickly get an appointment with them. A couple of days later, the whole vaccination process became much more centralized, and we would never have been able to get vaccinated as early as we did. But, they grandfathered everyone who’d already gotten their first shots, so we were okay. We ended up with Moderna.
shivenigma 5y ago
You guys were getting options? I was looking for vaccine madly to be opened up for my age group in India, I had to go with the first available option which is CovieShield.

5 points by SQL2219 5y ago

Appreciate some feedback, I have to make a decision soon. J&J, Moderna, Pfizer, or waiting on Novavax?

not a lot of data out there on comparison of brands, I did run across this one: https://imgur.com/yMA3Wsg https://imgur.com/yMA3Wsg would you recommend throwing darts?

cpach 5y ago
“would you recommend throwing darts?” Sure, why not.

Bostonian 5y ago

In some cases you don't get to choose. Our Massachusetts town had a 1-day vaccination clinic, and when you showed up you got what was available.

cpach 5y ago

I got Pfizer. That was the one I was able to get the earliest. It worked fine, IIRC I didn’t experience any side effects.

justforcovaxin 5y ago

Covaxin

sircastor 5y ago

I didn’t get a choice (this was back in April) and got Pfizer. I do recall hearing at the time that the J&J vaccine had a 60% efficacy rate, whereas the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines were in the 90s. I don’t know if that understand is still true.

softwaredoug 5y ago

J&J because I was caring for my dying mother at the time. Appointments for J&J were plentiful at the time and it got to immunity fastest

ksherlock 5y ago

There are some suggestions that Moderna might be longer lasting than Pfizer due to a larger payload and the 4 week delay (vs 3 weeks) for the second dose. They're all better than invermectin.

71a54xd 5y ago

Moderna, it was the fastest available in NYC and I was turned down for the Pfizer vaccine (even though I had an underlying condition) because some pharmacist in Manhattan said I "looked to young and healthy". I didn't feel anything on the first dose, second dose gave me insane dreams and night sweats.

approxim8ion 5y ago

AstraZeneca. Neither Moderna nor Pfizer were available and AZ seemed a better choice than Sputnik or any other available vaccine at the time.

AnimalMuppet 5y ago

J&J, but not by deliberate choice. I just went into the pharmacy to get a prescription filled, and they said, "Hey, we've got this extra dose, do you want it?" J&J has the virtue of only taking one shot instead of two. So that probably is the one I would have preferred anyway, because getting shot is, um, not my favorite activity.

bradknowles 5y ago

Didn’t have a choice. When we signed up, we didn’t know what would be available where. Our biggest fight was trying to find a place that would give us an appointment at all. Through a tip from a friend, we found a place nearby that had been in the phase 1a period for a while, and had not done any vaccinations recently — no one in that group wanted them, at least not from that provider. So, they moved on to phase 1b, and we were able to quickly get an appointment with them. A couple of days later, the whole vaccination process became much more centralized, and we would never have been able to get vaccinated as early as we did. But, they grandfathered everyone who’d already gotten their first shots, so we were okay. We ended up with Moderna.

shivenigma 5y ago

You guys were getting options? I was looking for vaccine madly to be opened up for my age group in India, I had to go with the first available option which is CovieShield.