5 ms·
The issue here is cows and their digestive system. Chicken is a perfectly reasonable substitute for beef. > There are no healthy cheapand safe alternatives to
by Retric 5y ago
The issue here is cows and their digestive system. Chicken is a perfectly reasonable substitute for beef.
> There are no healthy cheapand safe alternatives to meat.
There are over a 600 million people are living cheaply and safely on vegetarian diets. I love Meat, it’s tasty and delicious, but it’s very much a luxury.
- 6d6b73 5y agoSteak vs chicken breast? That's not an alternative not only from the taste stand point but also nutrionally.
- timeon 5y agoNutritionally it is more than good enough.
- nindalf 5y agoPlease enlighten us, what’s missing nutritionally in chicken that you can find in steak?
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoLots of delicious saturated fat, for one.
- Retric 5y agoEating a Chicken drumstick is more nutritious and healthier than a steak. That connective tissue is good for you. Chicken breast has more protein, less fat, less cholesterol, less saturated fat. Beef has slightly more iron and zinc but is overall significantly worse for you. That said their both missing vitamin C [edit: after cooking], so you need a more diverse diet anyway.
- wyager 5y ago> Chicken breast has more protein, less fat, less cholesterol, less saturated fat. Beef has slightly more iron and zinc but is overall significantly worse for you. If your nutritional understanding is at the level of “fat and cholesterol are bad” you should not be giving dietary advice. You appear to be approaching this from a USDA-poster style of nutritional reasoning (please do not do this), so I’ll make two heuristic arguments: Why do you think, everywhere in the world except where there are social taboos on beef, poor people who eat chicken will preferentially switch to beef consumption when their standard of living improves enough to permit it? Is the peptide and vitamin distribution of human flesh closer to that of a cow, or that of a chicken?
- Retric 5y agoThe human body can produce almost everything it needs internally from most editable plants and animals. People may for example need on the order of μg/day of Bromine, Arsenic, Nickel, Fluorine, Boron, Lithium, Strontium, Silicon and Vanadium based on organic compounds containing them, but the need is slow low their plentiful in any reasonable diet. So sure, if you where building a food synthesizer from inorganic compounds then nutrition is quite complex, but in terms of diets people generally self regulate quite well with cravings often occurring should a deficiency develop. Start looking for what’s not either sufficiently plentiful in most foods or synthesized by the body and you end up with a rather short list. Vitamin C is mainly an issue because it’s destroyed by cooking, and even then people can literally go months without developing systems even with zero vitamin C. Thiamine is another one that became an issue when people started eating a lot of white rice, but again it’s food prep not the plant that’s the issue. Many arguments around optimal diets exist, but the original quote was safety not say Olympic athletes. So, based on all existing research and in the context of a normal diet, no there isn’t a significant nutritional benefit to beef over chicken. > switch to beef Because beef is tasty. It’s the same reason people don’t need to be convinced to eat chocolate.
- wyager 5y ago> The human body can produce almost everything it needs internally from most editable plants and animals. I note that your statement is appropriately very strongly hedged. > So, based on all existing research and in the context of a normal diet, Dietary “science” has one of the lowest standards of rigor of any field, in the same ballpark as psychology. Until we have accurate computer models of every metabolic pathway in the human body, I’m not going to trust papers that are like “actually you can just eat soy and seitan and be fine” (incidentally, the counterfactual study got funding approval from vegan activists and seventh-day Adventists!). Also, “in the context of a normal diet” is another pretty big hedge - “normal” diets are terrible. In any case, when we’re talking about nutrition, since the state of research is so bad, we’re basically stuck with a priori reasoning and Bayesian observation, and after applying those two, my observation is that people who eat only ruminants and fish and stuff look really good and are strong and healthy, and the exact opposite is true for people who eat only vegetables, and this doesn’t really impose a big update on my prior derived from what I know about pre-agriculture food sources in these people’s evolutionary environments. > Because beef is tasty. As you point out, when your body makes something taste better than something else, it’s probably because it’s doing a better job of meeting your nutritional needs. If two foods were abundant in the evolutionary environment, I expect taste to be reasonably well-calibrated in terms of causing me to eat the nutritionally optimal distribution of foods. Ruminants and birds were both abundant in my evolutionary environment. So what does it say that ruminants taste so much better?
- oldgradstudent 5y ago> That said their both missing vitamin C, so you need a more diverse diet anyway. People have been shown to live on fresh beef alone for extended period without suffering scurvy. Paradoxically, adding other might actually introduce the need for additional vitamin C.
- Retric 5y agoUncooked meat has vitamin C, but is harder to digest and risks food born diseases. Cooking is the issue rather than the lack of it in chicken or beef. People don’t need much vitamin C to avoid scurvy, a healthy person can skip it for about 3 months without significant issue.
- the-dude 5y agoWhat is wrong with cholesterol?
- EvilEy3 5y agoNothing. Fatties seem to think that only they populate the earth.
- Retric 5y agoOn it’s own nothing the body needs quite a lot of it. But it can be a problem if your diet includes excessive quantities. Edit: Saying a food is healthy or not IMO really a question of how well it fits into the widest selection of current diets and lifestyles. Drinking say 1oz of sea water it generally fine and if people where frequently salt deficient then it could be considered healthy, but as insufficient salt intake is not a common problem and excessive salt intake is occasionally one I don’t think we can really consider sea water as healthy. Similarly dietary cholesterol has minimal impact on most people, but overall excess is more generally going to be an issue simply due to the small population that is at risk. As such I think we can say lower cholesterol chicken is a net positive overall unless we know more about the specific person involved.
- the-dude 5y agoWell that is true for almost anything including water. What is the problem you are referring to?
- wyager 5y ago> Chicken is a perfectly reasonable substitute for beef. This is completely 100% incorrect. Chicken is so nutritionally deficient relative to beef that it might as well be a vegetable. > There are over a 600 million people are living cheaply and safely on vegetarian diets “Cheaply”, yes, “safely” not so much. Vegetarian populations tend to be have stunted growth, have worse dentition, etc. compared to populations who eat a diet based on ruminants, fish, etc. Additionally, dietary requirements are not fungible across the human population. People whose ancestors come from different evolutionary environments will be tuned for different food sources. Lactose tolerance is probably the most well known example. A priori, all of my pre-agricultural ancestors must have had a diet completely incompatible with vegetarianism, so it’s not surprising that people of my background who go vegetarian tend to exhibit metabolic problems. Note that I am not comparing vegetarianism to the standard American diet, which is practically vegetarian already. Switching from SAD to a generic vegetarian diet might simply have the positive effect of reducing the amount of weird slop people consume. https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2016/december/a-look-at-calorie-sources-in-the-american-diet https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2016/december/a-look-at...
- Retric 5y agoVegetarian populations have different deficiencies than other populations but overall they aren’t worse lifespans than other populations with similar economic backgrounds.
- wyager 5y ago> they aren’t worse lifespans than other populations with similar economic backgrounds Even if this is true, it’s tremendously misleading because (globally) vegetarian populations tend to be quite poor.
- ben_w 5y agoTo the extent that’s true, it also demonstrates the false causality in your own claim: poverty, not the absence of meat per se, is the cause of all the things you’re blaming vegetarian diets for.
- jcfrei 5y agoIt's not a luxury at all in some regions. In higher altitudes for example where warm weather cycles are too short to grow a lot of crops (other than some type of grass) keeping livestock (for meat, eggs, milk) is essential for survival.
- yboris 5y agoIt's frustrating to see arguments devolve into this kind of thing. It's almost surely the case we are discussing developed nations like the US (one of the largest consumers of meat), not some remote village in a developing nation. Sure there might be remote places with no access to the world market. Sure there might be some people whose health doesn't allow removal of meat. But on the grand-scale of the US and other developed economies, we can reduce meat consumption by 90% without any negative effects (in fact, we'll improve average health by a lot).