4 ms·
It really isn’t pointless. Building, selling, or possessing facial recognition products or data obtained could easily be made illegal or extremely restricted.
by colechristensen 5y ago
It really isn’t pointless. Building, selling, or possessing facial recognition products or data obtained could easily be made illegal or extremely restricted.
We need to build an expectation of public privacy concept where everyone has the right to go about their public lives with only human levels of tracking, recognition, and memories. That is being seen and remembered a short while is acceptable, having every move recorded and attributed to me is not.
- mcculley 5y agoHow could it easily be restricted? As long as people or corporations are allowed to sell timestamped, geostamped photos and videos, the aggregation can be done.
- rt4mn 5y agoJust because something can be technically done does not mean that we cant impose restrictions that make it to costly to use except in the most constrained and extreme circumstances. This is an oversimplification of a complicated story, but a great example is when the NSA stopped doing mass phone / text analysis because of the additional regulatory burdens imposed by the USA Freedom Act. The NSA contends that the data is still useful, but also that the difficulties of complying with the law make it not worth it.
- mcculley 5y agoI am not understanding how you get to possible restrictions. How could I, as a private citizen or owner of a property be prevented from selling photos/videos with timestamps and geostamps? How could a company be prevented from buying and aggregating that data (even in other jurisdictions)? How could an end user be prevented from buying aggregated data as the cost plummets? Do you really think the NSA is not buying all available data sets?
- rhn_mk1 5y agoThe problem of preventing the transfer of uncomfortable data has already been tackled by copyright.
- mcculley 5y agoPlease elaborate. There are many markets for buying and selling photos and other data.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoCopyright is a law that by design prevents the selling or buying or other transfer of some data, and it even sometimes works (black markets notwithstanding). If your goal is to restrict the transfer of some other kind of data, copyright is already a legal and practical framework that had tackled the same problems, and offers solutions.
- mcculley 5y agoCopyright protects intellectual property. It does not protect those captured in photos taken by others. Trademark law maybe would work here. Is that what you meant?
- acover 5y agoHow can you be prevented from murder? How was private ownership of gold illegal for decades? How was a farmer growing hay to feed their own horses illegal? The government has pretty wide reaching powers.
- mcculley 5y agoI still have not heard a realistic way these capabilities would be limited. Ordinary consumers and corporations will have this technology. It will continue to get cheaper. How would governments not have it? The same people who sold browsing data to advertisers have this technology.
- 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoNSA cares about laws?
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoMany states have two party consent laws that make it illegal to record private conversations without consent even in a public place. I fail to see how the same thing couldn't be done with video. Of course finding the political will to restrict things like security cameras is a different matter, but I don't think it'd it'd case that we couldn't write effective laws to prevent this.
- mcculley 5y agoAs I wrote, we are already seeing this. Tow truck companies sell ALPR data to aggregators. Ring and Amazon are collecting security camera data. Please explain what legislation you would propose.
- colechristensen 5y agoWrite data privacy laws which apply to surveillance cameras which require commercial entities to disclose what information is being collected, how it is being shared with provisions banning certain kinds of collecting, sharing, and storage with regulatory fines, criminal penalties, and provisions enabling class action lawsuits for misuse or other banned disclosures.
- mcculley 5y agoDisclosure is insufficient to prevent aggregation. The same kind of people who sold browsing data to advertisers are selling this data. If you do not want to be tracked, you have to get those around you to not provide the data.
- colechristensen 5y agoThat would be why i listed many things more than disclosure.
- mcculley 5y agoI misunderstood. Would you eliminate Facebook and the existing ALPR data aggregators? I am wondering how such restrictions would be possible.
- colechristensen 5y agoYou would come up with a decent legal definition of a surveillance camera with a distinction from a person taking pictures. You would add disclosure provisions, if an observed person could reasonably be expected to see and make a choice (say entering a business) there would be one set of rules, when a person couldn’t see a notice or make a choice (say a camera on a vehicle) there would be much more restrictive rules. You would make it a crime to violate the rules but administered like and possible to sue in civil court for victims. The crime would be on the owner/operator of the camera and special provisions would be added for storage providers.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago>could easily be made illegal or extremely restricted. What bunker do you live in?
- colechristensen 5y agoThis is an inappropriate comment for HN.