12 ms·
Facial recognition technology: How to opt out at the airport
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoMaybe you can at the boarding gate and in some other points but when you get out of the fly/plane and you enter in the airport, there’s a(t least one) camera above your head and you can’t walk in other directions. Maybe you have to wear hat, sunglasses and a mask… Others critical points are at the temperature scanning at the entrance and at the passport check. I don’t think you can avoid those.
- andai 5y agoDo they use some fancy thermal cameras to check for fever?
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoYes, due to Covid-19.
- brk 5y agoThermal cameras absolutely suck for body temperature measurement. Those fever cameras are all security theater garbage.
- ekianjo 5y ago> The only snag is for non-U.S. citizens. As always
- vinay427 5y agoTo be fair, there was previously no systematic exit control process in US airports unlike in many countries including the Schengen area bloc, and many other countries have also long required photographs of non-citizens/non-residents along with exit controls. The US is more in line with the UK, Canada, etc. approach that doesn't allow any way of way of definitively knowing whether someone on a visa or restricted permit actually left the country if they were supposed to. While I would have preferred a non-biometric approach for everyone, I'm hoping that moving some of the burden to exit control 1. lessens the workload of immigration enforcement domestically, and 2. encourages a very slow transition towards more seamless international transfers given that US airports usually weren't built for this, although a lot more work would be needed here.
- refurb 5y agoMy understanding is the that airline passenger lists are the equivalent exit “check” for the US and Canada. They are shared freely between the two countries as are entry checks into respective countries (hence the US or Canada can confirm an exit based on entry to the neighboring country). That said, I think it’s mostly just “we can check if needed” and it’s not matched up automatically though that might have changed? I know if you’re an immigrant and you check your I-94 record with USCIS is usually wrong and missing data.
- sneak 5y agoTo be fair, the concept of passports (in the modern sense of a document required to cross a national border) is a relatively modern invention, on the close order of only about a hundred years.
- kylegordon 5y agoHow to Opt Out (of voluntarily Facial Recognition) at the Airport
- beckman466 5y agoYes... because they take their time to sit down and explain that to each person, right? /s
- deepsun 5y agoWhat's the difference if in order to fly an airliner you already have surrendered your ID?
- caymanjim 5y agoExactly. This is a giant nothingburger. You can't get through a gate at the airport without showing government-issued ID, by which point they know exactly who you are, and every detail about your life. What exactly are you opting out of? You're still being recorded by dozens--if not hundreds--of TSA/airport security cameras every step of the way, and even if there isn't software automatically identifying and tagging you, it would be trivial to determine who you are. You're on camera when you arrive at the airport, you're on camera when you check in, you're on camera when you go through security, walk to the gate, and board the plane. It's unlikely a single second of your activity in the airport is off-camera (bathrooms notwithstanding). I don't like the surveillance state, in particular the ubiquity of cameras in public open spaces where there's no compelling reason. I don't like the networks of private cameras people have attached to their front doors, all fed to Amazon and Google (and the state, most likely). If we're going to have cameras anywhere, though, the airport is the place I have the least problem with. We're way past opting out, whatever that even means in this scenario.
- pabl8k 5y agoIt's not a nothingburger. An ID card has biometric information from years ago. Correlating a photo match with a ticket at gate check in gives confirmation for updating the stored id-face model, which means the recency and fidelity of the biometric data stored by e.g. the airlines or CBP is higher than that from the ID card. Random surveillance video in an airport probably can't be used to update records because you have lower confidence of a match absent the other known factor that confirms ID. Moreover, masks/face covering is a norm that will also help subvert ambient face ID and model updating. The data won't stay in the airport—the updated id-face model will be used in places where we expect or should expect more privacy of identity. We as a society could decide to limit the legality of this. As individuals we can opt out and likely make a small but meaningful difference in the recency and fidelity of our collected and shared biometric data.
- avipars 5y agoDoesn't this just make you more of a target for them?
- yardstick 5y agoTangentially related, I wonder what happens if you wear a shirt that has a benign picture that matches a CSAM hash? Will everyone who takes a picture of you end up getting flagged by detection algorithms? I’m thinking in a similar vein to the magic DVD AACS number people printed on T-shirts mugs etc. Will this become a great way for camera shy people to pollute any paparazzi shots of them?
- eptcyka 5y agoThis isn't related to the story at all. CSAM doesn't hash parts of a picture, so your shirt would only trigger it if somebody took a photo of just the shirt at a right angle.
- yardstick 5y agoHence me going on a tangent :) So the solution for abusers is to just layer their photos inside subsections of normal photos to work around CASM? Anyway was just a thought experiment on how to automatically opt out while “sticking it to the man”, so to speak. Maybe I should look into EUrion constellation marks instead! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation
- throwaway47292 5y agoSadly, I think we are beyond opt-out with any facial recognition. I recently showed[1] to my daughter (10) as teaching her python, how easy it is to build some basic facial recognition using modern libraries and models. I had it running with one of her pictures, and i just asked her to come in front of the computer for a second to check something out, and she was completely shocked when the video put her name below her face, and my name below my face. She was shocked, a bit curious, and a bit revolted. On the next day when I took her to school, I just showed the amount of cameras on the way, and in the mall. At first she thought that its not an issue, as every camera only sees locally around it, so they cant connect her journey, but then she realised someone can own many cameras. I think we need to invest much more into adversarial machine learning[2] and possibly form some sort of organization to fund it. (I hope it will be called move-78 as Lee Sedol's hand of god move against alpha go) [1]: https://github.com/jackdoe/programming-for-kids/blob/master/week-017.md#day-119-basics-of-basics https://github.com/jackdoe/programming-for-kids/blob/master/... [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxbazQ6wJlU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxbazQ6wJlU
- pilingual 5y ago> she realised someone can own many cameras Or that the cameras are insecure, effectively public, and a motivated person or state could do the same.
- throwaway47292 5y agohaha i didnt tell her that yet, she is only 10 :D
- telesilla 5y agoIt's debatable how effective this is but CV Dazzle may just become a trend for youth. I'd support that but I'd expect to start seeing schools and commercial areas ban such practices. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/07/makeup/374929/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/07/makeu...
- mcculley 5y agoUbiquitous facial recognition is inevitable. Governments that are prohibited by law from tracking faces and locations/times will just buy it from private companies, like has happened with automated license plate readers on tow trucks. It is pointless to argue about legislation at this point. We have to assume governments and corporations will have this data. The only mitigation is to limit the overall power of governments and corporations.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt really isn’t pointless. Building, selling, or possessing facial recognition products or data obtained could easily be made illegal or extremely restricted. We need to build an expectation of public privacy concept where everyone has the right to go about their public lives with only human levels of tracking, recognition, and memories. That is being seen and remembered a short while is acceptable, having every move recorded and attributed to me is not.
- mcculley 5y agoHow could it easily be restricted? As long as people or corporations are allowed to sell timestamped, geostamped photos and videos, the aggregation can be done.
- rt4mn 5y agoJust because something can be technically done does not mean that we cant impose restrictions that make it to costly to use except in the most constrained and extreme circumstances. This is an oversimplification of a complicated story, but a great example is when the NSA stopped doing mass phone / text analysis because of the additional regulatory burdens imposed by the USA Freedom Act. The NSA contends that the data is still useful, but also that the difficulties of complying with the law make it not worth it.
- mcculley 5y agoI am not understanding how you get to possible restrictions. How could I, as a private citizen or owner of a property be prevented from selling photos/videos with timestamps and geostamps? How could a company be prevented from buying and aggregating that data (even in other jurisdictions)? How could an end user be prevented from buying aggregated data as the cost plummets? Do you really think the NSA is not buying all available data sets?
- elmalto 5y agoGlobal entry / TSA-Precheck only required my face when I entered the the US last month (LGA airport). While I have gotten used to having my picture taken at US airports, it was a weird yet incredibly fast experience
- da_big_ghey 5y agoIt is already too late, first it is opt in, then it is opt out, then it is compulsory. This will happen if we let it have any use at all. Write your congressman now if you have a desire for this not to come to pass.
- bm3719 5y agoThe facial recognition battle is lost. The only power we have is over how we behave as the losing side. Of the few options we have, one is normalizing wearing recognition-scrambling makeup/masks. Another would be to get stickers of eyes, brows, and noses, and place them in random places around your face. It'd be interesting to see some studies of the effectiveness of the different methods.
- 65 5y agoWell, until they ban facial recognition scrambling masks. If the burqa is banned in many European countries I don't see why facial recognition evasion devices don't also get banned.
- macawfish 5y agoFace recognition is one thing. Device free localization and identification by spectral/topological analysis of mm-wave antenna array data is even more invasive. Hint: I'm talking about 5G and its big surveillance application, an open secret.
- minton 5y agoDid you mean device-free? Are you saying 5G can track and identify people without using their phones?
- White_Wolf 5y agoI don't remember all the details for sure sure but I read some research a while back about using some form of radar "thing" to identify people using a details like gait, ear shape and size, neck length and shape, upper back shape and width, arm length and a few other things that I really can't remember. I think gait was the main factor along with height and then rest were used as filters. Edit: Forgot to mention this was pretty crude 10 years ago. I'm assuming op is talking about a practical application for something similar.
- macawfish 5y agoYup, exactly. Gait is the main thing I've seen too. But there are a whole grab bag of papers about these applications with different methodologies. Stuff like topological data analysis and machine learning are much more fleshed out these days, so these applications don't need to rely as much on rigid models to be accurate. Could be that they're using subtle, noisy information from breathing patterns, for example. "Device free", "localization", "identification" and "mm wave antenna arrays" are some useful keywords for checking this stuff out on Google scholar. Some other alternatives for "device free" are "passive" and "adversarial". I think I remember one paper where they were identifying dozens of people at once with like 95%+ accuracy. I could be getting the details wrong on that one but it was along those lines. For the high level overview though, you can just read the 5G industry whitepapers and it pretty clearly spells out that there are privacy implications and I'm sure that these kinds of applications are exactly why. Remember, higher frequency = more information density = finer resolution. Which is also why these radio waves can't travel through as much stuff... They simply interact with more; more stuff is opaque to them, and as such they carry information about more interactions in their image.
- andfer29 5y agoSorry, this may be a silly question, but what are some ways to explain why this may be bad to someone? I personally don’t care if an airport or a mall know who I am and track me so trying to understand why it’s not great.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoInformation is power. Giving it away puts you at a disadvantage. History has shown that government and business will often use their power for evil. Need examples? Read the Bill of Rights and then the reasons they were written.
- mbg721 5y agoYou could obscure your face and wear special contact lenses, and then you'd be instantly recognizable as "that guy whose license plate is all I's and ones".
- mlindner 5y agoI've never used facial recognition in the US and I never will. If they start requiring it for certain places/method of travel then I'll no longer use them.
- aiisjustanif 5y agoThis leads to the an even bigger question. Will kids be able to opt-out in schools? [1][2] [1]: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/safer-management https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/safer-management [2]: https://www.safermgmt.com/ https://www.safermgmt.com/
- lucb1e 5y ago> Facial recognition technology: How to opt out at the airport in the US* I thought this might be some China thing since the domain is cntraveler, or indeed a US thing since it seems also in line with both HN and the kind of stuff US airports do, but the title isn't quite clear so one has to click...
- baby-yoda 5y agohad my first experience with this a couple months ago at the gate, had no idea it was even a thing. it probably did improve boarding time for the entire plane (A350 transatlantic, 300ish passengers) but after understanding how the tech works I’m more impressed with how quickly the scan is validated against the CBP database - literally a second or so.
- JohnFen 5y agoAt this point, there's only one way that I can see to opt out of this nonsense. Don't fly. I've been fortunate in being able to avoid flying for years now.
- asah 5y agoEnemy of the State (1998, Will Smith): https://www.google.com/search?gs_ssp=eJzj4tTP1TcwNirOiTdg9BJKzUvNrVTIT1MoyUhVKC5JLEkFAJLGCfQ&q=enemy+of+the+state&oq=enemy+of+th&aqs=chrome.1.0i355i512j46i512j69i57j0i512j46i512j0i512l2j46i512j0i512l2.3160j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?gs_ssp=eJzj4tTP1TcwNirOiTdg9BJ...
- paulpauper 5y agoIf you bought a ticket it is already too late. This will do nothing. Take a cab or greyhound instead if privacy is paramint.
- zahma 5y agoI saw face-scan boarding an international flight at Atlanta last year. The reps for Delta did make it clear we could opt out by saying so, which meant them having to swipe my boarding pass. What was shocking is how few people bothered to question the system. Perhaps I am naive, but I trust CBP a lot more with my image than Delta. Maybe I shouldn’t trust either, but airlines seem to have gotten into the business of security. I do not trust them to keep their meandering and profiteering ways siloed off from passenger security systems.
- oliv__ 5y ago> What was shocking is how few people bothered to question the system. This is always what gets me: people will willingly walk into their own demise. I just don't get it, it's quite depressing frankly
- Animats 5y agoPeople can recognize you with face recognition. Cops spend time looking at picture books of wanted people. Store clerks remember customers. Vegas casinos hire people with unusually good face recognition skills. We're looking at the wrong end of the problem. We need to limit what consequences can come from being recognized. Like an "you can only be hassled once a year" policy for cops. Meanwhile, watch the Hikvision Corporate Channel and get over it.[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3trCnFdh6i8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3trCnFdh6i8
- tzs 5y ago> We're looking at the wrong end of the problem. We need to limit what consequences can come from being recognized. Like an "you can only be hassled once a year" policy for cops. In some of Asimov's science fiction mystery short stories there was something like this [1]. Police had technology called a "psycho-probe" that could essentially read your mind, with a slight risk that doing so would cause permanent severe brain damage. Because of this risk the law was that a person could only be probed once. That had some interesting consequences. First, if someone who had never been probed was tried for a serious crime juries were reluctant to convict. Second, a lot of criminals tried to get charged with crimes serious enough to get probed. Confess to a crime you didn't do in hopes of getting probed, cleared, and gaining immunity from probing for any future crimes you do. Even if you actually have to do a serious crime to get probed, it could be worth it to do so and serve your time to get that immunity for when you resume your criminal career when you get out. [1] Definitely in at least one of the "Wendell Urth" mysteries collected in "Asimov's Mysteries" [2]. I'm sure probing is a big part of "The Singing Bell" and I think it was at least mentioned in "The Dying Night". [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asimov%27s_Mysteries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asimov%27s_Mysteries
- oramit 5y agoThis has been my recent thinking on this as well. I wish we didn't have ubiquitous surveillance and I wish there was a way to stop it from expanding even more but that's not the world we live in. Privacy advocates who think they can stop this at the technology level are fooling themselves. The ship has already sailed. What's left is to create a culture where the abuse of surveillance is heavily stigmatized. There are a lot of laws that could be passed to minimize the time that data is stored and how it is shared. The government is the only entity with the power to make rules to stop this, and the government is the entity that controls the spy agencies (who are the most frightening abusers of surveillance power) and could reign them in. But privacy advocates are almost always maximally skeptical of government power so they reject out of hand to work "in the system" as it were, to make changes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]