5 ms·
> maximizing insurance based revenue That seems to be the state of US healthcare unfortunately. What used to be an ethical doctor-pactient relationship has tur
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> maximizing insurance based revenue
That seems to be the state of US healthcare unfortunately. What used to be an ethical doctor-pactient relationship has turned into a doctor-insurance-patient monstrosity. Doctors actually have limited autonomy. They can't always do what's best for the patient, only what the insurance company agrees with.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe patient and doctor are free to negotiate a deal that avoids third parties such as the insurance company. The patient chooses to hire an insurance company (better labeled a "managed care organization") to manage their care, because they do not know what they are buying, or how much it should cost. >They can't always do what's best for the patient, only what the insurance company agrees with. Because that is what the patient can afford. Note that when the previous commenter states this: > everything to do with maximizing insurance based revenue. They are referring to requirements frequently set forth by the government or their employer. Some of them are called "star ratings", and the government goes to managed care organizations (who also sell health insurance), and task them with implementing standards of care and star ratings and a very complex system that determines who gets paid how much and who is incentivized to do what. It is very naive and counterproductive to label insurers as the bad guy because "insurers maximizing revenue", because it lets go of the real issue, which is that A) healthcare is hard, and measuring results even harder B) supply of healthcare is low relative to demand C) the limited supply of healthcare has to be allocated in some manner It is a very complicated subject, that involves many players, incentives, opportunities for corruption, people with good intentions, and no easy answers.
- nescioquid 5y ago>> They can't always do what's best for the patient, only what the insurance company agrees with. > Because that is what the patient can afford. What is the point of paying for insurance, then? Nothing legitimizes for-profit insurance companies having any role or prerogative in health care, other than the status quo.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe point of insurance is to protect against unaffordable losses. An insurance business only works if the losses are, by and large, randomly distributed and unexpected. The more predictable the losses, the more an insurance offering resembles a payment plan where you are simply setting aside money with a third party to save for the eventual loss. This is because as losses become more probable, the insurance company has to increase premiums eventually to the point where the sum of the premiums is equal to the losses if the probability of loss is 100%. This is the current state of health insurance in the US. It is not what would normally be called an insurance product. In fact, quite a few of the stipulations of ACA make health insurance premiums explicitly a tax from the young/healthy to the old/sick. Therefore, the industry term is to refer to health insurance companies as "managed care organizations" (MCOs), some of whom sell health "insurance". In the US, when you pay health insurance premiums, if you are young/healthy, you are mostly paying for the treatment of the old/sick, and only minority paying to protect against the risk of you breaking your arm. The profit that MCOs earn is actually more like an administration fee. The US could have implement an NHS style taxpayer funded healthcare system, but the politically viable option in 2010 was to outsource the administration of healthcare (pricing negotiations, healthcare rationing, auditing, etc) duties to MCOs, hence we have a system where the government (or employer) sets the rules, that abide by ACA rules, and then the MCOs execute them. For example, nearly half of Americans' healthcare is paid by the government, but it is administered by MCOs. The MCOs are not setting the rules, just carrying out the stipulations of their contracts with the government: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10830 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10830 Finally, to answer this question: >What is the point of paying for insurance, then? If you have future earning potential, or a little bit of wealth saved up, then health insurance in the US is valuable because your out of pocket maximum is capped. https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/ https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-li... This is one of the policies that also helps make health insurance premiums more akin to a tax, along with, but not limited to, the following policies: Age Rating Factors (adds cost to young people's premiums and lowers old people's premiums) https://www.cms.gov/CCIIO/Programs-and-Initiatives/Health-Insurance-Market-Reforms/state-rating https://www.cms.gov/CCIIO/Programs-and-Initiatives/Health-In... And insurance cannot be denied to someone for any reason, and has to only be based on age/location/tobacco use: https://www.healthcare.gov/how-plans-set-your-premiums/ https://www.healthcare.gov/how-plans-set-your-premiums/
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Because that is what the patient can afford. The whole point of these things is to get them to pay for the costs of whatever the patient needs. These needs are determined by their doctor. If they're not paying, they have no reason to exist. Not being able to help people because of lack of resources is one thing. These companies hire experts and pay them bonuses every time they find some loophole they can use to get out of their obligation.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>The whole point of these things is to get them to pay for the costs of whatever the patient needs. These needs are determined by their doctor. If they're not paying, they have no reason to exist. Per the payer's terms, whether it be government or employer or insurance company, their needs are not necessarily solely determined by a single doctor. There are teams of doctors and pharmacists at CMS, state Medicaid organizations, and insurance companies that create protocol for various courses of treatment in order to prevent mistakes, waste, and fraud. >These companies hire experts and pay them bonuses every time they find some loophole they can use to get out of their obligation. Source? It seems odd that a company that earns more money if it spends more on healthcare would have an incentive to look for loopholes. Of course, they have an incentive to not spend frivolously to maintain competitive prices. https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/medical-loss-ratio-MLR/ https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/medical-loss-ratio-MLR/ But they are all using the same protocols that the government uses anyway (via CMS), since the government contracts with the same MCOs to administer taxpayer funded healthcare for 40%+ of Americans via Medicare/Medicaid/Tricare.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoIm sorry, but this is not true >>>>>The patient and doctor are free to negotiate a deal that avoids third parties such as the insurance company. Just like im free to negotiate a deal for some stock of TLSA directly from Musk, and not buy it via 401k. On top of the transaction cost of getting elon musk in the same room with me, there's a huge difference: 401k purchases are pretax. Buying from Musk is not pretax. Same is true for a "negotiated" transaction with a doctor, vs buying insurance from employer. >>>>>Patient chooses insurance to manage their care, because they do not know what they are buying, or how much it should cost. Wow. Those are some claims. Lets test them. I dont even know how to change the oil from my car. I barely know how it operates, and i couldn't repair one without years of training. Yet anyone with cash can and does buy these $30,000+ machines. How can something worth $50 - $300 be hard to understand? Also, I have an extremely powerful heuristic to know if its worth it, or not. ( feeling better = return to doctor. Feeling worse = change doctor ). No one needs insurance to buy medicine. Medical insurance is just simply a membership racket, legalized by the govt. History is not on your side. Medical insurance was an irrelevant, minuscule market until well after ww2. Why its sudden emergence? Government mandates (Medicare + federal insurance mandates to employers, for returning vets) >>>>>It is very naive and counterproductive to label insurers as the bad guy because "insurers maximizing revenue" Insurers are not the only bad guy. I'll give you that. But to say they are not a bad guy, is fraudulent or really naive on your part. So, Who are all the bad guys? Follow the money. Which players are going in acquisition sprees? Hospitals, Insurers, large Pharma, and PBMs. 1) Hospital "nonprofits", such as childrens hopsitals that have the gall to do community fundraising from bake sales while paying CEOs 5M+, while the CEO of the red cross is in hot water for making 500k. [1]. 2) Insurers that buy a medical practice in NJ, and then suddently cut off the competing practice from the insurance network, thus grating the newly acquired practice a local monopoly.[2] Or for a more recent example, take the lobbying to scare Biden's admin & CMS to permanently suspend the Trump administration mandate to force hospitals and insurers to disclose real medical pricing in 2021. [3] It begs the question on why Covid19 bigcos were giving Biden real time updates on covid19 drug development, while trump -the actual president- was kept in the dark. I know the bad guys were sweating bullets on that one! 3) PBMs? Creating formularies to favor sweetheart rebates to them, obscuring real cost from patients and regulators, while making patients and employers foot the bill? or 4) Pharma, racking in cash from drug $20 copays without disclosing to customers that they offer the same pills for pennies if you "cash pay" (not use insurance). Bad guys galore in healthcare. Insurers are most certainly in the podium. [1] Marty Makary : Unnacountable book [2] https://www.nj.com/healthfit/2020/02/an-insurance-titan-is-dropping-hundreds-of-nj-physicians-to-enrich-itself-doctors-and-patients-charge.html https://www.nj.com/healthfit/2020/02/an-insurance-titan-is-d... [3]https://www.natlawreview.com/article/cms-backs-price-transparency-providers-and-plans https://www.natlawreview.com/article/cms-backs-price-transpa...