7 ms·
I've read all the comments, and as usual, no one's asked "what do other industries do?" Money-handling, for example (banks, payment systems). If ever there was
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I've read all the comments, and as usual, no one's asked "what do other industries do?"
Money-handling, for example (banks, payment systems). If ever there was a Fraud Magnet, that's it. I've heard PayPal described as "a giant fraud-detection system, wrapped around a tiny money-transferring system."
And yet, they don't seem to be in the news all the time like "data theft" stories are. Could it be that the legal and regulatory and insurance systems have made it a manageable problem? Someone steals your credit card, your losses are capped. Someone steals your Personally Identifying Information, sorry, pal; change your passwords.
So maybe treating PII as the same thing, in every way, as money is the answer.
- acdha 5y agoOne useful move would be changing laws around identity theft so companies are liable for any costs incurred from their failure to verify identity, or for reporting credit issues from unvalidated activity. Americans worry about things like SSNs getting breached because they don’t want to get someone else’s bill — if companies were required to check photo ID against a real person (not an uploaded photo) that’d be a much harder crime to make financially viable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 5y agoIndeed, it is ridiculous that "identity theft" places a burden on the person whose identity was used - if someone opens an account in my name and the only "evidence" is having provided something that other people (e.g. my mother or spouse) can know, then in any dispute it should be illegal for that fraud/debt to appear on my credit report. That's the way how most of the world has mostly solved identity theft, however, it's not that easy to implement in USA because there's no system of universal secure IDs in USA (by design) - there's a multitude of ID forms, some of them are not really secure (easy to forge, no verification if it was really issued by the institution who did so, no easy process to quickly verify online if the provided credential has been lost/stolen/revoked, etc), and there's a sufficiently large minority of potential customers who don't have a valid ID. It would be helpful to have laws that clearly assign the credit fraud risk fully onto the defrauded companies instead of the people whose identities were used, as experience shows that this would rapidly result in improvements to fraud elimination (there's all kinds of measures that simply are not taken since they add friction), however, a proper solution does require a decent state-run identity system as the foundation of trust, and USA has made a political decision to not have one.
- acdha 5y agoOh, trust me, I know that this is a self-inflicted problem — we have too many people who subscribe to conspiracy theories about things like the “mark of the beast”. It's just somewhat impressive to see how effectively companies created a new category of crime to direct attention away from their negligence.
- ethbr0 5y ago> theories about things like the “mark of the beast” My hope is their anti-vax research eventually leads them to learning about DNA.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoThe problem isn't with a person having a UUID of some sort (of which their genome is one). The issue is that the Book of Revelations talks about a Mark people will need to have stamped on their arm and/or forehead in order to be able to conduct business. I.e. it's a problem of allegiance, not authentication. So, in practice, anything that pattern-matches to "people will need to carry some sort of token given by a big organization (private or public) to pay or be paid for goods and services" will be viewed by some as the Mark, or a slippery slope towards the Mark.
- ethbr0 5y agoLast I checked, the anonymous web was effectively dead. Or do these people not use the internet either?
- TeMPOraL 5y agoThey do, but most people aren't aware how Internet works. Hell, most people haven't learned the concepts necessary to comprehend what information is (personal or otherwise) and how it behaves - not in terms of technology, but as a fundamental component of reality. Anyway, the Mark as described in Revelations is pretty... bodily, for lack of better term. It evokes the image of getting a barcode stamped on your arm or your forehead, in exchange for swearing fealty. The Mark feels like a concrete, physical thing. That's why things like "government ID" or "payment chip in your arm" pattern-match to this prophesy for so many people, while things like "mobile phone number" or "e-mail address" don't. (There's also a factor of scale/graduality. For people alive this century, countries and governments were always a thing. A big thing. Banks too. The governments, the UN, the international financial system - they look big, evil, and pattern-match to the Beast. In contrast, for most people alive today, mobile phones and e-mail addresses were something they've seen introduced gradually, from great many independent vendors. They don't have this obvious Beast-like quality.) Source: grew up as Jehovah's Witness. While I obviously can't speak for all fundamentalist Christians, and while JW teachings don't consider government IDs to be the Mark[0], I got pretty familiar with the patterns of thinking people show around this topic. -- [0] - They do, however, believe that the Beast described in the Revelations is currently embodied by the United Nations. So if the UN ever proposes a common ID scheme or an electronic payment system, I'm pretty sure plenty of Witnesses will throw a fit.
- nitrogen 5y agoif companies were required to check photo ID against a real person It'll be really hard to convince people to give up the convenience and higher returns of online-only banks. A better option would be using cryptographic digital signatures by an HSM (smart card) to verify ID for financial services.
- alexott 5y agoVideo ID verification works quite well in many cases.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoWe have online banking here in Norway, have had for decades in fact. We don't have any problems with verifying ID.
- bostik 5y agoIt's not theft. It's fraud. Framing the action of defrauding a person as a downstream effect of being a victim of theft, is nothing short of institutionalised victim blaming. No, just no. The person was defrauded because of stolen identity and/or payment info documents. They were not a "victim of theft": they were a target of fraud. Calling it theft is a sleight of hand to absolve banks, payment providers and businesses from their responsibilities.
- faeriechangling 5y agoThis is fundamentally why "identity theft" exists at all. It's slight of hand for moneyed interests to shift the responsibility of being robbed onto their customers. It's no wonder "identity theft" is such an issue since there's so little incentive to use a not broken means of verifying identity. Using a secret number to verify identity is absurd and hilarious.
- johnchristopher 5y agoBut GDPR and cookie banners forced me to stop selling my startup services in Europe :(. /s
- alexott 5y agoI doubt about PayPal’s anti-fraud capabilities. They allowed to open another account with the same name and address as mine, but with different phone and email, without any confirmation. And that person bought something, and after it wasn’t paid, gave my information to collectors…
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoWhat would be the cap for losses from losing PII. Credit cards generally have one use: payments. Usage is not difficult to quantify. The card is generally worth the same to whomever is in possession of it. PII has a multitude of uses. The prices offered on the black market for PII do not reflect its value to those that it identifies or those from whom it was stolen.
- harikb 5y agoIf we treat PII as money, it implies the loss can be clearly quantified and loss can be compensated for. Banking industry isn’t better because they have solved the problem, they are just hiding behind the fact that victim can be compensated and hence an insurance can cover all risks
- anothernewdude 5y agoI've heard Paypal described as a "giant fraud system"
- thayne 5y ago> So maybe treating PII as the same thing, in every way, as money is the answer. How? Money is fungible, PII is very much not. It's not like they can give you a new identity if your identity is stolen.