5 ms·
On the other hand the replacement of existing hierarchies with meritocracy seems to be one of the appealing things of post-apocalyptic scenarios for average peo
by wongarsu 5y ago
On the other hand the replacement of existing hierarchies with meritocracy seems to be one of the appealing things of post-apocalyptic scenarios for average people.
- Iolaum 5y agoUntil you factor in there that merit in immoral behaviors such as pillaging, looting and bullying will also be a big factor.
- mtoner23 5y agoPost apocalyptic meritocracy doesn't poll very well last i checked
- kypro 5y agoWorse, it doesn't even seem realistic. Far more likely you'll have anarchy and those with the resources to do so will create social hierarchies.
- swader999 5y agoYes, watch or read The Road.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoNo thank you, once is enough.
- swader999 5y agoIndeed.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoYou'd just get rule by sociopaths - as usual. No genuine meritocracy anywhere.
- themaninthedark 5y agoIt would be a meritocracy of sorts, but what talents would you be optimizing for? My guess would be: Willingness to use violence, cunning, manipulation, organization.
- throaway46546 5y agoDoesn't sound all that different from the status quo.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoExactly
- duxup 5y agoYou're going to be in a new one. Generally, I expect it won't be very pleasant / the 'law' a bit less predictable.
- Emma_Goldman 5y agoMeritocracy is economically efficient but often congeals into an ideological dogma justifying a plutocracy of the talented, even though talent is - to a very great extent - an undeserved function of genes and environment outwith one's control.
- javert 5y agoThat only bothers people who want to make life "fair" at the expense of what is practical. There is a reason we let people keep the wealth they build. It's not because it's "fair." It's because taking it away, and having the brutes or demagogues decide how to distribute it, makes the society a hellhole.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoYou should try visiting the Scandinavian hellholes to see how bad this can get. They're so backward they don't even have hundreds of thousands of health insurance bankruptcies every year.
- javert 5y agoWouldn't work in the Americas, which have a far lower average level of human capital. You can't redistribute what has not been produced. There are lots of examples of this in history. By the way, the US health system crisis is caused by regulatory capture. There is no way to regulate the regulators to prevent this. At least, not in a failed democracy such as the US. Probably the only way to regulate the regulators in a society as complex as the US and most other countries (contra Scandinavia) is with strict constitutional principles. That's the only way I know. Once you put "people" in charge, corruption and other dysfunctions eventually reign.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoAre there any “not failed” democracies in your estimation? If so, what are they doing right that the US is doing wrong? Or is the whole Democratic experiment a failure?
- foobarian 5y agoIt is an interesting question how various countries would turn out after a big civilization reset like a nuclear war. Seems like it would likely go the feudal route with the cruelest warlords rising to the top in various locales (pretty much like narco-lord ruled Mexico). How would the United States turn out? Would the Ohio valley turn into its own kingdom? Texas its own? All of Northeast probably. I wish there was historical fiction along these lines.
- arethuza 5y agoI can recommend A Canticle for Leibowitz - it covers your last point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Canticle_for_Leibowitz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Canticle_for_Leibowitz
- tristor 5y ago> I wish there was historical fiction along these lines. Ah, but there is. I highly recommend S.M. Stirling's Emberverse series: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emberverse_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emberverse_series Well worth the read. One Second After: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Second_After https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Second_After is another great choice.
- ornornor 5y agoJust finished reading One {second,year} after. It was entertaining but a lot of the story revolves around military inspired heroics and battles. You can tell the author is into military fiction.
- scruple 5y agoAh, thank you so much for linking "One Second After." I had seen someone recommend this book on HN previously but had lost track of the comment and the title of the book.
- arcanus 5y agoA Canticle for Leibowitz is a famous sci-fi that directly mimics feudalism and the church after nuclear war-- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Canticle_for_Leibowitz https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Canticle_for_Leibowitz
- SavantIdiot 5y agoYes, but what hierarchy would replace what we have now? Do you want RoadWarrior/MadMax? Because that's how you get RoadWarrior/MadMax.
- chasd00 5y agoright, the merit in "Post apocalyptic meritocracy" would be the most equipped, most armed, most violent, and the most followed.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoLooking back at ancient cultures, how many millenia would it take for Grecian democratic ideals to re-evolve from a hoard of gun toting MAGAs? Let alone Descartes level introspection?
- s5300 5y agoGun toting MAGAs by and large survive on a supply chain of McDonalds Hamberders and insulin. It's a point not brought up very often, but they'll crash and burn in around a week once that supply chain is interrupted.
- themaninthedark 5y agoIn that sort of survival situation, meritocracy would mean survival of the fittest. But not necessarily the person with the most/best survival skills. You will have different groups lead by what they perceive is the "best" person. Your local groups will probably consist of: Religious groups Groups centered around politicians Scouting groups Survivalists Law enforcement groups Military groups Gangs Each of those groups will be vying for control of limited resources with varying degrees of violence. For the average person, all they will see is a rapid decrease of the average lifespan. The leaders who make it to the top will do everything in their power to keep themselves and those who they favor at the top. I think a good example of this is North Korea, Afghanistan or any of the other Middle East countries where the government collapsed and there was not a single clear leader.
- 7952 5y agoGroup's can succeed because they are communal. The survivalist idea of an isolated compound does not work. Because the larger group of people who can work together will out man you. The best survival strategy is to make friends with your neighbors. And to be in a town and city with less territory to control. Ethnic communities can do this kind of thing really well.
- themaninthedark 5y agoI was thinking about the sort of people who tend to create small communities out in Montana, not the modern preper movement. But a quick search shows me that the prepers have several forums and communities and the advice I saw was that you should form a close group of diverse talents and that there is safety in numbers, just be choosy of who you count in your number.
- leto_ii 5y agoI find your take comically misguided and naive. There are, first of all, some basic things that need to be established: what is merit? how do you rank people based on their merit? can this ranking be objective and absolute? are the people with most "merit" also the most moral or capable to lead? are differences in merit meaningful in any way? why would the most "meritorious" end up on top after the apocalypse? Aside from this, I'm pretty sure that life after a nuclear holocaust will be much worse for the average survivor than their life before the event. At best people would revert to some pre-modern self-governing communes (which are not necessarily a bad thing, it's just that they would lack a lot of things in terms of healthcare, nutrition etc.). At worst we would get Mad Max or Cormac McCarthy's "The Road" or smth along those lines.