3 ms·
Pseudonymity is important, but cheap disposable identities lead to lots of community-destroying mischief. What's the best practice for enabling pseudonyms but
by gojomo 15y ago
Pseudonymity is important, but cheap disposable identities lead to lots of community-destroying mischief.
What's the best practice for enabling pseudonyms but curtailing throwaway spam/harassment/sockpuppet account-creation?
For my next project I'm considering offering two registration options:
(1) Use Facebook, which is close enough to 'real names' for most purposes – while still having some room, as Boyd notes, for many users of persistent pseudonyms.
(2) Buy a pseudonym with a nonrefundable Bitcoin payment. If you're serious about pseudonymity, why not go all the way? This is a variant on the 'Metafilter $5 one-time fee' model, but as Matt Haughey has noted that still occasionally suffers from chargebacks by dedicated vandals. Bitcoin solves that.
Any thoughts?
- icebraining 15y agoHaving to buy Bitcoins just for registering seems cumbersome. Why not use the services of one of the payment-by-sms providers?
- gojomo 15y agoThat's an interesting idea, but I'm not familiar with its mechanics/limits. Who would be a representative provider? Now, for this goal, cumbersome and/or irreversible is somewhat the point, to prevent throwaway accounts. But an occasional SMS-chargeback would be OK, as long as the source phone number can be blacklisted against reuse in the future, forcing mischief-makers to burn one phone number each registration.
- icebraining 15y agoThe problem with the Bitcoin approach is not so much the money, but the time and knowledge needed to set up a wallet, buy BTCs and then perform the payment. And as long as it costs money it would still hopefully stop trolls. The only provider I know is Fortumo[1], but I'm sure there are others. It seems pretty easy to integrate with a website[2] and as far as I know there is no way for the client to issue a chargeback. [1]: http://fortumo.com/ http://fortumo.com/ [2]: http://fortumo.com/api http://fortumo.com/api