7 ms·
Vivaldi Replaces Firefox as the Default Browser on Manjaro Linux Cinnamon
- josephcsible 5y agoThis is terrible news in two different ways: it's replacing a FOSS program with a proprietary closed-source one, and it's making the Chromium monoculture worse.
- anothernewdude 5y agoOn the other hand, it's Chromium that isn't a fucking snap.
- steerablesafe 5y agoDebian still has that.
- passthejoe 5y agoDebian's Chromium package hasn't been updated since May. It's a bit of a problem.
- steerablesafe 5y agoInteresting, it had frequent updates up until then. What happened? https://metadata.ftp-master.debian.org/changelogs//main/c/chromium/chromium_90.0.4430.212-1_changelog https://metadata.ftp-master.debian.org/changelogs//main/c/ch...
- brnt 5y agoDoesn't every distro now come with Flatpak by default? For many browsers like Chromium and Firefox, it's the best way I think.
- Aisen8010 5y agoIt's sad that the only point to keep using Firefox is because it is open source. The Firefox's interface is getting worse and worse and it does not seem to be doing anything to protect the users privacy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- detritus 5y agoI'm a Firefox die-hard, but these last couple of updates have really irritated me. I couldn't give a damn about nonsense UI changes and tweaks that serve only to add unwanted confusion and consternation cycles to my schedule. It probably says more about me, but I spent a good 20 minutes last night trying (and failing) to work out how to remove the recently-added 'Firefox Suggest' line in the Address bar drop down when you enter a character and it starts to filter options from history, etc. It's a stupid wee thing, but I don't need it, don't want it. It's just clutter, and besides it's not 'Firefox Suggests' it's my bloody history! Get out.
- jjcon 5y agoCareful you just spoke ill of one of the community golden calfs, despite giving a totally legitimate critisicm. Firefox has the same marketshare as samsung browser. Nosalgia wont save it. Chromium and its derivatives is just the standard client for the web, like linux is on the backend, the sooner everyone comes to terms with that the better.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoWhy is that for "the better" when it produces a flawed monoculture?
- jjcon 5y agoStandardization is the bedrock of so much innovation, especially in computing. We standardize so much, why not standardize web clients? If you can argue why a certain firefox approach is inheirently better and not even possible in the chromium ecosystem that is compelling but I have yet to hear of such an argument. For my part it seems like firefox just keeps getting more and more behind.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoWhy fucking Vivaldi? I would take vanilla Chromium over this
- tryptophan 5y agoWhats wrong with it? I've been using it for a while and it seems like chrome + UI improvmenets.
- sigzero 5y agoIt's not FOSS.
- lucideer 5y agoVanilla Chromium is a (I would guess deliberately) terrible user-experience. This seems like a user-oriented decision; moving to Chromium would be a regression in that area.
- ch_123 5y agoAs someone who loved Opera up to 12.x, I want to like Vivaldi. However, I've already been burned once by a proprietary web browser deciding to change direction, and I'm not interested in getting burned a second time.
- Proven 5y ago"Burned" how? You wrote 9 extensions for it and then the browser started to suck? Burned... Just export your bookmarks and start using another one.
- filthylurker 5y agoPlease note that Manjaro Cinnamon isn’t official Manjaro, and is maintained separately - other Manjaro flavors still use Firefox as their default.
- jonathonf 5y agoAlthough that edition is maintained by one of the Manjaro GmbH CEOs, and received not insignificant fanfare from Vivaldi as being "the default browser on Manjaro", https://vivaldi.com/blog/vivaldi-is-the-default-browser-on-manjaro-linux/ https://vivaldi.com/blog/vivaldi-is-the-default-browser-on-m...
- AdmiralAsshat 5y agoIsn't Manjaro the distro that previously planned to drop LibreOffice from its installation and include the proprietary word processor FreeOffice instead? [0] I guess my point is, this is kinda par for the course. [0] https://itsfoss.com/libreoffice-freeoffice-manjaro-linux/ https://itsfoss.com/libreoffice-freeoffice-manjaro-linux/
- kunagi7 5y agoBoth Manjaro and its parent Arch Linux aren't distros oriented to pure FOSS. The community repository contains a mix of open and closed source applications. And there's AUR to build your own custom packages, which most of them are just a PKGBUILD file. The PKGBUILD downloads the source, patches it (if required) and compiles it to create the desired package. If the package is closed source it just downloads the binaries and repackages the result as a Pacman package. So they can offer both open and closed source editor suites and you're free to install whatever you want. I've tried several office suites and FreeOffice is quite faster than LibreOffice actually. I've also tried one suite which was an electron app (OnlyOffice) and LibreOffice felt faster than a plane compared to it.
- AdmiralAsshat 5y agoTo be clear, that was sort of my point. This is being viewed as a loss to FOSS, but I think Manjaro was never a FOSS purist from an ideological standpoint to begin with.
- kunagi7 5y agoPretty much, nothing of value was lost today. It would be more surprising if Fedora started to bundle not legally available applications [0] or Debian added the nvidia or amdgpu-pro drivers by default. [0] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/quick-docs/setup_rpmfusion/ https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/quick-docs/setup_rpmfus...
- jonathonf 5y agoI thought your point was that Manjaro isn't afraid to try to introduce commercial software into the default installs... (The FreeOffice version included was essentially feature-limited shareware, also requiring registration after 30 days)
- dtx1 5y agoThis really is a weird decision! And a closed source Browser, too. There was money involved in that decision, i guarantee it. Now talking about browsers since firefox's market share seems directly corrlated to the inverse of their CEOs paycheck, what GOOD options are still out there? * Chrome - Spyware * Chromium variations of all kind - Spyware with some mitigations * Midora, Konquerror, other weird browsers etc. - hopelessly never going to be feature complete enough to be useful * Firefox - Now with spyware AND woke politics! * Firefox based privacy remixes like libewolf - current best choice for privacy and reasonable website compatibility.
- cassianoleal 5y agoWhat spyware is present in Firefox?
- dtx1 5y agoDefault behaviour to send back data to mozilla and run studies WHICH THEY ALREADY ABUSED BEFORE https://www.zdnet.com/article/privacy-touting-mozilla-caught-shoving-mr-robot-add-on-into-firefox/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/privacy-touting-mozilla-caught... edit downvote me to oblivion if you must. I too weep for the mozilla of the olden days. The inarguably good guys winnning their fight david vs goliath style against the evil Mircosoft empire. Sadly, those games are gone.
- hulitu 5y agoSafe browsing sends data to google.
- SquareWheel 5y agoNo it doesn't. It downloads a list routinely and checks requests against it locally. Firefox takes it even further and proxies that request so it appears to be coming from them. It would be extremely wasteful and privacy-invasive if they issued a query to Safe Browsing for every request.
- hammyhavoc 5y ago
- nobody0 5y agoI use Firefox and will continue to do so to resist one browser rules all situation.
- dtx1 5y agoWe are Chrome. Resistance is futile. Your Internet usage as you know it is over. From this time foward, you will be monitized by us!
- wayneftw 5y agoEvery Linux distro uses the Linux kernel and that's not a problem just like Chromium is not a problem for the various browsers that use it. Chromium is entirely open source.
- sodality2 5y agoThe difference is the development of Linux is community based, whereas the direction of Chromium is all but controlled on Chromium.
- wayneftw 5y agoAnd? Firefox is not community based either. That's why we have all sorts of things like Pocket integration and constant pointless UI churn that we don't want. Chromium is a whole 5 million lines of code and meanwhile the Linux kernel is 30 million. If Chromium ever stops serving the community, we'll just take it over. Chrome itself is absolutely fine with me. I wouldn't use anything else right now and I love only having to test with Chrome and Safari. Anyway, it doesn't matter what the tiny loud minority of Firefox users think. They've already lost.
- sodality2 5y agoAt least Firefox is OSS. I can TELL if there's a backdoor. With Vivaldi? I don't. Will be reinstalling clean Arch after this decision. Also, your tone about Chromium is precisely going to create another IE. Screw this monoculture of browsers. Chrome did the FLoC fiasco, this is proof they can't be trusted.
- Ekaros 5y agoUsed Vivaldi for a while albeit on Windows. Dropped it because it broke constantly a game I was playing in browser. Likely due to some high refresh rate and trying to use multiple screens and play video on other one... Strange thing is haven't seen this on Firefox or Opera with same use pattern...
- lcnmrn 5y agoVivaldi is the best browser on Android, but Firefox is king on Win/Mac/Linux.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoWhat makes it so good on Android when there is a major disparity in feature parity with the desktop version of Vivaldi?
- lcnmrn 5y agoActually, the fact that is not the same as desktop browser.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoThen what is the point of setting up Vivaldi's email utility exactly how you want it just to not be able to use it on your phone or equivocal tablet?
- kunagi7 5y agoAs a Vivaldi user I'm quite happy to see my default browser as a default for Manjaro Cinnamon. I've been using it since 1.x on both desktop and mobile (after they added the adblocker). From my point of view, I try FOSS alternatives but if I don't like them... I don't like to spend time changing CSS files or messing with configurations. I spent quite a lot of time doing just that for Pale Moon and then Firefox. These days, I just use closed ones (or none). But... From the FOSS point of view, Vivaldi is closed source and we shouldn't use it. I keep ungoogled-chromium as an alternative on my desktop devices and Bromite on Android for sensitive stuff (things like banking). Still, I hope that someday Vivaldi makes its source available. Even if it's mostly a custom Chromium base with a React user interface (and quite complete actually) on top.
- taylodl 5y agoA few months ago I went on a quest to find a new browser. I settled on Vivaldi (and I tried just about every browser there is!) It's quite simply the best browser I've ever used. I love the tab groups, the speed dial, the way it manages bookmarks, the notes - it's just a lot of small things that really make it a great browser to use.
- bstar77 5y agoIt seems the worst thing you can say about Vivaldi is that it’s closed source. I actually really like Vivaldi when I want a bloated browser experience (sometimes I do). I’ve been jumping between Vivaldi and Qutebrowser on my Linux box. Qute us amazing except when it isn’t, which is about 10% of the time. Im not sure how much I care about browsers being proprietary as long as the engine is open source (I really like safari). If there’s evidence that Vivaldi is doing terrible things with my usage data then I’ll likely change back to FF.
- brnt 5y agoLast I read [1] Vivaldi was one of the chattier browsers out there [2], generating a unique ID for you, and building from source also was not actually possible. Wonder if this has changed, and how Manjaro handles the building. Much of Vivaldi's components are closed source (the mail client for instance). [1] https://spyware.neocities.org/articles/vivaldi.html https://spyware.neocities.org/articles/vivaldi.html [2] https://brave.com/popular-browsers-first-run/ https://brave.com/popular-browsers-first-run/
- kunagi7 5y agoManjaro used to do nothing around Vivaldi's package. It's just the inherited community/vivaldi package from the Arch Linux's repositories. I have a Manjaro and an Arch Linux machine with me so I can just type "pacman -Qi vivaldi" on both of them and reveal the package's information: Name : vivaldi Version : 4.1.2369.21-1 Description : An advanced browser made with the power user in mind. Architecture : x86_64 URL : https://vivaldi.com https://vivaldi.com [...] Installed Size : 278,59 MiB Packager : Ike Devolder <ike.devolder@gmail.com> [...] The same result comes out on both machines.
- lucideer 5y ago<slightly-off-topic-but-relevant-rant> Recently started using an RPM-based OS as my daily driver (previously Debian->Gentoo->macOS, never ever used anything RPM-based before). I'm mainly terminal-based, so the number of GUI apps I installed is pretty small: FirefoxDevEdition (my main browser), Chrome (needed for cross-browser testing as a web-dev), Slack, Telegram, VSCode. Only one of those posed a problem. The open-source one. The irony of this is pretty embarrassing. A LOT of this can be put down to the fragmentation of Linux OS package management, and the package repos maintained by individual OSes, but the entire experience has been so bad with Firefox in many ways that can't really be blamed on CentOS/Fedora/RHEL folk, or on the broader Linux community in general. - Not only do Mozilla not provide any 3rd-party yum repo, they don't even provide RPMs. - The built-in Firefox updater UI dropdown (with the upgrade now button) triggers but doesn't seem to have considered Linux at all: it's just a no-op. It would be nice if the updater actually worked in Linux (as Chrome's does), but if it's a no-op the UI should at least not be misleading/confusing. - The updater CLI is largely undocumented, it doesn't autodownload new versions (you must handle that yourself) and it doesn't gracefully handle killing/restarting running processes. - There is no programmatic way to shutdown the Firefox process gracefully via the Linux cli anyway... - Firefox puts its user data in "$HOME/.mozilla" instead of being XDG compliant. If that's Firefox's level of support for what is (surely?) the 2nd biggest Linux packaging format, I wonder what the Manjaro/Pacman experience is like. I get that Arch's systems are generally much simpler, so it might be much better, but still...
- lbhdc 5y agoI am not sure what Mozillas involvement in creating any of these RPMs, but there are a number of RPMs available for firefox[0]. I am running fedora, and firefox is in the default repos. [0] https://rpmfind.net/linux/rpm2html/search.php?query=firefox https://rpmfind.net/linux/rpm2html/search.php?query=firefox
- lucideer 5y agoJust referring to DevEdition here. The mainline Firefox is the default on a few RPM distros, so definitely is included in repos (That said a few of my bullet-points still apply to mainline, particularly around updaters & XDG). One could definitely argue that this is an edge-case, but... then one wonders who the typical DevEdition user being targetted is.
- dna_polymerase 5y agoIf they disabled installation of other browsers I'd be concerned. This way people can interact with a browser that is not commonly known and give it a try. Maybe some people like it, others will just install whatever they prefer. Firefox is coming to an end. The Mozilla mismanagement can't be continued forever, either people start supporting a new browser vendor or Chrome monoculture it will be.
- jdlyga 5y agoVivaldi is nice, but it's a niche browser. It has a ton of features, and some people might find that bloated. I definitely do not think it should be default.
- rubyn00bie 5y agoI think this artisanal browser shit is a disservice and what pushes people away from Linux. Every single “custom browser” out there is largely, IMHO, a pile of shit. They very often add no value except for niche use cases which almost no one uses. They’re likely to confuse users because they abso-fucking-lutely have never heard of it. I seriously don’t know how the hell anyone thinks this sort of thing is user friendly or good.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoThe solution is simple: ship with a basic open source browser, and during the intitial setup procedure, the wizard should ask users if they want to import data from an existing browser they currently use, or use that same browser, and to select it. This lack of understanding onboarding and setup UX is the great differentiator from Windows and macOS for most consumers.
- smoldesu 5y agoHey, I use Manjaro Cinnamon! I'm still gonna stick with Firefox, but Vivaldi is a pretty good browser from what I've tried of it. The only thing I dislike is their leadership: they cited 'Vivaldi's brand' as the reason why they can't go open source, which seems like such a cop-out in my eyes that I switched back to Firefox. That said, browsers are hard to get right, so at the very least, Kudos to the Vivaldi team for being less-terrible than Chrome.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoWell Firefox users are used to having to install a browser on their Desktop OS. It's usually the first thing I do on any OS and typically the last time I use the bundled browser. Chrome users have a similar experience (unless you are on Android or ChromeOS of course). Otherwise most of us would be using Edge and Safari instead. I actually played a little with arch recently in a VM. It's actually a quite nice distribution. With arch the whole point seems to be not getting locked into any kind of opinionated defaults for whatever. The gnome desktop I installed comes with a thing simply called Web, which appears to be some Gnome Webkit derivative. I also played with Manjaro, which is a lot simpler to setup. I wouldn't get to hung up on default apps on either of those two platforms. If you install them, you kind of should know what you are doing and what you like.
- vegai_ 5y agoI guess I'm one of the last ones to ditch Firefox. I moved to chromium very recently and everything's just smoother. I totally get why people do that. Firefox still has some use insofar that adblocker blockers don't target it as much.