6 ms·
"Wi-Fi is among the most successful wireless technologies ever invented. As Wi-Fi becomes more and more present in public and private spaces, it becomes natural
by belter 5y ago
"Wi-Fi is among the most successful wireless technologies ever invented. As Wi-Fi becomes more and more present in public and private spaces, it becomes natural to leverage its ubiquitousness to implement groundbreaking wireless sensing applications such as human presence detection, activity recognition, and object tracking, just to name a few."
"...and private spaces, it becomes natural to leverage its ubiquitousness ..."
Are these researchers soley focused on their next grant only, do they live in another world? Or do they sometimes pause and think about the ethics of their research?
- Joeri 5y agoThey think about it, they just consider it somebody else’s problem. The genie is somewhat out of the bottle already, because existing access points can track the position of wifi devices and deduce a lot of this information. This takes it one step further to also track people without wifi devices.
- belter 5y agoThis will be deployed in 3 years or so. I think we need a legal and technical approach that will allow "stand your ground" type of rules. Against my neighbor WiFi waves and FFT extrapolation of what division of the house I am in at the moment and with who.
- ptr2voidStar 5y ago> "Stand your ground" rules American spotted.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> The genie is somewhat out of the bottle already Very much so. As early as 2012, maybe 2013, retailers were piloting technology that would offer guest wifi networks, then track you using the in-store surveillance cameras. Don't even need facial recognition, just tie the person's identity to the phone they logged in with. The camera adds better location data than you could get with the wifi alone. This was about the time that Amazon was offering a Black Friday discount if you used their app to scan the barcode of a product in a retail store, then bought online — and back then, only checkout was https, so if you were in the data path you could detect that sort of a lookup.
- pier25 5y agoI recently traveled and used JFK's free wifi. I went to a duty free shop to buy some chocolates and now all online ads ar showing me the same woman perfume ad.
- Darmody 5y agoI've thought about that. But what's the alternative? Someone else would do it anyway and use it against you.
- EGreg 5y agoSame argument goes for general AI, weapons and everything else.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoEven if they do this type of research and don't release it to the public, you can bet nations states already are doing the same research in private, and using it against whoever they want. Better to have this in the public eye, than to be too scared to carry out the research in fear of others abusing it. because whether the research is done publicly or not, the "bad guys" are probably doing it in private.
- HWR_14 5y agoYour threat model for ubiquitous cheap sensing tech is nation states? I'm not overly worried about being spied on by nation states. In general, my feeling is that if a nation-state decides I'm important enough to deploy hardware against, I have no real defense. Now, big tech companies putting it everywhere, and either convincing the stores I shop at or my neighbors to pay for the hardware and slurping up the data - that is a real danger case. And those companies build off academic research like this. Even trillion-dollar companies don't do as much of this research inhouse as they do by sponsoring grants like this.
- BurningFrog 5y agoWe can already see where in the store you are.
- colechristensen 5y agoBut your clerks aren’t going to record every step i take for a decade inside your store and run algorithms to manipulate my brain into optimizing store outcomes.
- withinboredom 5y agoThey already do this using security cameras. How do you think the manufacturers know which shelves and the placements of them to bid on?
- 5y ago
- marcinzm 5y ago>Are these researchers soley focused on their next grant only, do they live in another world? Or do they sometimes pause and think about the ethics of their research? Should we not do any third party security testing or vulnerability detection either? Ignorance is not a solution to a potential problem but simply means you won't know about it until it's far too late.
- gambler 5y agoNice funding scheme you have here. Develop a threat, write it up as if you're researching it for prevention. The more you work on it, the bigger the threat will get, the more money you can ask for to research "prevention" in the future. This is literally how a lot of this sort of research works.
- natpalmer1776 5y agoIt's a digital arms race. You can't prevent it from happening by condeming those who are participating. These unfolding events are merely organic consequences to overarching dysfunction within society.
- wpietri 5y agoYour theory is that nobody but researchers looking for funding to publish about threats would find these threats? That seems very optimistic to me.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoSeems like a convoluted way to secure research funding. If you don't care who you hurt it would probably be simpler to just go work for a defense contractor and drop the publication pretense altogether.
- kevingadd 5y agoResearch ethics are a very important consideration, but in this case this research is identifying a real risk posed by people's widespread deployment of Wi-Fi. We need to know the risks it creates so we can make our choices appropriately - otherwise the only people who know are criminals and nation states.
- gambler 5y ago>Are these researchers soley focused on their next grant only Yes, they are. Anyone who is saying otherwise is either gaslighting you or speaks out of their ass. The way science is funded right now is incredibly broken. This is admitted both by people who worked in research during 60s-70s (when funding worked differently) and by honest people who worked in modern academia. Alan Kay speaks about this often: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdHtYW_wcAs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdHtYW_wcAs Dark Horse podcast spoke at length about the current system: https://odysee.com/@DarkHorsePodcastClips:b/corruption-in-science-and-academia-(from:5 https://odysee.com/@DarkHorsePodcastClips:b/corruption-in-sc...
- rapjr9 5y agoI worked in Computer Science (CS) research for 20 years. Some researchers take privacy concerns seriously, many do not and see it as out of scope or a nuisance. CS is still mostly male and hence most research is done by male grad students. Young males are often fascinated by spy stuff (I know I was) and will orient their research around it. The conferences where they publish papers also reward them for it by publishing their papers, which indicates an acceptance of this kind of research by the community. Similarly I saw lots of grad students who arranged their research around quadcopters. They liked quadcopters and wanted to play with them so they looked for research that could be done with quadcopters. If they could do CS research that involved looking at porn and get it published they'd probably all flock to that. So part of the explanation is human nature, but the fact it is accepted and published shows there is little real critical review of potential misuse of this kind of research. It is also really difficult to invent anything that can not be misused, especially in research involving sensors. A WiFi sensor can monitor your heart rate for health purposes but can also monitor your heart rate to sell you more stuff. However I've been thinking the same thing for many years, that much of the CS research seems aimed at spying on people. Companies that will be hiring those grad students may also be partly to blame by hiring students who do such research, probably because it fits with their own corporate data collection and analysis practices on their customers. Grad students want jobs after they graduate, and developing spy stuff gets them jobs. The military -wants- spy stuff so they encourage this kind of research. So the solution seems to be to somehow get more awareness of potential misuse factored into paper reviews, encourage more research on mitigating misuse of new technologies, and getting more women into CS. Unfortunately women seem to be leaving or not choosing CS more and more lately. Some women may like spy stuff too even though it has historically been more of a male thing, probably due to the military. I'm not sure there is anywhere yet that you could publish research into mitigating misuse of new technology (except privacy research journals). Sometimes there are solutions for classes of sensors, like cameras or microphones. For example, f you have an interesting application based on cameras but recording video would be very privacy sensitive you might be able to only output the processed result and throw away the video data, and a commercial version could be a chip that does exactly that, making misuse of the video impossible.
- aidenn0 5y agoWide-band (and ultrawide-band) microwaves were already used for such through-wall sensing. It was just a matter of time before somebody noticed that there is already wide-band microwave transceiver in everybody's home.
- IncRnd 5y agoI'm sure you recognize the motivations of people who would investigate technology that can peer into a closed and locked room. I recall the first time I read about using a laser to image the contents of a room. It was old-fashioned military technology when I read about it then - the 1980s.
- lp0_on_fire 5y ago> Or do they sometimes pause and think about the ethics of their research Obviously they don't
- m9731526 5y agoThis resonate me, but also it's impractical to expect something achievable with tech to never happens as long as humanity exists. It's not even about who invent it. The only solution is new tech to counter... new tech, it's no way back, I believe.
- xmcqdpt2 5y agoAs someone who worked on a DoD funded project, that's how you get the grants. A very large proportion of physics, chemistry and engineering is funded by defense interests. Academic scientists span a large range of politics, from peace-loving hippies to pro military hawks. Many scientists just run on a heavy justification treadmill ("if it's not our group, it would be another one" and "this tech is not yet ready for deployment anyway" and "we'd be doing this work anyway, so it doesn't matter if we spin it as defense related"). Frankly, ethics is not really a strong point for physical scientists and is kinda selected against by the hiring system. Being able to take DoD money and sleep at night helps a lot to get tenure.
- fennecfoxy 5y agoIt's the sort of thing where "if we don't do it, someone else will". These sorts of things are better to research and make known to the public so that they can be legislated etc etc.