4 ms·
We’re Asking the Impossible of Vaccines [On sterilizing immunity]
- mdp2021 5y ago> In 1846, ... Peter Ludvig Panum traveled to the Faroe Islands in search of measles. ... slammed with an outbreak, ... Dozens of the islands’ eldest residents, who had survived another measles epidemic in 1781—65 years earlier—weren’t getting sick this time around. “Not one ... was attacked the second time.” ... his observations helped spark the inklings of ... the promise of perfect immunity. > technical coarseness might help explain why several historical vaccines have been assumed to be sterilizing ... When virtually no one fell ill after an inoculation campaign, researchers figured that infections had evaporated as well > For most of vaccination history, humans have been guided by stopping sickness, and that’s been enough. The smallpox vaccine wasn’t sterilizing; it still helped us eradicate a pathogen. Even measles, ... can offer an optimistic example The article does not go into much depth - the immediate questions about "why and how" are largely unanswered. It was written more as a polemic against "sterilizing immunity as a myth". Still, the few positive points which are present remain interesting, though thirst enticing instead of thirst quenching.