8 ms·
If you aren't happy giving out your real name, you shouldn't be using social networking. Anyone with a social graph of any size has already betrayed their iden
by jdietrich 15y ago
If you aren't happy giving out your real name, you shouldn't be using social networking.
Anyone with a social graph of any size has already betrayed their identity, whether they know it or not. When people are sharing large volumes of data about themselves and their connections to others, they are a correlation attack waiting to happen. Pseudonymity on the internet is largely a fool's paradise - either you are fully anonymous, or you are using an identity which is separated from your own by a brittle and invisible membrane.
You may be filtering out low-level annoyances, but you're also establishing a false sense of security. If anon chooses to dox you, they'll do it and there's not a damned thing you can do to stop them. Pseudonymity offers some degree of protection for people with little to hide, but if for whatever reason you sincerely believe yourself to be a target, you should act as if your pseudonym has already been compromised.
- darklajid 15y agoSo you say my ex is going to correlate the social graphs of well-known friends of mine to find me online? What's the difference for you between a forum for anonymous alcoholics and a G+ circle with 'Joe' and 'Bob'? Don't conflate the wish to withhold your name with the 'I need to be anonymous or the government is going to kill me' with all the other reasons, please.
- gte910h 15y ago>So you say my ex is going to correlate the social graphs of well-known friends of mine to find me online? That's exactly what abusive ex partners due. I am currently working with a social networking component of an iPhone app and "Guy who used to beat his wife" and "Not being found by that guy if you're the ex-wife" is a scenario we're actively making sure is protected against. You are aware many pictures have geolocation data in them no? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exchangeable_image_file_format#Geolocation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exchangeable_image_file_format#... You don't see how that could be accidentally dangerous for a person?
- darklajid 15y agoWhoa. I think we're on the same side (reading your other posts here. Please do the same..). I was merely pointing out (tongue in cheek) that one (the parent of my post) doesn't need to play the 'you're not anonymous anyway and cannot hide' card. There are plenty of good reasons (one is just .. preference) to choose a pseudonym. I wanted to put a little perspective on the thread. Holding up for people that rely on this feature for their well-being is on a different level. You seem to come from that direction. I cannot comment on cases like that, because I'm ultimately lucky to have no such experiences and live a relaxed life.
- gte910h 15y agoSorry man, missed it.
- danilocampos 15y ago> If you aren't happy giving out your real name, you shouldn't be using social networking. The many dissidents who live in oppressive regimes and use these tools to coordinate resistance and provide support for like-minded allies will care not even a little bit about your guidance. The privilege implied by the bias in your remark is exactly the trouble with these real name policies in the first place. Christians in China, gay kids in the Bible belt, women in Saudi Arabia, they're all entitled to take measured risks to find fellowship in their struggle. It's not for you or Google or Facebook to tell them what they should or should not do with their identity on social tools. Assuming the social platform operators provide reasonable disclosure about the risks, it's up to these folks to assume those risks and try for anonymity if they want it.
- smokinjoe 15y agoGiven the fact that the number of social tools is only increasing, isn't there feasibly a social network for everyone? If anonymity is important, use Twitter or another product. I actually appreciate Google making people use their real names, it's a step forward to actually having the ability to make people responsible for their actions online. Google isn't forcing you to use your real name everywhere until the end of time, simply on their Google Plus Network.
- danilocampos 15y ago> I actually appreciate Google making people use their real names, it's a step forward to actually having the ability to make people responsible for their actions online. I'm going to be honest: your comfort and enjoyment of the internet is orders of magnitude less valuable to me than the knowledge that good, decent folks who are endangered by harmful zealots can have a safe place to communicate with their compatriots. If the companies responsible for these platforms don't recognize the importance of this opportunity, they're squandering their unique position to make some good money while making the world a better place. And that's a shame.
- philwelch 15y ago
- crux_ 15y ago> low-level annoyances ... like abusive former partners, death threats, being involuntarily outed, etc etc etc. Calling these things "low-level annoyances" betrays a deep self-absorption.
- gte910h 15y agoIf you're trying to escape a abusive ex-partner, you need to be on the social networks to make sure other people aren't posting pictures of you giving away your location.