3 ms·
Pardon my following likely idiotic statement from a layperson, but the surprising matter of the charge distribution within the neutron suggests that the nuclear
by kazinator 5y ago
Pardon my following likely idiotic statement from a layperson, but the surprising matter of the charge distribution within the neutron suggests that the nuclear "weak force" is actually just electrostatic force. So that is to say, if the neutron is slightly negative near the surface, what if that's the entire basis of the force that makes neutrons able to bind protons in the atom nucleus. We would expect this to be a kind of dipole whose field drops off rapidly with distance.
- LegitShady 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroweak_interaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroweak_interaction
- thayne 5y agoFirst of all, the nucleus is held together by the strong nuclear force, not the weak nuclear force (the weak force causes certain kinds of decay, such as a neutron to decay into a proton and electron). Secondly, as soon as you have multiple protons, the repulsion from the positive charges will be much, much greater than any dipole attraction. Finally, physicists have done a lot of really precise measurements with subatomic particles, and I don't think a dipole interaction like that would match the observed results.
- kazinator 5y agoRight! The strong nuclear force is over two orders of magnitude stronger than electromagnetism, so it cannot be caused by it. It has to be, in order overcome the vehement repulsion among the protons.
- betterunix2 5y agoActually the relationship between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force is well understood. It would have to be related, given that the weak interaction is the cause of beta decay, which results in a neutron becoming a proton (which has a positive electromagnetic charge) and the creation of an electron (which has a negative charge). The force carrying particles of the weak force can also have electromagnetic charge, further demonstrating the connection between the two phenomena. You can reason about all the forces being related in some way. For example, beta decay happens in free neutrons, but does not happen in a helium-4 nucleus; there should be a connection with the strong nuclear force that explains this. In some sense the fact that we can observe or measure an interaction implies that it must be related to other forces, since our ability to make an observation is itself dependent on such connections (in the end you need some electromagnetic effect that your eyes can perceive).