3 ms·
Communication is a two-way street. When someone is making an effort to learn, most FP advocates will happily make an effort to teach. But someone who comes in w
by lmm 5y ago
Communication is a two-way street. When someone is making an effort to learn, most FP advocates will happily make an effort to teach. But someone who comes in with guns blazing doesn't get to complain about being met with hostility, and if telling someone they're wrong when they're wrong is gatekeeping then it's a kind of gatekeeping that we need.
- xigency 5y agoBeing a teacher is a labor of love. There’s nothing wrong with a student coming in with any attitude. This attitude justifying gatekeeping reminds me of Stack Overflow - mods tired of seeing the same wrong questions asked. But it’s a Q&A site and the purpose is for people to get answers to their questions.
- bidirectional 5y agoYes, that goes for teachers. Not normal working programmers who choose to discuss FP in the terminology which has been commonplace for decades. They are under no such obligation.
- alex_smart 5y agoA Q&A website needs both people who ask questions, and people who answer them. Perhaps the latter even more than the former. You can ask a question on stackexchange and have it answered by Peter Shor. Not having the platform inundadated by dumb repetitive questions and homework problems is the compromise you need to retain such talented people on your platform. If you want an example of what happens to a Q&A site without any gatekeeping, look at Quora.
- WJW 5y ago> There’s nothing wrong with a student coming in with any attitude. A student can definitely have an attitude that prevents them from learning effectively though. If anyone wants to see the use of correct terminology as "gatekeeping" then they are of course free to do so but the obstacles to learning the subject that such a mindset creates are then a logical consequence of their actions and entirely their own fault.
- rizky05 5y agoYou remind me of sheldon.
- void_mint 5y agoI would say the person you're responding to didn't come in "guns blazing". They seemed legitimately eager to learn, and expressed gratitude that the person that wrote the blog post used language they could understand. Now, I would say you showing up and openly disparaging both the blog and the person you responded to qualifies as "guns blazing".
- lmm 5y agoThey said "It's like when the medieval Catholic Church refused to print a bible in anything but Latin so that they'd remain the sole authority on its content." and concluded with "shame on those who maintain this status quo." That's pretty "guns blazing" in my book.
- void_mint 5y ago> "It's like when the medieval Catholic Church refused to print a bible in anything but Latin so that they'd remain the sole authority on its content." The debate is about using language as a gatekeeping mechanism. The analogy is spot on... > "shame on those who maintain this status quo." A person shows up eager to learn, expresses gratitude, feels scorned at all of the language-based gatekeeping that goes into this topic. You don't think it's fair to feel frustrated with the people doing the gatekeeping? (I don't think _you_ will, but only because I think you're one of the gatekeepers the original poster is (fairly) shaming).
- lmm 5y ago> A person shows up eager to learn, expresses gratitude, feels scorned at all of the language-based gatekeeping that goes into this topic. They expressed gratitude for those who told them easy falsehoods and scorn for those who told them harder truths, characterizing such honesty as "gatekeeping". That's not the action of someone eager to learn, it's someone who's eager to avoid learning, like those politicians who, rather than put in the effort to understand the economic implications of their policy, go shopping around economists until they find one who gives them the answer they want.