5 ms·
A lot of these policies really strike me as White Supremacism 2.0. To quote Wikipedia: "White supremacy, as with racial supremacism in general, is rooted in et
by Alex3917 15y ago
A lot of these policies really strike me as White Supremacism 2.0. To quote Wikipedia:
"White supremacy, as with racial supremacism in general, is rooted in ethnocentrism and a desire for hegemony."
In other words, white supremacism isn't about white people per se. Rather, it's about promoting one culture as the dominant one while trying to suppress all other cultures. That's exactly what these policies are doing.
- davidw 15y agoFrom a real name policy to "White Supremacy" is quite a leap. I think back on planet earth, what's more likely is that the people who created these systems are insisting on real names to solve one sort of problem without thinking about the other problems it may cause, rather than "a desire for hegemony" or "promoting one culture as the dominant one".
- sliverstorm 15y agoYour parent's point of view is the current extension of political correctness taken to it's extreme. That is to say, the world is steadily being encroached by the idea that not expressly considering a minority in a decision is the same as actively campaigning against them.
- pyre 15y agoWell, Mark Zuckerberg has claimed that people that don't use their real name are Bad People(tm). (1000 thanks to whoever can conjure up a link to that quote) Personally, that seems like he's attacking anyone that opposes his idea of trying to force people into using real names. The same can't be said of other systems (Google+, Quora, etc) to my knowledge.
- pyre 15y agoHere's a link: http://michaelzimmer.org/2010/05/14/facebooks-zuckerberg-having-two-identities-for-yourself-is-an-example-of-a-lack-of-integrity/ http://michaelzimmer.org/2010/05/14/facebooks-zuckerberg-hav... Zuckerberg thinks that anyone that has two identities for themselves has a 'lack of integrity.'
- adw 15y agoOr - and this is taking the opposite polemical position to yours - that designing systems without empathy is reprehensible. I lean more to the latter but that doesn't mean what you claim is entirely false either. It's not as simple as anyone paints it, and what's more, it's an area where short-term economic incentives are often drastically misaligned with both goals of personal autonomy and, more arguably, long-term success of a community and product. But unrestrained personal autonomy gets you 4chan. The real problem is trying to flatten the richness of human experience to fit through TweetBook+ (or whatever comes next). No easy answers and the problem ain't going away.
- 18pfsmt 15y agoI think you should look at the HN community as a model, rather than 4chan. Consistent pseudonyms, tied to karma seems to work. No?
- damncabbage 15y agoUntil an account starts getting its posts auto-killed. When you say "consistent", what's your position on multiple pseudonyms (or "restarts")?
- ender7 15y agoHegemony is very distinct from the white supremacist movement. While white supremacists probably promote hegemonic practices, this does not mean that some engineer who didn't take the time to think about people in circumstances very different from his/her own is a white supremacist. Sadly, dominant members of a hegemonic culture (read: pretty much every culture) participate subconsciously to reinforce the hegemony simply by not being aware of it. I understand that you don't like the Real Name requirement, but pulling out the Big Gun Labels like this is akin to calling Larry Page the New Hitler. It's not accurate, and all you're going to do is make people angry.
- Alex3917 15y agoSo is your argument that the system does not promote cultural hegemony, or that it is not intended to promote cultural hegemony? Because the latter, while it may be true, is largely irrelevant. I think it's entirely possible that you can get forces that promote hegemony as an unintended consequence of seemingly innocuous design decisions, or else as an emergent phenomenon of complex systems. I'm not trying to call Larry Page the new Hitler, rather I'm just pointing out that there is an existing word for what Danah Boyd and others are describing.
- sliverstorm 15y agoender7 (an ironic name) did not refute the idea that the system promotes hegemony. His issue appears to be with your conflation of hegemony and white supremacy. Your argument is a classic logical fallacy- "white supremacists want hegemony. We have a hegemony. Ergo, the system is run by white supremacists"
- _delirium 15y agoOddly enough, a lot of who used to be "white suprematists" are these days are more of the non-hegemonic cultural-separatist types, heavily influenced by postmodernism and postcolonial theory in the "right of Peoples to self-determination" sort of sense (at least those associated with the 'New Right' theorists). You end up with strange spectacles like French nationalists getting along well with right-wing Turkish nationalists, Japanese nationalists, or Israeli nationalists--- they all agree that they'd like to observe each other peacefully from a distance, in each group's pure, mono-ethnic country, each with their Glorious Histories and whatnot, maybe with the occasional bit of tourism, but definitely no immigration.
- tlb 15y agoI think "cultural imperialism" is the term you want.
- napierzaza 15y agoWhite supremacy did not invent hegemony. It's a fallacy. There are people who say that places like Africa or North America was peaceful before the europeans. Unfortunately they were both very active places where people would kill their neighbours. It's a part of humanity, one we need to fight against.