3 ms·
They increase the risk of asymptomatic transmission, because vaccines suppress the symptoms of infection, which would otherwise signal the infected person to qu
by walterbell 5y ago
They increase the risk of asymptomatic transmission, because vaccines suppress the symptoms of infection, which would otherwise signal the infected person to quarantine. The CDC says this can be addressed by regular testing of the vaccinated, https://archive.is/PW9SP https://archive.is/PW9SP
> The agency now advises that vaccinated people be tested for the virus if they come into contact with someone with Covid-19, even if they have no symptoms... “Our updated guidance recommends vaccinated people get tested upon exposure regardless of symptoms,” Dr. Rochelle P. Walensky, the agency’s director, said in an email to The New York Times. “Testing is widely available.”
- tfehring 5y agoDo you have a source for the claim that a vaccinated person is more likely than an unvaccinated person to transmit the virus asymptomatically?
- walterbell 5y agoThat wasn't the claim. The claim was that an unvaccinated person can self-isolate when they observe symptoms. As the CDC said above, absence of symptoms is not a sufficient indicator for a vaccinated person. If a vaccinated person is tested regularly, they can self-isolate upon a positive test result, since they can't rely on symptoms as a signal.
- MagnumOpus 5y ago> absence of symptoms is not a sufficient indicator for a vaccinated person Absence of symptoms is not a sufficient indicator for the unvaxed either, so your argument falls apart. Why isn't 90% reduction in ICU occupation and 70% reduction in chance of infection a sufficient argument for the public benefits? Just because it is not perfect, you'd rather let the country's hospitals overload and shut down?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoThe problem with COVID-19 all along has been that it is transmissible before being symptomatic. That is why it spread like wildfire when SARS and MERS did not. Listened to a good interview on NPR some months ago with a leading coronavirus expert who went over this in detail, but unfortunately can't remember her name or find the interview right now. In any case, vaccines don't really change the equation here. Testing for temperature and symptoms with COVID have proven to be ineffective because asymptomatic transmission in the early stages is a thing with COVID-19 even without vaccination.
- ac29 5y ago> symptoms of infection, which would otherwise signal the infected person to quarantine I'm not sure that people who have chosen not to get vaccinated by this point are going to be the people who follow self-quarantine rules well.
- walterbell 5y agoSome of those who have chosen not to get vaccinated are those already recovered from Covid, who now have natural immunity. This includes many essential workers and first responders, who worked throughout 2020 without the protection of a vaccine. That leaves the subset of non-immune people who are unvaccinated. If this hypothetical person is reckless (as your comment suggests), should they not have already been infected in the past 18 months? If they were not infected in 18 months, that suggests at least some ability to isolate and self-monitor.
- gbear605 5y agoNatural immunity is not as strong as the immunity provided by the vaccines and the immunity provided by both together is much stronger. Having already had COVID is no reason not to get vaccinated.
- phendrenad2 5y agoThey increase the risk of asymptotic transmission, but decrease the risk of transmission overall.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 5y agoHow do you reach that conclusion?