4 ms·
His schtick is claiming he’s real “father of deep learning” and that all major work in ML has been built off of work done in his lab, and that he’s unjustly rem
by jowday 5y ago
His schtick is claiming he’s real “father of deep learning” and that all major work in ML has been built off of work done in his lab, and that he’s unjustly remained unrecognized while other pioneers in the field have received tons of awards and compensation from big tech companies.
When I say it’s his shtick, I mean that he basically brings it up whenever possible. When another big name in the field receives an award, he’ll write up a huge blog post about how ackshually they didn’t invent XYZ, but rather modified A and B, which is related to work C he did at his lab in 1980.
See
https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/critique-honda-prize-hinton.html https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/critique-honda-prize-hinto...
https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/naturedeepmind.html https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/naturedeepmind.html
https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/critique-turing-award-bengio-hinton-lecun.html https://people.idsia.ch//~juergen/critique-turing-award-beng...
At 1:03:00 in this video he interrupts a lecture at NIPS from Goodfellow (another leader in the field) to try and claim credit for the subject of the lecture in a sort of slimy way.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=HGYYEUSm-0Q&feature=share https://youtube.com/watch?v=HGYYEUSm-0Q&feature=share
Honestly I’m not equipped to tell whether Schmidhuber’s claims are true since I haven’t followed the progression of ML research since the 1980s - but the impression I get of him is that he’s kind of a jackass who’s willing to spend a ton of time tearing others down in really petty ways. If there is some truth to his claims, perhaps the reason he’s unrecognized is because he’s a bit of an ass to work with?
- rich_sasha 5y agoI met him, he’s very nice in person (at least over the course of a day, say). Kind, patient and genuinely interested in other people. So I doubt it is as simple as he’s a horrible person. But clearly he’s an outlier in terms of demanding recognition.
- saeranv 5y agoTangent: While I've listened to him on podcasts, and am reading his Deep Learning textbook, this is the first time I've seen Goodfellow in person. I'm crushed to see that he is not, as I assumed, some 60 year old professor who has spent decades earning his expertise, and instead is someone young enough to pass as a college student!