4 ms·
That comment on incentives is funny, but I'm not sure it captures the situation here: The mathematicians who wrote The Disc Embedding Theorem have been quite s
by auntienomen 5y ago
That comment on incentives is funny, but I'm not sure it captures the situation here: The mathematicians who wrote The Disc Embedding Theorem have been quite successful. All are on the tenure ladder (or tenured already) and publishing novel research in a field they revitalized.
I can see how sinking time into this is risky, but that's generally true of choosing a field of research. I think the authors deserve credit for doing it well. Likewise, Peter Teichner should get a little credit for helping to create the space for them to do so.
- spekcular 5y agoI agree, actually. I think a book published by a major academic press is a plus for any tenure/promotion committee. Further, this is definitely not just "expository" work; as the article notes, they had a bunch of gaps/errors to fix. I expect the importance of those contributions would be reflected in strong recommendation letters for promotion.