3 ms·
The problem with unions is that skilled workers don't need them and unskilled workers have no power even in a union. Skilled workers are scarce, so they alread
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
The problem with unions is that skilled workers don't need them and unskilled workers have no power even in a union.
Skilled workers are scarce, so they already have negotiating power at the individual level and collective bargaining is just overhead and another bureaucracy to take a vig that could have gone into your paycheck.
Unskilled workers aren't scarce, so what happens if they unionize? The union strikes, the company hires a different set of unskilled workers and all the union workers get is laid off.
This is especially true for an Amazon warehouse because there are thousands of them all over the world. If the workers at a warehouse near San Francisco strike, not only can they easily hire different workers, they can just send everybody their stuff from another warehouse in Nevada or any of a thousand other places.
What unskilled workers need isn't a union, it's some way to make unskilled labor more scarce, e.g. a UBI so that people aren't so desperate for a job and can hold out for better pay and working conditions.
- fallingknife 5y ago> it's some way to make unskilled labor more scarce Maybe don't allow employers to hire 10's of millions of illegal immigrants under the table?
- kelnos 5y agoCare to back up a wild claim like that with some citations?
- burnished 5y agoI generally agree with your conclusion and recognize your arguments. This might just be ignorance on my part, but don't we have a history of unions fighting for labor rights and securing real improvements for unskilled labor? My understanding is they've been sharply eroded, but minimum wage and a 40 hour work week alone seem like incredible improvements.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoMost of the successful 20th century unions weren't representing unskilled workers, they were representing skilled workers against employers so large that they had market power in the labor market for that type of skilled labor, like the Big 3 auto makers. The problem for those workers was that although they were skilled labor, the number of employers who needed auto workers was small enough for them to act as a cartel. The concentrated market offset the negotiating power of a skilled individual, but at the same time, a company that employed a third of the auto workers in the country couldn't just replace them all if they went on strike. But that was kind of a pathological circumstance and the better solution in that case is to do some trust busting. Or if competition increases on its own as it did from the Japanese automakers during the oil crisis. The closest thing to that in the modern economy is the relationship between app developers and platform app stores. It's the same sort of cartelized market. But some trust busting would work there too. And other markets don't look like that. If you're actually an employee of Google or Apple, they don't have anything like market power in that labor market, because it's the same skillset to go and work for Facebook or Microsoft or Netflix or a million other places including a large number of smaller companies and startups. And if you're a worker at an Amazon warehouse, it's not skilled labor. > My understanding is they've been sharply eroded, but minimum wage and a 40 hour work week alone seem like incredible improvements. Most of the claimed victories were symbolic, because they were things that were happening anyway and then legislators passed laws requiring them after they'd mostly already happened so they could say they were doing something. Workers expect to be paid more to work 80 hours instead of 40, so given the choice between paying one worker for 80 hours and two workers for 40 hours, employers found the second option led to higher worker productivity and reliability because the workers weren't constantly exhausted and making mistakes and didn't as often quit from burnout. Around 2% of people in the US make minimum wage. In other words, ~98% of employers pay more than that even though the law doesn't require them to, because the market does. And even without minimum wage, the other 2% would be making around the same amount of money, because the employer still has to offer enough to get the employee to accept the job. Minimum wage is even harmful to employees because it forces them into bad trade offs they otherwise wouldn't have taken. There might have been a job paying $6/hour across the street from your apartment, but it goes away if minimum wage is $7.25 and then you have to take a job at $7.25 which is an hour away and costs you more than $1.25/hour in commuting expenses, plus the lost time and significantly increased risk of a car accident. Likewise, the limit on hours or requirements to pay overtime can hurt workers, because if you need the extra hours, people end up taking a second job instead, which still doesn't pay time and a half but now you have two commutes instead of having one commute to a single job where you take two shifts. The things that help workers are the things that actually increase their negotiating power. Artificial price controls don't really do that, because when your negotiating power isn't actually any better, you just end up forced to accept worse terms on some other dimension, like the longer commute.
- narrator 5y agoSkilled workers have unions. For example, airline pilots have some pretty strong unions. The jobs that don't work as unions are where workers are not interchangeable because of large differences in talent. This makes it a bad deal for highly talented members of that professions to be in the union, as they can get paid a lot more than the average because of their exceptional talent. If they were in a union, they would be more likely to get paid the same as other members of the union. For example, software developers have wide differences in talent and ability, and thus pay, and that's why they don't unionize. An airplane pilot can only be so good at their job though, even though it takes years of training, so they benefit from a union.
- moduspol 5y agoI generally agree with your take, although professional sports players have unions that seem to work well for them despite being skilled workers with large differences in talent. I guess there's no hard requirement that unions get involved in pay negotiations, and that's the only one I know of that seems to have workers' pay in-line with actual market factors. It's not like Tom Brady has to get paid the same amount as a lesser-performing quarterback just because they've been doing it the same amount of years.
- adwn 5y ago> What unskilled workers need isn't a union, it's some way to make unskilled labor more scarce, e.g. a UBI [...] Here in Germany, unions work as intended. The solution is simple: you can't be fired for participating in a strike. There, problem solved, no UBI necessary. > The problem with unions is that skilled workers don't need them Also wrong. There a many unions for skilled workers in Germany.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> The solution is simple: you can't be fired for participating in a strike. If you're on strike you're not showing up so you're not getting paid. They just let you stay on strike forever and in the meantime hire somebody else. Assuming they don't just close the warehouse, so that you're not getting fired for going on strike, you're getting laid off because the job no longer exists.
- kelnos 5y agoThat doesn't always work, especially when all the workers available for those positions are members of a union. And closing a warehouse is a drastic measure that will undoubtedly cause harm to the company's finances. That's not a decision they'd make lightly. Striking actually can work, and I find it strange that you seem to believe that unions aren't effective. Despite their problems, unions tend to work ok in the US, and even better in other places where they have healthier attitudes toward employment.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> That doesn't always work, especially when all the workers available for those positions are members of a union. But they're not, because it's unskilled labor. They can just hire anyone off the street. > And closing a warehouse is a drastic measure that will undoubtedly cause harm to the company's finances. If you close a warehouse, it's still a warehouse. You sell it to Walmart or Target and pretty much get all of your money back. That's the problem with the whole thing. A strike is brinkmanship. It hurts the workers and the company both. The idea is that if you're willing to hold out longer than they are, you can get what you want. Which you might be able to do if going on strike shuts down their whole business. But going on strike only causes the 10112 mile journey the goods take from source to destination to become a 10188 mile journey. They just route it through some other path. From the company's perspective it's a mild inconvenience that they could suffer indefinitely without ever feeling the need to concede anything over it. Whereas for the warehouse workers, the longer they strike the longer they're not getting paid. So they blink first, and the company knows they will, so the union can't gain anything from striking and is consequently useless.
- ryandrake 5y ago> Skilled workers are scarce, so they already have negotiating power at the individual level and collective bargaining is just overhead and another bureaucracy to take a vig that could have gone into your paycheck. Totally disagree with this. Being skilled at your job doesn't necessarily mean you are skilled at negotiating your pay or working conditions. These are entirely different skills. We all know people who are not as good at their jobs, but are smooth talkers and good negotiators, and vice versa is true, too. I know for sure that I could be making a lot more if I had a professional negotiator, whose job and dedicated skill it was to negotiate, either collectively bargaining or bargaining on my behalf.
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoPeople like to say skilled workers don't need unions but I never heard a convincing argument about why. Most of the fields I think of when I think of successful unions in the US are ones I consider skilled -teachers -electricians -carpenters -airline pilots -actors
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoOn your list are one group of government employees, three licensed industries and one of the last industries to still be dominated by a tightly knit cartel (the big Hollywood movie studios). Public sector unions are negotiating with a monopoly. In that sense they actually do something. The problem is that the monopoly is the government and then the union is a labor monopoly acting in opposition to the public rather than a capitalist private business. This is great for teachers but terrible for students and parents and taxpayers. The unions in licensed industries are unions because the law privileges unions, but in practice they're lobbying organizations. Your local electrician doesn't need a union to negotiate with you when you want a generator panel installed in your house. Their actual purpose is regulatory capture, and then you have the same problem as the teachers unions, e.g. the union lobbies to make it harder for people to become electricians to reduce competition to the detriment of prospective electricians and the general public who then has to pay more for the services of the people already in the club. And then Hollywood is a cartel in need of some antitrust enforcement, which is the one place where unions actually do something useful (but the better solution is still busting the trust).
- kelnos 5y ago> This is great for teachers but terrible for students and parents and taxpayers. Given how poorly public K-12 teachers are paid in the US, I don't think this is an accurate statement.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe average public school teacher salary in the US is $63,645. The US median personal income is $35,977. On top of that, public school teachers get pensions and other benefits not given to the median US worker. The idea that they're poorly compensated is a myth. They make more money than most of the people funding their salaries. On top of that, teachers unions cause all the usual non-monetary harms, like preventing teachers who deserve to be fired from being fired, or driving off eager young teachers with stale seniority rules.
- asdff 5y ago>The problem with unions is that skilled workers don't need them Entirely disagree. Unions for skilled workers would mean that when you go into surgery for a car accident the doctor who is putting you back together actually had a full night of sleep that day.