4 ms·
This is a case where the proposal is actually worse than the headline, I think. From a non-paywall source: https://calmatters.org/politics/2021/08/california-r
by sokoloff 5y ago
This is a case where the proposal is actually worse than the headline, I think.
From a non-paywall source: https://calmatters.org/politics/2021/08/california-recycling-single-use-plastic/ https://calmatters.org/politics/2021/08/california-recycling...
> Despite the best intentions of Californians who diligently try to recycle yogurt cups, berry containers and other packaging, it turns out that at least 85% of single-use plastics in the state do not actually get recycled. Instead, they wind up in the landfill.
The plastic resin is recyclable, but is not commonly recycled and this act seeks to remove the marks that serve to indicate the former because of the latter. I can’t see how that will increase recycling in CA, nor be likely to leave CA citizens nor environment better off.
- jffry 5y agoIf you've only read the headline, here's a mirror: https://archive.is/ma1Ob https://archive.is/ma1Ob The California legislature has appeared to take the non-recycling of most plastics into account: A majority of the state’s assembly members voted to ban companies from using the arrows symbol unless they can prove the material is in fact recycled in most California communities, and is used to make new products.
- elif 5y agoIt will decrease the number of plastic goods people buy under ecological pretexts. For instance, when I learned about plastic bottle recycling, I switched to canned water.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt will also lead to the landfilling of recyclable resins in communities where their waste management is capable to recycle them, which in turn will result in fewer communities adopting/adapting waste management practices to process these items properly because consumers won’t put them into that stream.
- lttlrck 5y agoI hadn't realized the numbers were that bad... https://oceana.org/blog/recycling-myth-month-plastic-bottle-you-thought-you-recycled-may-have-been-downcycled-instead https://oceana.org/blog/recycling-myth-month-plastic-bottle-...
- mikeryan 5y agoMost communities in the Bay Area at least have separate recycling and trash pickup bins. This isn’t to increase recycling it’s so the sorting is better and more efficient.
- burkaman 5y agoYou're misreading that quote. It's saying that Californians do put these things in recycling bins, but they aren't actually recyclable, so the recycling facilities have to send them to landfills. People are trying to recycle the wrong things because of the intentionally misleading resin identification codes, and California is trying to fix that.
- sokoloff 5y agoI don't think I am misreading it, but rather thinking about the holistic solution differently. The waste processing that the various CA communities have contracted for is not recycling those resins, even though they're capable to be recycled and being presented for recycling. That gives me the view that the most effective action is not an on-the-street "consumers, please put these into the landfill stream" but rather a "communities, please choose to upgrade waste management practices on the blue stream".
- burkaman 5y agoThe goal is not to get people to put them in the trash, the goal is to get companies to stop using them. Basically, ask companies to be more responsible vs. let them do whatever they want and ask communities to clean up after them. It is not ethical to label something as recyclable when that is theoretically possible, but not practically possible in 90-100% of the state.