8 ms·
Contributing to Wikipedia is not fun. If you create a new article, it's likely to get deleted for not meeting high "notability" criteria. Your first edits wil
by pornel 15y ago
Contributing to Wikipedia is not fun.
If you create a new article, it's likely to get deleted for not meeting high "notability" criteria.
Your first edits will likely end up being reverted for not having sources good enough. For overzealous admins it's easier to bin them rather than find a better source link or let someone else improve it.
- moultano 15y agoI haven't found that to be true at all, but maybe I'm editing different articles. I've gone through on a bunch of math topics that I know a fair bit about and reworded things to be understandable to someone not steeped in jargon and I've always gotten a positive or at least a neutral response.
- ColinWright 15y agoTweaking what's there isn't so bad. Anything substantial is rapidly punished unless perfect from the start.
- _delirium 15y agoMost of my editing is creating new short articles that are far from complete (often one or two paragraphs), and I haven't had problems. I do tend to cite at least one source per article, though (the place I got my info from). Is that the main reason? Or am I just lucky? Or choosing unproblematic areas? Occasionally someone or a bot slaps on a "this article is a stub" footer, but that doesn't really bug me. The one time I ran into trouble was a pretty edge case: my article on internet-meme rapper "Average Homeboy" was deleted, though it seems to now have been recreated. When I write articles on almost anything that isn't internet culture, there doesn't seem to be an army of evildoers looking to hassle me about them (say, on a CS theorem, castle in Greece, Prussian general, or a city hall in Minnesota).
- mclin 15y agoThanks! Way too often I find a math article jumps straight into the equations without a good overview that can be understood by someone without a math background. Example applications, for example, would greatly reduce the abstract nature of these pages. Here's an example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controllability http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controllability
- eru 15y agoDo you see that page as a good or bad example?
- mclin 15y agoWell, I'd seen the term 'Continuous Linear System' somewhere and came to this page, where it starts out as: Consider the continuous linear time-variant system <equations!> so, bad.
- ColinWright 15y agoIt's an encyclopedia, not a tutorial or textbook. It's not supposed to be something you learn from, but something you reference. What you want is something that would be more useful, but harder to produce.
- mclin 15y agoIt's not supposed to be something you learn from, but something you reference. Really? That's the exact opposite of how I think of it. An encyclopedia is something you learn an initial shallow understanding from. A field specific reference text is something you reference. eg. My linear algebra text book. For sure re usefulness, which is why moultano's work is greatly appreciated.
- jerrya 15y agoApart from the usual wikilawyers warring and reverting everything, I've also recently found lots of bots come by just to tag edits, which were correct, as possible vandalism, etc. Plus the problem mentioned in the article that it's no longer "okay" just to drop a url into an article, everything has to match some bizarro world template that no one would ever want to fill out given their lousy pay rates. And for all that, the wiki staff is too stupid/poor/unimaginative to automatically download and archive what the urls in the articles point to, meaning that the whole thing suffers from increasing amounts of link rot. It's also fun to contribute a new article and then see it nominated for swift deletion because it rubs someone the wrong way and has violated one of a trillion different little wiki policies all put up to justify reverting/deleting otherwise fine content.
- _delirium 15y agoThe template isn't as important as the source; if you drop an IEEE/ACM/jstor/Citeseer URL in lieu of a formatted citation, that's fine, and someone should fix it up later into the full journal citation. If it's a URL to a DailyKos diary or something, though, that's less useful.
- jerrya 15y agoI would claim you've got it skewed, especially for someone posting from Hacker News. Let me try and reformulate it: If you drop a URL in that's fine, one of our bots will come by, not to chastise your edit as possible vandalism, but to fill out the journal entry for you and download the url and archive it.
- Enlightenment 15y agoThe biggest problem with wikipedia edits are people NOT following the rules. People act like they can make CRAPPY edits in any way THEY like and then EXPECT those CRAPPY edits to stick. If you add a bunch of text WITHOUT a reference citation, then whine because someone deletes your text, then it is YOUR own fault for NOT adding a reference. Most people need to quit whining like a bunch of little girls and edit articles the correct way.
- yichi 15y agoAs an administrator on Wikipedia, I thought the Wikipedia notability criteria is quite leniant about articles which are not that notable, this is evident if you ever look at what kind of articles gets kept on [[WP:AFD]]. The reason notability criteria is there so not everyone can create an article about their band which sold 3 copies of their CD (edit: Which typically have no realiable sources indicating its existance). If the article you are creating was deleted for not meeting the notability criteria, it means you probably did not source it with a reliable source, and the administartor who deleted it could not find a reliable source about the article you were writing. If you think your article's deletion need to be reviewed, try contacting one of the admins, if your article was deleted by me I would be more than happy to tell you why I deleted it, and if I made a mistake I would not hestitate to revert the deletion.
- ramchip 15y ago> The reason notability criteria is there so not everyone can create an article about their band which sold 3 copies of their CD. I could see this being a problem if the band's name is ambiguous with existing, important articles. But if there's no conflict, how is that a bad thing? Perhaps it would encourage people to contribute more if Wikipedia is a little too lenient rather than a little too strict.
- yichi 15y agoBands which sold 3 copies of their CD tend to have no reliable sources indicating its existance even, with no sources, how is anyone able to ensure that it even exists? (Perhaps I should of reworded that). Notability criteria in a nutshell, basically means, the subject of the article needs to be mentioned by some reliable source. If we had no notability criteria, then we simply have no ways to ensure that the subject of the article exists or even real. Note: I'm pretty much summarizing what's on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:N http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:N If you think I'm biased, please read the policy directly on Wikipedia itself.
- cma 15y agoThat's an apologist revisionism take on what Wikipedia notability criteria is.
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoAnd good luck contributing edits to controversial topics (i.e. anything related to the big topics like the Middle East, religion, Pokemon etc.) where the same battles are fought over and over and over again in a war of attrition. The price of victory is eternal vigilance and an endless supply of fresh troops to reinforce your position.
- Florin_Andrei 15y agoWhy is Pokemon "controversial"? (disclaimer: I barely know what Pokemon is)
- SamReidHughes 15y agoSome people say the site lost its way when each kind of Pokemon didn't have its own Wikipedia page.
- scythe 15y agoIt's controversial because people get into arguments about it. He included it in the list because it's also trivial and silly, as a way of saying that Wikipedians get into arguments about trivial and silly things ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:LAME http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:LAME ). It's a joke of sorts.
- pyre 15y agoTrivial indeed: Are U2 an "Irish band" or simply a band that happen to be from Ireland, since two of their members were born in the UK
- wisty 15y agoThere's Keldeo, Meloetta, and Genesect - the missing Pokemon. They are only present on a Nintendo game, and only if you hack it. But they are vaporized, 1984-style, from the English Wikipedia; as they don't exist in the real Pokemon world. At least, that's what I can glean from 5 minutes on the discussion page here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_Pok%C3%A9mon_(599%E2%80%93646) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_Pok%C3%A9mon_(599%....
- gnosis 15y agoThere are actually many incredibly obscure articles that are created on Wikipedia which rightly deserve to be deleted for not meeting the pretty reasonable notability criteria. There are also way too many articles with either no sources at all or with really crappy or biased sources. If the articles are obscure enough, they often never even get challenged or deleted. Many of those that do get challenged or deleted deserve to be. The real problem comes in when articles which really are notable and information from sources which are credible get deleted for ideological, political, or other biased reasons (though, of course, the people doing the deletion will always claim otherwise). Wikipedia really has no good solution for this than letting the parties involved argue it out, or draw in more editors/admins (who have their own biases) in to the argument. What usually emerges from these arguments is not "neutrality" or "objectivity", but rather a biased point of view of those people who managed to out-Wikilawyer, outnumber, or outlast the other side.